Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Israeli socialists speak out against the Gulf wa The issues in this wa

Socialist Organiser no. 477, 28 February 1991 · scan pp. 10–11 · about 2,040 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

The Matzpen group (Revolutionary Communist League) in Israel - the only organised Trotskyist group in the Middle East - spells out the arguments against the blitzkrieg on Iraq Wsir, and following the hang ith the eruption of the war in the bombing of Iraq by the United States and her allies in the region, the Israeli government and the leadership of the Zionist left in Israel hurried to back the warlike designs of these powers.

This situation has been aggravated since the start of the missile attacks on Israeli population centres. Confronted with real fear the majority of the activists of the left lined up unanimously behind the plan seeking the elimination of Saddam Hussein and his regime.

All of a sudden, all the arguments for the need to prevent this war are forgotten. Moreover, the fact that the Palestinian national movement has been standing beside Iraq has provided a legitimation for withdrawal from the struggle against occupation, in something like a collective "punishment" of the Palestinian people.

Fear on the one hand, and political blindness on the other, have raised many questions linked with this war. We decided here to answer some of them in order to strengthen the activists of the Israeli protest movement.

What is the character of the Iraqi regime, and why has it occupied Kuwait?

The regime of the Iraqi Ba'ath, headed on state terror, which systematically and brutally suppresses all its opponents: the Kurdish national movement, the parties of the left, labour unions, and others. The regime's power derives from its ability to distribute the social wealth among three strata of the ruling class: the industrial bourgeoisie and the big landowners, the state and political bureaucracy (the Ba'ath system), and the military system. Although Saddam Hussein's regime has improved the Iraqi masses' standard of living, especially after the oil crisis of the "70s, this improvement was conditioned upon the elimination of basic civil and democratic rights.

The outbreak of the Iranian revolution set a significant turning point for this regime. The imperialist states, ie. the USA and Western Europe, saw in Iraq the only local factor able to stop the influence of the Shi'ite revolution on the region. Thus Iraq received enormous financial support from her regional allies at that time (Saudi Arabia, Kuwait, Egypt, and the Gulf Emirates) as well as from the Western powers (especially France, Germany, and Great Britain), in Saudi defence minister Prince Sultan bin Abdel-aziz with linked to their desire to stay in power order to equip herself with the most modern instruments of warfare and to open war against the Iran of Khomeini.

The Western powers and their allies calculated that it was worthwhile to turn Iraq into a regional military power, in spite of the fact that this would upset the balance of military power in the area; they saw themselves confronted with the dangers caused by the mesasge of the Iranian Shi'ite movement, a message which, at least in the initial phase, was anti-imperialist and directed against all "infidel": Zionists, the corrupt rulers in the Gulf, and others.

Saddam Hussein's regime, also fearing the influence of the fundamentalist movement upon the Shi'ite population of Iraq, fulfilled the allies' expectations and started a bloodsoaked war against Iran, a war which cost the lives of about one million, and ended only because of Iraq's inability to defeat Iran militarily.

At the end of the war (1988), Iraq was left with huge foreign debts to its various providers of weapons and finances, with a devastated economy, and with almost one million soldiers recruited to a military system, which - according to Western analysts — is one of the biggest and most modern in the world. (Here we have to point out that, until the occupation of Kuwait, Iraq continued to receive military aid, especially from the United States.)

In this situation of no-victory and nodefeat, and with Iraq having fulfilled her role in the war against Iran, her creditors felt that the time had come to demand the return of debts. Whenever a mercenary finishes a job, they turn their back on him and demand the full price for the military adventure.

The dynamics governing regimes of the Iraqi type forces it to maintain and justify its military system, although its role — to block the Iranian threat — already ceased to be practical, and this for the following reasons: the army is the regime's basic pillar; mass recruitment serves to cut down unemployment and provides the recruits' families with a regular income; keeping up a huge military system justifies the continuation of the emergency regime and the suppression of democratic rights caused by it.

In such a situation, the occupation of Kuwait was regarded an aim easy to achieve, legitimising and consolidating the dictatorious Iraqi regime, while at the same time eliminating one of its main creditors. Beyond the historical explanations, according to which the Iraqi Ba'ath regards Kuwait as a province extracted from Iraq by British imperialism (1922) in an artificial way, the act of occupation was not peformed in order to distribute the wealth owned by a few corrupt sheikhs among the Iraqi masses, neither has it come to "correct" the distortions introduced by imperialism at the beginning of the century. By occupying Kuwait, the Iraqi regime hoped to find a solution to three problems: the cancellation of her debts to Kuwait and to use the Kuwaiti oil to cover her budgetary deficit, to pressure for a raise of oil prices in the international market, and to justify the maintenance the system.

Is the occupation of Kuwait a legitimate act or a violation of Kuwaiti people's right for self-determination? Bis economic and political control over ritish imperialism, striving to maintain our region invented — in the concrete sense of the word - various states and nations: Kuwait, the Gulf Emirates, Jordan, and others. This was done by enthroning local effendis, and by controlling natural resources and relations of political power in the region. Also the establishment of the state of Israel has its origin in the imperialists' desire to consolidate their policy of conclude that the examination of the question of the occupation of Kuwait the basis of the Kuwa people's right for self-determination is an Historically, Kuwait belonged to Iraq. Her separation aimed first of all to facilitate control over this area rich in oil; the quantity of oil produced there surmounts the quantity produced in all of the present Iraqi territory. Ever since Iraqi independence there has not been one government which agreed to the artificial separation of Kuwait.

The Kuwaiti ruling class is and was the local representative of the multinational monopolies controlling extraction, refinement and marketing of the oil. The fact that the greater portion of Kuwaiti capital was invested outside the state borders, and outside the region, especially in the United States and Europe (in the form of investment in international companies and trusts, and petrodollars invested in Western banks) gives ample evidence of the parasitic character of this corrupt ruling class. The fact that, in spite of the expulsion of the ruling families from Kuwaiti territory, the state's capital has remained in their private accounts abroad is the best proof of the character of this state's ruling class and of its type of "patriotism" Here we have to add also that around 60% of the workforce in Kuwait is not of Kuwaiti origin, but composed of Palestinians, workers from East Asia, Pakistan, and India. The total Kuwaiti population amounts to It is difficult to speak of self-determination in the case of a people who live in a state which was invented artificially, and whose rulers make use of the natural resources in order to pile up private capital. Viewed from this angle, there is much justice to the Iraqi demand for the annexation of Kuwait.

However, as already explained above, Saddam Hussein's regime did not occupy Kuwait for the sake of the well-being of the Iraqi masses, and even less so for the sake of Arab unity.

From all this we have to conclude that the examination of the question of the tion of Kuwait on the basis of the Kuwaiti people's right for self-determination s in fact an interesting theoretical question, b it irrelevant for the understanding of the present war. Our opposition to the occupation of Kuwait is based on the principle that any step forward by the masses themselves, on the basis of democratic principles. Saddam Hussein's regime is far from representing the interests of the masses of his people, and even farther from representing the principles of democracy… So why, if in fact, did the United States and her allies start this war?

The question of Kuwaiti self-determination has been the fig-leaf used to cover up the real needs and aims of the West and its regional partners. It was not concern for the Kuwaiti people which led the United States to recruit all its military power against Iraq, but her and her allies economic, military and political interests:

• The need to control the world's energy resources is not the private interest of the few international companies which market the black gold. We are dealing here with the energy source which runs capitalist industry all over the world. Given the absence of cheaper alternative sources of energy, control of the oil is equivalent to control over the wheels of world economy. Seen in this context, the Western states, ie. the biggest consumers of the black liquid extracted from our region, have to do everything in their power in order to guarantee that the oil will arrive to the world's economic centres, regularly and for the lowest possible price. (We include here Japan among the Western states not because of her geographic location, but because of her being a capitalist state which shares the world's social wealth with West Europe and the USA.)

• The imperialist character of the Western states does not derive from their physical rule in the countries of the "Third World" nor, as in our case, in the Arab countries, but from their ability to decide what type of government is set up in these countries, and to control the capital accumulated from the local natural resources.

• Imperialism rules by supporting dictatorious regimes that represent the interests of a small minority of the population and strive to remain in power to continue to accumulate capital. Undermining these regimes is equivalent to the undermining of the imperialist states' ability to keep control over the oil. Moreover, the Arab states' capital originating from oil — and to a major part from the sale of oil to the Western countries — is not reinvested locally, but in the imperialist countries, because the Western economic centres provide better opportunities to save and increase capital. Of course there is one precondition to the friction-free circulation of this capital, ie. regional rulers who do not challenge the rules of this game.

• From all said so far, it is obvious that any imperialist interest necessarily infringes upon wealth and prosperity of the masses in our region. Any policy striving towards economic independence, regional development, elimination of poverty and ignorance, will go the expense of the imperialist companies control over the oil, to the expense of capital investment in the West, and will threaten the regimes serving imperialism.

• In addition to the reasons linked to the regional context, US-imperialist has found itself recently in one of the most severe economic crises it has known since the 1929 stock exchange crash. Therefore it attempts to prove itself in the international arena; proceeding with a strong hand against all types of "rebellious" regimes in the world, it hopes to consolidate its position as policeman of world capitalism. There is no doubt that the present war is underlining the fact that there are no Western states able to compete with US military power.

In the struggle against imperialism in our region we cannot remain neutral. Even if we oppose Saddam Hussein's regime, even if we demand the change of this blood-soaked

Scan page 11

N PERSPEC niser

----- pull-quotes -----

"divide and rule" in the area. 'From all this we

interesting theoretical question, but irrelevant, the understanding of the present war."

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 477

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →