Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Neal Ascherson: "we have to choose between greater and lesser evils The poverty of liberalism

Socialist Organiser no. 476, 21 February 1991 · scan p. 10 · Patrick Murphy · about 1,093 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

strong record as critic of British national chauvinism, the hypocrisy at the heart of parliamentary government and imperialist pretensions. Despite the strength of that current in Scottish socialism he has been an inveterate opponent of Stalinism and a champion of national rights in Eastern Europe

His support for the Gulf war is not so predictable but his logic corroborates that of

many on the Labour "soft left'. The quote above is startling because it is clear that he appreciates the likely outcome and yet still The costs of fighting him are very great; a brutal and indiscriminate war whose The core of his argument is firstly that there is simply no alternative and, secondly; bill in blood will be paid mostly by that Saddam's growing power and conquests civilians and helpless conscripts; a pro-imperialist domination, Israeli regional which will try to impose a new Western supremacy and the horrors of war. "Even hegemony over the Middle East and revolutionaries" , he mourns, "have to which will leave Israel as the unchalleng- choose between greater and lesser evils and ed regional superpower. Yet even these contemplate alliances with power structures things are less terrible than leaving intact Saddam's conquests and power to conquer." So says Neal Ascherson in the InLiberals have got the issue of the war all wrong with, as far as I can see, no excuse. There is little that is unique about this war and no-one has attempted to define with determination the comparison with Hitler. (Ascherson, again unDespite the 'agonies' of self-doubt liberal commentators insist on putting themselves characteristically, simply asserts it and makes and the rest of us through, they are the in- no attempt even to explain why Saddam is obviously a greater danger than imperialism. heritors of a less than proud tradition. Good, internationalist, democratic commentators in Fundamentally, however, they are paralyspeacetime have, with monotonous regularity ed by the limits of their own politics. Liberals and predictability, supported wars 'once they have started' (always the time when opposi- that shakes the power structures that cause wars." "We have to mobilise all opposition to the war and try own rulers, commentators on the excesses of are, and have always been, critics of their tion is most difficult, takes most courage and capitalism, observers of, rather than participants in, great struggles. The idea of their being a serious alternative to capitalism, a It is only polite to agonise and show customary reluctance in public first. The vic- different way to organise relations between peoples (within as well as between nations) is simply not on their agenda. The only choice is between existing ruling classes, there can be no other - that is the basic conservatism at Wars waged by imperialist powers can be opposed when there is something in the enemy to support or encourage; the Vietnamese should govern themselves, the Egyptians should control their own Suez Canal, There is nothing to support in Saddam Hussein. The choice in the real world, the only world, is no choice. Saddam is a brutal dictator, the West plan regional domination — where is there for a liberal to hide? Most are hiding in the same bunker - built on lesser evils and realpolitik. The coalition are at least democratic (not true of most of its members), Iraq started the conflict with an aggressive act, the UN endorsed the action - hence war There is, perhaps, no alternative if your highest aim is to critically advise capitalism. how to rule more wisely, humanely, democratically. There is an alternative only if our aim is to mobilise the variously-inspired opposition to war and try to turn it into a force that shakes the power structures that It matters very much, however, who defeats Saddam and who rules the roost after the war. The European order after fascism could have been settled by working-class, democratic forces had revolutions against the right proceeded differently in Spain and France in particular. As it was, US capitalism and Stalinism carved up the continent and from there shaped much of the post-war world. The forces for a democratic working-class social order were there, but they needed political ideas, answers to great questions of tactics and principles, and, above all, their political independence to act This is the indispensible armoury of a force with no great weapons of destruction, defined by its lack of control over wealth and power. To write this force out of events, or to insist on tying it to existing ruling classes, especially when great wars occur between rival gangsters, is to doom humanity to a cycle of such wars and such hopeless choices.

world which cannot stand up to Alill soon become unhabitable will soon become unhabitable. dependent on Sunday.

Neal Ascherson illustrates a liberal intelligentsia' support Gulf. would make most difference). point. Most war in the tims of such wars, short main sadly oblivious to some of the warmongers. and long-term, the reluctance Ascherson, however, sadder fact which the lei a left-wing Scottish n

long before it became fashionable.

supports the war. they hope ultimately to overthrow". example Id registe ist he l the heart of liberalism.

• There is "compelling scientific evidence" that cigarette smoke causes lung cancer in non-smokers.

etc.

• There is "more than a little evidence" that other people's smoke causes "glue ear" in children, a condition that can cause deafness if not detected and treated early enough.

• The statement by the TIA was likely to mislead smokers and non-smokers on the effects of smoking.

He granted an injunction is just...but only just! against repetition of the advert.

Morling did not comment on the evidence that passive smoking can endanger a foetus. If he had, the ruling would be subject to the legal challenge that foetuses cannot read and would therefore not be misled by a newspaper cause wars advert!

The ruling could make it much more difficult for employers, restaura teurs, pub owners and others to avoid legal action if they allow their employees or customers to be exposed to other people's smoke.

Ten years on (and on)

It doesn't seem possible, does it? An article about science, health or the environment in nearly every issue of SO for the last decade, covering in their own right. anything from outer space to nuclear physics, lung cancer to wind power. If you have enjoyed or learnt anything from these, perhaps you might send a bit extra to SO's latest fund-raising scheme.

----- pull-quotes -----

are a greater evil than (presumably) Western bably botched settlement' afterwards

HE POLITICAL FRONT

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 476

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →