[Matt Cooper accuses me (Letters, SO474) Bof echoing…]
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-02-21Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 11
Matt Cooper accuses me (Letters, SO474) Bof echoing "the media assault on Saddam as an eco-terrorist" in my article, "The Gulf War: the Environmental Threat"
My article is further accused of "like the media generally, communicating] as much by which (sic) omits as by what it includes"
Unfortunately, Matt has completely failed to realise that the article was about one particular environmental threat, namely the danger that would ensue if Saddam's retreating army were to set fire to the Kuwaiti oil wells. It may be that he only read the headline which did give a misleading impression. My chosen title was "Keep the Oil Fires Burning..."
The article relies extensively on the theories of leading CND member Dr John Cox and of the climatologists who originated the theory of the "nuclear winter" '. None of these can be said to echo the aforesaid media assault.
Nor are these theories scaremongering. My article is careful to dismiss the more doomladen scenarii of King Hussein and the Green Party while pointing out that Met Office studies bear out the predictions of climatic dislocations affecting agriculture in the Indian subcontinent. The British government is funding research into how Indian farmers could respond to this danger.
As far as the TV coverage of the oiling of sea birds in the Gulf is concerned, I don't see how we in SO can do much more than we already have, which is to point out that the birds shown were not the victims of deliberate pollution (though such victims there surely will be and to criticise TV for ignoring the human casualties of the bombing.
This was done prominently next to my article as well as elsewhere.
It is true that I did not mention the bombing of Iraq's nuclear reactors or indeed of its chemical weapons plants. The article was about one thing only, the consequences of oil well fires. As readers of my column will know, I have written extensively on pollution around nuclear plants, whether through "normal operation" or during accidents, and have also written on chemical weapons and their effects. As soon as I get any information on the bombing of these plants, I will certainly relay it to SO readers but I would rather not indulge in speculation.
Incidentally, I note Matt's assertion that to bomb nuclear and chemical weapon plants would be a war crime if dangerous material were released to the detriment of the civilian population. 1 have no evidence that this has occurred and neither, I imagine, has Matt. I wonder, if I were to suggest it might be some sort of crime to build chemical weapons plants, might be accused of echoing the media assault on Saddam.
Les Hearn Croydon Victim of a chemical bomb attack during Iran-Iraq war. Les Hearn: "I have written extensively on the effects of chemical weapons."