"PR can only help the bourgeoisie"
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-02-28Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 14
London called by the Committ to Stop War in the Gulf. Assemble 12.00, Embankment Sunday 3 March "Imperialism East and West", London SO educational. Details 071 639 7965 Monday 4 March Anti-war meeting, Brighton Exchange, 7.30. Speakers include Tony Benn and Bruce Kent Media Workers Against the War National Rally: Edward Pearce and John Pilger. 7.00, Central Hall, Westminster, E2.50 Wednesday 6 March "The fight for Lesbian and Gay Rights", , Liverpool SO meeting. 7.30, Room S26, Merseyside I Centre, Hardman St. Speaker Janine Booth Further Education Activists Conference. Manchester Poly, fom 11.00am. Contact Steve Mitchell on 071 272 8900 Labour Against the War nationa organising meeting. 7.30, Peace Pledge Union, Endsleigh St, London (opposite Euston tube). All Labour Party members welcome Thursday 7 March "The Gulf War", SO meeting. South Manchester College, 12.30 Manchester Campaign Against War in the Gulf meeting. Town Hall, 7.30 Friday 8 March International Women's Day action. Meet 5.00, Albert Embankment, march to St Thomas's Hospital to highlight health cuts. Vigil: 6-7 in Parliament Square. Women only Pergamon Press picket of Mirror building, Holborn, 12.30 Rally organised by Women Against War in the Gulf. Central Hall, Thank you for the T coverge you gave of the industrial struggle during the war from Sam's and my book, War and the International. A mistake has, however, crept into your final footnote.
It is not War and the International that is currently out of print, but its predecessor, Against the Stream, which sold out within a year of printing, and which Pluto promised to reprint, but have so far not come across with it.
Your correspondent (6 February) from the Socialist Society, who is so anxious to destroy the Labour Party's election chances on behalf of the Green Party, or any small Socialist party that might arise (the CPGB perhaps, that has been campaigning for proportional representation for years) challenges me to name disillusioned exTrotskyists who have now found a home in the Socialist Society, I don't like "naming names" much — we have had enough of it from witchhunters and Stalinists (who, incidentally, also from inside the unions have been moting this proportional representation stuff inside the Labour Party as well), but since your correspondent has implied that I am in the business of making false allegations, I will have to reply.
Two that spring to mind straightaway are John Palmer and Richard Kuper, apart from the clapped-out with the remark that it was "not something that he would like to put into the hands of young people coming into the movement"
Far more important than the fate of a particular book, however, is the fate of the whole future of the labour movement. It is not the task of socialists, in my opinion, to advise the bourgeoisie about the best methods of arranging elections within their state. Our task is to try to set up a totally different democracy — a democracy of the toilers.
Your correspondent seems to be indifferent to the fact that proportional representation systems almost invariably produce coalition governments (or, as we 'antiquarian' Trotskyists might put it, Popular Fronts). Some of these systems, far from increasing the hold of local labour institutions over their elected representatives, allow all the prospective MPs to be nominated in a vast list drawn up by the central office of the party in question.
Does your writer want to risk either of these?
He should also, in opinion, examine the origin of this sort of campaigning within the labour movement. The parties that have been so anxious to promote it have been the old Liberals, the Communist Party and now the Greens. All of these groups have shown themselves to be enemies of the Labour and trade union movement, who would not hesitate to wreck it entirely if their own sectarian ends and petty personal ambitions could be promoted.
For years the Communist Party has tried to push it, occasionally along with such stunts as "tactical voting" at the time when the Labour Party was faced with the threat of the right-wing splitoff of the Social Democrats, and the brief (let us hope Liberal revival a few years ago.
The motives of this organisation are inspired by its Popular Front policies and its dislike of pure labour movement politics, even social democratic ones [in the older, reformist, meaning of the term]. But left wing activists within the Labour Party should not be blinded by this anti-class propaganda.
A coalition government, backed by the Liberals, Which placed Kinnock in office would provide him with the ideal alibi for not doing anything at all to advance the cause of the working class — the usual argument of do you want the government to fall and let the Tories in again?' in a far more dangerous form.
Surely, socialists within the Labour Party should be arguing for the extension of the power of all the institutions of the labour movement, not lending support to the intrigues of its declared enemies.
Al Richardson South London