Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Their new order

Socialist Organiser no. 478, 7 March 1991 · scan pp. 3–4 · about 1,229 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

In the Observer of 24 February, a military man wrote that never before in history had soldiers faced such concentrated bombing for so long. The nearest comparison he could find was from World War 2.

In 1944 a German unit suffered rwo and a half hours of continuous bombing. Many died, others went insane or killed themselves, and the rest were shattered and dazed. Much of the Iraqi army faced hours on hours of bombing for five weeks solid. It destroyed them.

As the Observer article pointed out, there are probably hundreds of thousands of psychological casualties to add to the tens of thousands massacred as the US-led coalition bombed and shelled the fleeing Iraqi troops.

Smart bombs, laser systems, and electronic gadgets won the Gulf war.

For centuries, it was a basic rule of warfare that technology and industrial strength brought victory. Gunpowder, and later the Maxim gun, enabled European powers and European colonists to conquer The emenin ом, не варисмо class is also the emancipation of all weincess distinctionwo sex or race."

KariMark Socialist Organiser 1514NA Newisdesk: nunn 1639 7965 Lakesimate for sepprist monday Editor: John O'Mahony Anted yu Trades threes a Eleabridge hersheved зеле пемфаре et imes Post Office nice done necessary eflecti the views of Socialist Organiser and are in —а ретвопей свроски imespmerherwise:

stater great empire:

Wars like have broken has enforced Vietnam's see ned to that rule. Now the US it again.

he US's rapid victory, and its horrific demonstration of the power of its military technology, will strengthen the hand of the Americans.

But they will not bring a new era of stable US world domination, a new "American Century" , or a new world order.

In Iraq, the best alternative for the US would be a stable pro-American puppet government, which could act as a watchdog for the whole region. It still seems. unlikely that the US can get it, even after its crushing victory.

The main forces vying to replace Saddam are Shiite Muslim fundamentalists in southern Iraq, Kurdish nationalists in northern Iraq, and the Iraqi Communist Party. None of them are the sort of people the US prefers to deal with. And if the US can find a compliant American-educated Iraqi general, how will that general keep control over the fundamentalists, the Kurds, and the Stalinists?

Triumph for the technology of mass murder does not do away with the political difficulties of establishing a stable colonial or semi-colonial regime in the modern post-colonial world. Iraq is not a country of dispersed peasant communities with small, easily-coopted landlord and comprador classes; it is a country with big cities, a sizeable working class, and a big middle class.

More likely than a stable puppet government in Iraq at present seems to be the conversion of the country into something like Lebanon - its division into segments ruled by rival warlords, Kurdish nationalists in the north, Shiite fundamentalists in the south, and so on, with, perhaps, a long-term US military presence in the south paralleling Israel's long-term military presence in southern Lebanon, George Bush he Americans will have made dozens of promises to the Arab governments which supported them, and dozens of contlicting promises to Israel.

They are more likely to keep the promises to Israel. Israel's most powerful military rival has been seen off. The Palestine Liberation Organisation has suffered huge diplomatic and financial damage from its alliance with Saddam Hussein. The Arab states will be more concerned to get aid to repair the economic damage they suffered from the war than to agitate for the Palestinians.

Long-term - over decades closer US involvement in policing the Middle East could drag the US into a position like that of Britain in the '30s and '40s, when Britain had colonial or semi-colonial rule over the Arabs of Egypt, Iraq, Jordan and Palestine and simultaneously allied with the Zionist community in Palestine.

Weight of numbers and economic interest finally pushed Britain towards more concessions to the Arabs. But similar pressures could take decades to sway the US, and much can happen in the meantime.

The US will have a rough ride as policeman of the Middle East. The victory of its technology is a terrible warning to any Middle Eastern (or other Third World) people contemplating revolt, but make it all-powerful.

Anger and hatred against the Americans because of their slaughter of tens of thousands of Iraqi civilians and soldiers will remain alight in the Middle East for decades to come. It will inspire revolts.

Unfortunately, the political trend best-placed to channel that revolt is Islamic fundamentalism. The US would prefer not to have to deal with the fundamentalists. Yet it has managed to deal with the Saudi fundamentalists, and will probably work out an adequate arrangement with the Iranian fundamentalists.

Since the USSR is no longer able to act as an alternative superpower, and Japan and Germany are not yet able to act as such, any fundamentalist regime in the Middle East which wants to do business in the world as it is will have to do business with the superpower, the US. It will have narrower options than the secular Arab nationalist regimes of the '50s and '60s, which could tack and turn between the US and the USSR.

The working class and the left, however, face only repression and exploitation from the fundamentalists. A further surge of fundamentalism will be much worse news for the working class than for US imperialism. State dance, hate the tis of ome groups of the Western left safe distance, hailed the rise of Islamic fundamentalism as a progressive (although distorted) anti-imperialist movement. A new rise of fundamentalism should force them to rethink.

If the secular nationalism of the Palestine Liberation Organisation is displaced, or ousted within the PLO itself, by Islamic fundamentalism, then the old formula of the PLO in the 1970s, "democratic secular Palestine" , will no longer be on offer.

The democratic secular Palestine" was always a misleading formula. Whether it was meant sincerely or as political window-dressing, it was defined by the fact that its premiss - the creation of a single Arab-dominated state Palestine, whether the Israeli Jews liked it or not — could be achieved only by military conquest of the area by the Arab states, by states such as Saddam Hussein's Iraq. In reality it could not be democratic.

Islamic fundamentalists will strip away all the window-dressing and all the naive good intentions. They have no time for democracy in any recognisable form, and certainly no time for secularism.

For them the answer is the slogan of the Arab chauvinists before 1967: "Drive the Jews into the sea". The left will have to define itself independently, as it did before 1967: neither for Israeli conquests, nor for Arab chauvinism, but for a socialist federation of the Middle East, with the right of self-determination for national Turn to page 7 Gillitoriad Brand Gi nham Bash VadiminDerer Terryntag Pron Jatin Hatiai (Uabna Por:

Black Sections)

Eric iNefffer iMP Dorpthy Macedo Joel Marino _bhn Mellroy John Nichbison Peter ToucheN Members of the Advisory Committee are drawn from a broad cross-section of the left who are opposed to the Labour Party's witch-hunt against Socialist Organiser. Views expressed in articles are the responsidinity.on the authors and mot if the Advispry Fattorial Board

Scan page 4

Socialist Organiser No. 478 page Military research on campus

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 478

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →