Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Two peoples - two states For the Palestinians

Socialist Organiser no. 477, 28 February 1991 · scan pp. 3–4 · about 1,322 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

The Palestinian people are e from the Gulf war high on the list of losers.

The Palestinians living under Israeli occupation in the West Bank and Gaza have given solid and enthusiastic backing to Saddam Hussein. So has the Palestine Liberation Organisation (PLO).

The Palestinians have backed Saddam against the West. With diplomatic demurrals, they backed his annexation of Kuwait. They looked forward eagerly to the blows he promised to rain down on Israel, with troops, Scud missiles, and poison gas.

For the great majority of Palestinians, a new pan-Arab saviour, a new Nasser, had arisen, who would champion them and "liberate Palestine" Saddam would settle with Israel. The Palestinians' long and unequal struggle with Israel was about to be transformed.

It is being transformed, but for the worse. From this war, the Palestinians have so far reaped the bitter hostility of the Arab governments participating in the anti-Iraq coalition. They have forfeited rich subsidies from Saudi Arabia and the oil sheiks. They have suffered a crushing blow in the propaganda *The emecon она Warkg class is also the emancipation of all human beings without distinction of sex or race.

Karl Marx acint Organiser POM Br BZEN Gondon St 15M NA 4397966 Latestantel for seppris: Monday Editor: John O'Mahony Published by WL Publications Ltd, nO Box 234 London BE 5 INA Printed by Tridant Press, Edenbridge Registered acme new coppermer thr Host Office:

Articles do not necessarily reflect the views of Socialist Organiser and are in ареголей capecyaniess otherwise:

Stated war.

For years now Israel has been losing the world-wide propaganda war. Its savage tactics against the Palestinian intifada have provoked very widespread revulsion. Even Israel's US backers had distanced themselves more and more from the Israeli government, and were going along with calls for a peace conference and an Israeli settlement with the Palestinians.

Now the Palestinians are mired in Saddam Hussein's mud; Israel is a rehabilitated, albeit unofficial, member of the grand coalition. After the military power of Iraq has been destroyed, Israel will be the region's military superpower.

Non-combattant Israel, tacing indiscriminate Scud attacks with restraint, has won widespread sympathy; the Palestinian cheerleaders for Saddam (and even for Saddam's atrocities against Kuwaitis and Israelis) have forfeited much of the world sympathy their people had so belatedly won in the last few years.

For can the Palestinians hope that, nevertheless, the self-interest of the likely victors in the Gulf war will lead them to seek justice for the Palestinians.

The Arab governments may seek some progress in Palestine, but no reliance can be placed on them. On the contrary. Time and again the Arab rulers have betrayed - and massacred - the Palestinians.

They would like to eliminate Israel, but they know they can't. They would like a West Bank/Gaza Palestinian state in the Israelioccupied territories; but Israel under its present government, or any other government likely in the short term, simply will not agree to it, and the Arab rulers are "realists".

The US is likely to stand by Israel. American politics works by horse-trading and lobbying. Votegenerating campaign money from competing ethnic and other networks controls Congressional votes on important issues. The Jewish community is among the most powerful of the competing ethnic political groups; the pro-Israel lobby is one of the most determined and powerful in American politics. The Jewish community had been split for and against the existing Israeli government and its West Bank/Gaza policy. It is split no longer.

Even should Bush and his team of gung-ho imperialists sincerely want to impose a new and more rational blueprint on the Middle East, they would face tremendous resistance and difficulties inside American politics. The peculiar nature of American pseudodemocracy will make it cripplingly difficult for the US ruling class to pursue long-term enlightened and rational politics in the Middle East.

Given the prevailing attitudes on the left, it is necessary here to underline what we are, and are not, saying. It is not a matter of a "Jewish conspiracy" but of the American political system within which the Zionist lobby works, as other ethnic-political associations work: for example, the Irish lobby was powerful enough in 1920 to get a resolution recognising the Irish Republic, fighting a war with Britain, through the House of Representatives.

The pressures and realpolitik of today will impel Bush to "punish" the Palestinians and destroy the PLO, In the immediately foreseeable future, the Palestinians stand to lose on all fronts.

This makes it all the more necessary that the serious left should raise the question of the rights of the Palestinians, and insistently advocate the only possible democratic solution to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict: two states for the two peoples.

Socialist Organiser has argued against those on the left who deny Israel's right to exist because it illtreats and oppresses the Palestinians. Israel's right to exist, we have insisted, cannot be conferred or denied according to what we think of the Israelis' behaviour Equally, the right of the Palestinians to self-determination in their own state cannot and should not depend on their "good behaviour"!

In 1948 the Palestinians backed the Arab armies which invaded the newly-independent state of Israel. For nearly 20 years after that, they all but disappeared as a political entity. Their organisations looked to the Arab governments, especially Nasser's Egypt, to solve their problems.

*What Yasser Arafat - with the backing of Palestinian public opinion, it seems — has done with his reliance Saddam Hussein is to destroy all that and turn th Palestinian political clock back 23 years to the days of stark dependency on such as Nasser. The price that the enemies of the PLO and Palestinians will try to extract will be a terrible one.

Only when those governments had been humiliated by Israel in the June 1967 war did the PLO begin to act as an independent force, the Palestinians to gain something like political autonomy.

Desperate Palestinian terrorism and many disasters — in Jordan, in Lebanon — followed. Four years ago, a mass people's resistance erupted in the occupied territories. It put militarily-powerful Israel on the political and moral defensive.

What Yasser Arafai - with the backing of Palestinian public opinion, it seems - has done with his reliance on Saddam Hussein is to destroy all that and turn the Palestinian political clock back 23 years to the days of stark dependency on such as Nasser. The price that the enemies of the PLO and the Palestinians will try to exact will be a terrible one.

But, to repeat, right to self-determination cannot be cancelled out by the criminal foolishness of their bourgeois leaders — not now, any more than in the '30s and '40s.

The left must defend the Palestinians. It will not be able to defend the Palestinians if it persists in its long-time advocacy of the most boneheaded and bloodthirsty Arab irredentism, with denial of the right of the Jewish state to exist at its centre.

Irredentism — the drive by a nation to annex and grab outlying territories and enclaves in its sphere — cannot be squared with socialism or democracy. It means suppression of minorities and insoluble, unending conflicts between neighbouring nations. Israeli irredentism is reactionary; so is Arab irredentism.

In the period ahead, such politics will be not only wrong in principle, but also suicidally stupid in terms of the realities the Palestinians are likely to face.

It must be two states for the [WO peoples: self-determination for both the Israeli Jews and the Palestinian Arabs.

Ark/nsory Grahem Bash Vladimir Derer Terry Engleton latin Hariar (Labore Patr lack Sections)

Eric Weffer MP prothyaMacero per Martno Wolmevichror John icho com Peter latchell Mambers of the Advisory Committee are drawn from a broad cross-section of the eft who are opposed to the Labour Par s witch-hunt againsu Bocinlist ganiser. iMes expressed in noticies ere M MI the Advisory prial Board, the authorsand impt of the Advisory cortoriar boara.

Scan page 4

Organiser

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 477

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →