Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The weird history of Socialist Action VOTE Socialist Unitu

Socialist Organiser no. 476, 21 February 1991 · scan pp. 14–15 · about 1,755 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 14

"Why we orient to the labour Huddersfield Poly SO meeting: to Stop War in the Gulf anti-war mobilisations, manage to get to the centre of the Committee? (The Committee's secretary, Carol Turner, is a Socialist Action supporter). And, having got there, why does it joir in a purge against those sharing its own polic of support for Iraq in the Gulf war?

It is a long story, and there isn't space for it all here. Even a short outline has to go back to 1971, when John Ross, the chiel ideologue of Socialist Acti today, joined the International Marxist Group.

The IMG was a small, dim group. Its chief distinguishing thought was enthusiastic speculation about the revolutionary Anti-war meeting, West Sussex Institute, 7.00.

Cardiff anti-war benefit. 12 bands at Bogey's nighclub, 8.00-1.00 Friday 22 February Ireland: Geoff Bell debates Austen Morgan. Jacksons Lane Community Centre, 271 Archway Road, Londo N6, 7.30. Organised by Pluto Books North West Labour Against the War meeting. Manchester Town Hall, 7.30. Speakers include Eddie Newman MEP, Mike Hindley MEP, Cate Murphy CND Lobby of Parliament Against the Gulf War Saturday 23 February Sheffield Socialist Organiser d school: "Gulf war: the issues f socialists", 12.00-5.00, Poly Student Union Upper Heyford anti-war demonstration. Assemble 11.00; Lower Heyford Railway Station Sunday 24 February the Vietnam Solidarity Cam paign, and, like all the left groups, it had grown in the agitation of the late '60s.

But it was floundering. It was narrowly student-based, at a time when industrial militancy was rising. It was involved in, or ran, a vast range of campaigns, none of which ever seemed to come to much.

And then came Ross. A student at Oxford University, he had been a Maoist and then a *bright young thing" in the SWP (then called IS). In fact -though he denies it — he joined the IS as a scout for Reg Birch's Maoist group - and stayed! During a spell in hospital he was recruited to the IMG. Gathering around himself a group of students and exstudents who likewise fancied themselves as intellectuals, he movement", , London SO educational. Details 071 7965 Monday 25 February Socialist Organiser London Forum "Lesbian and gay liberation: the socialist agenda". LSE, Houghton St, 7.30. Speakers include Peter Tatchell, Janine Booth (NUS Women's Officer), Jon Johnson (Rouge)

Tuesday 26 February Southwark Labour Against the War, Peckham Town Hall, 7.30. Speakers include Dawn Primarolo MP, Alice Mahon MP, Gavin Strang MP Wednesday 27 February Anti-war lobby of the TUC Assemble 8.15, Congress House, Gt Russell St, London. Called by NUJ Book Branch Manchester Poly SO meeting: "Israel, Palestine and the Gulf war", , lunchtime. Speaker John O'Mahony Manchester University SO meeting "Israel, Palestine and the Gulf war", 3.00. Speaker John O'Mahony Thursday 28 February The IMG's members reoriented to industrial struggles, using social-security advice through Claimants' Unions as their means to make contact, avoiding conflict with militants by avoiding "calls to action" and making general propaganda.

The "new thinking" worked as a means for reorienting and managing the group - or at least it worked for a short while. In the summer of 1972 Uganda expelled its Asian community. The Tory government honoured the Asians' British passports and admitted them Britain. There was a racist backlash. The IMG's paper commented: "Asians: Big Chance for Left"

The reasoning was that the racist backlash created a big need for general socialist propaganda. (Analogy - "Black Death: Big Chance for Doctors").

"Where we stand", : 1.00. Speaker John O'Mahony Bradford University SO meeting: "Where we stand", ", 5.00. Speaker John O'Mahony "Israel, Palestine and the Gulf War" , Leeds SO meeting, 7.30, Packhorse Pub, Woodhouse Lane. Speaker John O'Mahony Lancaster University SO meeting: "Israel, Palestine and the Gulf war", 1.00. Speaker Mark Sandel Newcastle Poly SO meeting: *Capitalism, socialism and war 12.30 Nottingham SO meeting: "Why students should oppose the Gulf war" : 8.00, International Centre, Mansfield Road. Speaker Mark Sandell Friday 1 March Sheffield University SO meeting: "Where we stand", 12.00. Speak John O'Mahony "George Fox and Millinarianism", 6.30, Friends Meeting House, Euston, London. Speaker Christopher Hill Saturday 2 March Workers Liberty dayschool, St Mary's Centre, Middlesbrough, 11.00 start Anti-war demonstration in London called by the Committee 1979: Revolutionary defeatism?

At this time many of Ross's former allies rebelled. Over the next few months a big opposition developed in the IMG.

Its chief agitation was for the IMG to adopt the "call to action" General Strike to kick the Tories Out! This was a commonplace slogan of the left in those days of high industrial militancy against the Tory government; and, in my view, confused slogan too. Nevertheless it gave the anti-Ross fac tion a clear and unmistakeable banner.

Ross responded by outflanking the opposition. In early 1973 he took up General Srike to kick the Tories out! as his own slogan, and started denouncing the opposition for their "social-democratic" misunderstanding of it!

Only in a group where the a tivists' basic Marxist education and critical faculties had been first softened by the years of speculation about the "world revolutionary process", then overwhelmed by hundreds of pages of philosophical mumbojumbo about the "new thinking", could this bizarre turn have been possible. Only in such a group could Ross's com bination of manic energy, low ingenuity, high pretence, and utter shamelessness in the use and abuse of ideas have qualified him for leadership.

That tura set the pattern for 12 years or so. Constantly stealing marches on an increasingly punch-drunk but usually uproarious opposition, Ross led the group through a series of wild political cavortings.

By the time the miners' strik in 1984-85 the faction-fighting had become more complicated As well as the "traditional" anti-Rossite opposition there was a new faction, co-thinkers of the Socialist Workers Party in the USA (no relation to the SWP-Britain), whose chief plank was political identification with a new leadership of the world revolution" to be found in Sandinistas, the Cuban government, and the ANC The "traditional" oppos Insisted on some critical distance from those forces, stressed more serious work dlxa.....

the Labour Party. (After being largely sidelined by the big Labour Party struggles of 1979-81 — in the 1979 election campaign it ran, jointly with some smaller groups, a slate of anti-Labour candidates called Socialist Unity - the IMG had dissolved and regrouped around a newspaper in the Labour Party, Socialist Action).

Ross's faction maintained control by tacking between the two other factions, allying first with one and then with the other. Then he outflanked then both, simultaneously.

He insisted on 100% -uncritical support of Scargill in the miners' strike, and declared that the miners leadership was part of a new class-struggle vanguard worldwide, together with the ANC, the Sandinistas, and various Labour left groupings (Black Sections, Women's Action Committee, Campaign Group of MPs). Thus he could be more pro-Sandinista than th SWP co-thinkers and more Labour Party oriented that the other opposition!

This ideological manoeuvre did not hold the group togethe but it did enable Ross to keep control of Socialist Action whil the two oppositions flaked awa - the SWP co-thinkers to forr the Communist League, and th traditional opposition to launcl International, then Socialist Outlook.

There is some justice in politics, and Socialist Action has declined from a weekly paper to a thin magazine published about four times a year. Ross has rallied the grou by declaring that the decline is not a decline. On the contrary, Socialist Action has broken away from the sectarian fringe of polities and is into the big time.

Motivated by its new ideology, the group round Socialist Action, now very small, has squirrelled its way into many leading positions in the ancillary staff of the broader Labour left. Carol Turner, for example, is secretary of Labour CND, that gave her the basis to become secretary of the Committee to Stop War in Gulf.

The reformist and aides-de-camp, and no-one fills those jobs better than revolutionaries possessed by an inner vision which tells them that the reformist campaign is, in its secret essence, the stuff of revolution. Labour Briefing did the quartermaster work for Ken Livingstone and the local government left in the early '80s, motivated by one such inner vision; now Socialist Action, motivated by another, does, for example, the production and distribution of Campaign Group News for the Campaign Group of MPS.

Socialist Action's role in the anti-war movement marks the reductio ad absurdum of this latest Rossite ideology. Their pursuit of centre place in the Committee - which their inner vision tells them is the centre of revolutionary polities, despite such profane details as its support for sanctions and its equivocation on the US-British military presence in the Gulf has led them to outlaw their own professed opinions on IraqHow they can extricate themselves from this latest fiasco or indeed whether they can at all - we shall see.

The whole bizarre history is lesson on the need to build a Marxist left wing in the labour movement based on clear ideas and strict political accounting.

In their outward form, the IMG and Socialist Action have been attempts to build such a left wing. In reality they have been the opposite; to borrow image from nuclear physics, they have been the antimatter" of Marxist politics.

A Marxist left wing is the memory of the labour movement. Activists grouped together only organisationally, without a theoretical basis, have only their individual experience to go on; they lack the discipline of having to spell out. collective ideas at each stage, compare what's said today to what's been said in the past, analyse mistakes, learn lessons; they are easily swayed by the ebbs and flows of amorphous left opinion.

Far from being an antidote, contribution to forming a continuous memory, the Ross grouping has worked to wipe out even such consistent memory as honest and serious individuals without theoretical baggage or the aid of a collective might have.

All the twists and turns, fros the "new thinking" in 1971 to the latest gambit, have been basically bright ideas for organisational advantage. And the theoretical uproar surrounding them has served not to put the gambits in broad context, or to provide a framework for evaluating them, but to obscure, thwart and derail even the most elementary common-sense practical evaluation.

Instead of theory illuminating practice, and practice checking and exposing errors in theory, theory has been subordinated to perceived practical advantage, and practical judgement subordinated to manufactured theoretical mumbo-jumbo.

Scan page 15

IND niser

----- pull-quotes -----

WHAT'S ON Thursday 21

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 476

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →