A few honourable exceptions
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-03-07Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
Pamphlets from Socialist Build the 200 Club!
PRESISEGIANG
Psan and the Guardian apers as diverse as the have been playing a peculiarly tasteless and inappropriate little game: drawing up lists of "winners" and "losers" of the Gulf war.
Bush, Schwartzkopf, Major - even Kinnock and Ashdown, all had a "good war" . Saddam, Arafat, King Hussein, Tony Benn and Edward Heath all had a "bad war". The population of Baghdad and Kuwait City don't warrant a mention in this amusing little game, of course. Neither do the carbonised conscripts on the road from Kuwait to Basra.
One thing is for sure: few British journalists and no British papers come out of the war with much in the way of honour. The Sun and Star have been nauseating even by their own putrid standards. The mid-market tabloids rehashed Pentagon propaganda while denouncing the BBC and ITN as stooges of Saddam.
Telegraph editor Max Hastings popped up all over the place, arguing that the "duty" of the press was to "come on side" (ie. suspend all objectivity and criticism) tor the duration.
Then there were the more *sophisticated" commencators, with their "reluctant" justifications for the war. People like Hugo Young of the Guardian, Michael gnatieff of the Observer and the Independent on Sunday's Neal Ascherson: they were the "conscience" of the prowar lobby, serving up one hundred and one liberal platitudes all of which amounted to the old song "We don't want to fight/But by jingo if we do...
So let it be recorded that there were just a few honourable exceptions to the pro-war chorus in the press.
Three out of the five regular columnists on the Mirror opposed the war. Edward Pearce (who joined the Guardian from the Telegraph last year, amid complaints from Guardian readers that he was too right-wing) waged a tenacious anti-war camA Werkers" Liberty/Socialist Organiser pamphiet 75p he winner of the £100 draw for March is Caroline Henry from Sheffield.
Contributors to the *200 Club" pay E1, £5, E10 or E20 The analy: the Gulf u pence plus postage paign, denouncing allied hypocrisy and reminding us of the real cost of war, beneath the "mortal lawn mower" of the US bombers.
Of the reporters out in the Gulf, Marie Colvin of the Times deserves credit for writing truthfully about the Baghdad shelter bombing ('there was no evidence on the ground that this structure had a military purpose") and Robert Fisk of the Independent will be remembered for his consistently honest, detailed and moving reports. His despatches from Kuwait continue to be essential reading: last Monday Fisk described how he and Colin Smith of the Observer attempted to stop Kuwaiti 23, whatever towards our fund drive each month, and in return get an equivalent number of chances for a monthly draw prize of 100.
The fund drive is aiming a total of £25,000, through donations or through "200 Club" contributions which soldiers, watched by American troops, beating up a Palestinian boy: *When I asked the American officer why he allowed the Kuwaitis to beat civilians, he replied: 'You having a nice day? We don't want your sort around here with you dirty rumours. You have a big mouth. This is martial law, boy. Fuck off'" -Unfortunately, for every Robert Fisk there were a proved "line»,» toeing the ap- dozen hacks cooped up in the • And for every Edward Pearce there are two dozen saloon-bar warriors churning out propaganda from their air-conditioned offices in Wapping. They all had a very "good war" , of course.
USSR E1.20 plus 32p postage enable us to cover payments! a bank loan. Our total so far just over £15,000.
Donations to, and *200 Club" forms from, SO, PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA. And quickly, please: the pressure on our finances ting acute.
Scan page 7
Analysing events, promoting campaigns PAX Socialist Organiser No. 478 page 7
----- pull-quotes -----
IN GUL Issues in Lappur