Fact: passive smoking makes you
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-02-21Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
Hearn's COLUMN Hard on the heels of evidence that passive smoking causes much more illness than was originally thought comes a landmark legal ruling in Australia.
For the first time in the world, it seems, a court has declared that exposure to cigarette smoke leads to certain diseases.
The case started five years ago when the Australian Federation of Consumer Organisations (AFCO) took exception to a newspaper advertisement from the Tobacco Institute of Australia (TIA). Court proceedings lasted 2½ years. The ad, appearing in 14 newspapers, claimed there was "little evidence and nothing which proves scientifically that cigarette smoke causes disease in nonsmokers"
Despite complaints by AFCO, this wording was not changed and so they began proceedings under the Trade Practices Act.
AFCO tabled over 300 reports, chiefly those on the effects of passive smoking published by the US Surgeon General, the US National Research Council, the National Health and Medical Research Council of Australia and the Froggatt inquiry into health and smoking in Britain.
TIA witnesses question the design and methods of some of the reports and asked whether "statistical significance" of data from epidemiological studies could be equated with legal proof.
This has been a problem before in legal cases. Briefly, the question is whether, if a survey shows that, for instance, children of smokers are more prone to suffer from asthma, it can be said that passive smoking causes asthma. It is perhaps even more difficult to say whether a particular case of asthma has been caused by passive smoking. Clearly, asthma occurs in the absence of smoking.
This line of argument is an old one, and not only for the tobacco industry. Epidemiological studies have shown a link between lung cancer and smoking. Is it the case, as the tobacco lobby used to say, that this was a coincidence or that people prone to get lung cancer for some reason liked to smoke!
This is not as ridiculous as it seems. People working in dusty, polluting jobs tended to smoke more heavily, perhaps for relief from stress, or for "cultural reasons" More exact studies, allowing for such factors, provided the evidence that lung cancer and many other ailments were far higher in all groups of smokers than in similar groups of non-smokers.
Thus the TIA were on shaky ground, particularly since it would be difficult to argue that people chose to be passive smokers.
The judge, Trevor Morling, agreed with cancer expert Professor Sir Richard Doll from the University of Oxford that statistical significance was a guide. Lack of it was a sign for caution, rather than an indication of disproof, Passive smoking studies are full of problems such as the difficulty in establishing how much smoke had been inflicted on the subjects/ victims. However, Morling agreed that the overall pattern emerging from such studies was clear.
His conclusions were as follows:
• There is overwhelming evidence" that passive smoking triggers asthma attacks and diseases of the respiratory tract in chidren.
Scan page 11
BIANS Socialist Organiser No. 476 page 11