Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

George Bush must hate this Western

Socialist Organiser no. 477, 28 February 1991 · scan p. 13 · about 892 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 13 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 13

Boys Own images of fast planes and armoured trucks and tanks soldiers decked out like our comic book heroes and report from space in glowing terms that there may have been some casualties, and their numbers and their pain withheld Belinda Weaver reviews Dances with Wolves Hollywood sneered at Kevin Hoose or bore a lester.

with Wolves, a Western, for God's sake!

But with Academy Award nominations in the bag, and the public flocking to see it, he can sneer right back. He's made a hit.

Deservedly so, in my opinion. Yes, it's a bit long, and he overdoses on scenery, but it's nothing like the standard Western, with its stereotypes of bad Indian, good (civilised) white man. It's so determinedly on the side of the Indians that it almost overbalances, but with so many shameful Hollywood films to make up for, that's no bad thing.

Set in 1863, it's the story of John Dunbar (Costner), a cavalry lieutenant transferred from the butchery of the Civil War to the furthest frontier — Indian country — where he mans an outpost singlehanded. The local Indians are the Sioux, and Dunbar is eager to make contact. Unlike the other white men, he doesn't shoot on sight; he wants to know them, to see how they live.

Once he's met them, he's smitten. He goes all the way, living with them, dressing like them, turning his back on the world he came from, yet feeling conflicted when normal the Indians question him about the white man's intentions.

He knows the Sioux are doomed, yet he can't bring himself to warn them; he's still too loyal to his own race. But events eventually force his hand. He has to take sides.

It's all fairly credible. Dunbar's VO the mind has been achieved and independent thought incapable romance is not romance is not so much with the white woman, Stands with a Fist, white woman who's been raised by the tribe, as with the tribe itself. We see all the stages, from infatuation, through misunderstandings and longings, to acceptance and trust.

Infatuation certainly describes Dunbar's feelings, and it seems to cover Costner's as director as well., The Sioux are shown as the last word in harmony - with nature, with each other. When ugliness threatens, it comes from outside, in the shape of the warring Pawnees, who are movie-standard barbarians with punk hair-dos. (To punish them, Costner doesn't subtitle their speeches, the way he does for the Sioux. We have to imagine the evil talk for ourselves.)

Costner is a big enough star now to greenlight any project. It's nice to see him choosing Dances with Wolves instead of trash like Days of Thunder, one of Tom Cruise's free choices.

I wish Costner hadn't idolised the Sioux, though. He doesn't need to turn them into angels to win our sympathy. They deserved (and still deserve) justice, not because they were "perfect" , but simply because they were human beings, deserving of common humanity.

All the same, in the current warmongering climate, this film is extraordinary, preaching as it does its lessons of tolerance, trust, and solving questions peacefully rather than by land-grabbing and violence. George Bush must hate it, which makes another good reason to go and see it. of rising to take hold of brains of the people again.

but instead on News at Ten Liki you a WI you but like Masters of war Come you masters of war you that build the big guns you that build the death plan you that build all the bombs you that hide behind walls you that hide beind desks I just want you to know that see through your masks.

You that never done nothing but build to destroy you play with my world like it's your little toy you put a gun in my hand and you hide from my eyes and you turn and run farth when the fast bullets fl : a judas of old lie and deceive orld war can be won want me to believe I see through your eyes I see through your brai I see through the water runs down my drain.

You fasten all the triggers for the others to fire then you set back and watch while the death count gets higher you hide in your mansion while the young people's bloo flows out of their bodies buried in the mud.

You've thrown the worst that can ever be hurled fear to bring children into the world you're threatening my bal unborn and unnamed you ain't worth the blood runs in your veins.

How much do I know to talk out of turn you might say that I'm young you might say I'm unlearned but there's one thing I know though I'm younger than you: even Jesus would never forgiv what you do.

Let me ask you one question is your money that good? will it buy your forgiveness. do you think that it could? I think you will find, when your death takes its toll, all the money you made would never buy back your soul.

And I hope that you die and your death will come soon and I'll follow your casket on a pale afternoon and T'll watch while lowered your death bed I'll stand over your grave to make sure that you're dead.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 477

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →