Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The fire last time

Socialist Organiser no. 476, 21 February 1991 · scan pp. 8–10 · about 2,244 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

The spectre of the Vietnam War is haunting Washington. The fear of internal division and the unleashing of huge anti-war struggles is haunting the USA, once again at war.

The Vietnam War was the greatest evil for a whole generation of American youth. In an attempt to prevent the unification of South and North Vietnam under Stalinist control, the Americans launched a brutal and crushing war. They subjected North Vietnam to massive aerial bombardment and forcibly removed millions of Vietnamese civilians to concentration camps.

The Americans used toxic weapons such as napalm, and defoliated whole jungles by spraying them with "Agent Orange" , which poisoned crops and people. People are still dying from its effects, and generating deformed children because of it. The Americans committed acts of the most appalling brutality, such as the massacre of unarmed villages. The massacre at My Lai is the best documented example.

President Lyndon Johnson administered this death and destruction, and his words then have been parroted today by Bush. Bush too fears being judged a coward, an unmanly man. A man without a spine...a traitor, a weakling."

The label murderer is perhaps a more precise description of what Johnson was. That is what millions of Americans came to think Johnson and his successor, Nixon, were. They made that label stick by building a broad anti-war movement that could not be ignored.

That is what we must do to the mass murderers Bush and his stooge, Prime Minister John Major. We must build a mass anti-war movement.

But, as Marxists, our task is even greater: we must seize the opportunity offered to the left by anti-war radicalisation and transform it — or much of it - into a revolutionary anti-capitalist offensive at home.

The Vietnam War is instructive on this. The politics of that anti-war movement May 1968, Paris deserve our attention.

The Vietnam War shook up the whole of Western society and created an unprecedented international anti-war movement of great strength. At first demonstrations were small, the protests a vociferous minority, but as war dragged on and the senseless killing continued the movement grew in scale and developed politically. Eventually the anti-war protests began to overspill into the rest of society, affecting other social issues.

he rebellion against the war had begun with students in America faced with conscription into fighting "Johnson's war". National protests were organised from the beginning by groups such as Students for a Democratic Society.

But it was not only America where the student population organised against the war. There was street fighting in Japan against the "King's campaign used the glaring inequality of the black/white death ratios in Vietnam to illustrate the terrible latte day social cannibalism with which American capitalist society treated its black people."

American use of Japanese military bases, a famous student occupation at the LSE in London, and student protests in Italy, Spain and France.

In turn, the example of students acting against the war inspired students all over the world into political activism — and not only about Vietnam. 1968 saw a strong surge of anti-establishment student protest in neo- Stalinist Poland.

Bubbling beneath these protests of - on the whole — a middle class privileged group of young people, there were even greater antagonisms contained and straitjacketed for decades. War and the radical student response brought these issues explicitly to the surface.

1968 saw the radicalisation of other, and independent streams of revolt and protest converging with the anti-war movement -for example, the movement for black civil rights and against America's own "apartheid system" , a movement which had been gathering strength and militancy since the mid-'50s.

In addition, the modern feminist movement was born in the spirit of equal rights for all people. And in May 1968 there was the largest general strike in the history of our movement in France, detonated by student action.

The war focused a mass movement of idealistic youth fighting for liberation politics, and bearing great hopes for a different world. The campaigns that emerged from the Vietnam syndrome saw themselves as libertarian and anti-establishment on a world-wide scale.

he American black civil rights movement was a rebellion against America's deep and ingrained racist attitudes and institutions. Martin Luther King attempted to channel the alienation of black people living in American ghettoes into a huge movement of non-violent disobedience.

large-scale rebellions which left many dead. It was an immense modern slave revolt in the very heart of capitalism. Great fires gutted the heart of some of the most prosperous cities of the most prosperous country on earth.

New radical black leaders emerged, like the Black Panthers, who took on the racist terror-mongering US cops and defended the ghettoes, gun in hand.

As the Vietnam War dragged on, King's stand became more radical. He drew out the links between war and poverty. Motivated by Christianity, King was nevertheless a committed fighter for social justice and he launched the poor people's campaign against poverty. King's campaign was a universal campaign against poverty and for equal rights for all people. It used the glaring inequality of the black/white death ratios in Vietnam to illustrate the terrible latter-day social cannibalism with which American capitalist society treated its black people.

Is the world-wide movement with VietAit absorbed other currents, and not only it absorbed other currents, and not only from the black movement in the USA.

The modern feminist movement was born in the spirit of equal rights for all people. The left itself was deeply ingrained with male chauvinist and sexist ideas; sexual liberation — the great slogan of the '60s — was itself sometimes a cloak for the traditional abuse by men of women within relationships. Women fought hard against the sexism of the left and for their own equal place inside the movement. Women considered themselves to

Scan page 9

Vietnam war movement be part of the general movement for liberation, part of an "all people's movement" for equality and the end of oppression. Socialist feminism chimed with these times of mass mobilisation and radical protest.

he high point of this great spreading flood tide of rebellion came in May 1968, with the giant general strike of nine million workers in France.

Students confronted the French government in protest against cuts, and against the decrepit state of French education. Inspired by Vietnam they built barricades and took on the notoriously violent head-cracking and gun wielding special police, the CRS. Big battles took place on the 'Night of the Barricades', May 10th. The students occupied the Sorbonne. - Suddenly the French working class followed the lead of the students: all across France, ignoring the official Stalinist labour movement leaders, they occupied the factories!

Despite the official unions' attempts to contain the strikes and limit demands, the strikes quickly generated a political threat to the state. Workers' defence was widely organised, democratic structures governed the organisation of occupations and democratic committees of students and workers organised the distribution of food.

Meetings demanded a minimum wage, a pension at 60, a forty-hour week, payment for the strike period, and ended with the singing of the Internationale.

More ominous for the French ruling class was the refusal by many workers to demand anything at all! Workers occupying a Citroen factory defied management pleas to come up with some demands; instead management were left with silence for some days. Plainly, the workers wanted more than a better deal with the bosses.

The then immensely powerful French Communist Party strove to undermine the strike: "the nine million strikers do not seek -power, they want better conditions of work" , said a PCF official. The French "Communist" trade unions refused to harness the power of the strikes to political demands and positively encouraged workers to return to work with improved conditions and pay. But time and again workers' demands transcended the attempts of the PCF to try and contain the struggle.

The PF succeeded in gradually driving strikers back to work. A general election resulted in the strengthening of the French right wing and its continued dominance over French society for the next 13 years. Thus it was a deliberately provoked defeat of the French working class, consciously organised by a PCF frightened of revolution.

France demonstrated the great worldshaking power of the working class when it chooses to act. It showed that, in certain conditions, radical students could inspire and help ignite working class action. Unfortunately, the experience of the general strike also demonstrated the power of the entrenched capitalist class and their "socialist" and Stalinist allies to derail and hold back the working class.

The huge contradictions gaping in the politics of the anti-war movement opened it to additional political weaknesses: it inverted the nationalism of its own side, uncritically accepting the nationalism of the others, marching under the flag of the Vietnamese Stalinist "National Liberation Front". The destructive tendencies of American imperialism towards the Third World led to the politics of a kind of knee-jerk reaction, and a glorification of leaders who championed Third World causes.

The chant of "Ho, Ho, Ho Chi Minh" was the chant of radical students all over the Western world. [There was a "Trotskyist" version: "Ho, Ho, Ho Chi Minh - how many Trots did you do in?" Trotskyists like the supporters of Ernest Mandel wouldn't chant this version, on principle!] Fidel Castro and Che Guevara caught the romantic imaginations of the young articulate middle class students who were looking for progressive causes, and found them in the glorification of Cuba. There was a growth in Maoism and a championing of the monstrous ultra-Stalinist Chinese Cultural Revolution.

In reality, of course, the Cultural RevoluAnti-war protester taunts military police outside the Pentagon tion was a philistine step by the ruling Chinese Stalinists devised to liquidate opposition, the teaching of a single text with a hatred of "intellectuals" leading to thousands of deaths and heralding the lunatic genocidal ideology of the Khmer Rouge in. Kampuchea. The Khmer Rouge merely did things more comprehensively and intensely and all in one go.

nevitably the *1968 tide" began to recede. There was a retreat from the politics of universal equality both within the feminist and the black movements. King's assassination led to a hardening of attitudes.

Feminism increasingly put gender rather than class at the centre of oppression. These were the politics of a kind of despair and frustration at the lack of change.

The politics of the new left were in reality only one step away from conforming with the ruling ideology of society. Changing the world was seen only as an incidental and, faced with difficulties became for some increasingly an unnecessary part self-realisation.

The counter-culture was about finding a *true knowledge of self" and as such eventually gave way to the "me generation" , and later collapsed into the tame reformist politics of equal opportunities, ecology and moralism about Third World struggles.

Furthermore, those who had embraced Stalinism had strangled the notion of socialism as self-emancipation and replaced it with the idealisation of a monstrous, repressive state tyranny. The idealisation of Cuba, China, Cambodia and Vietnam did nothing but demoralise and disenchant: the movement had erected false gods.

Much of the present and recent public disillusionment of ex-revolutionaries and exsocialists is a movement by these very people, grown old and tired and now disenchanted. But there was never any respect-worthy intellectual, political or moral reason for them to subscribe to these illusions in the first place!

In any case it is not liberating working class socialism they hve become disillusioned with: most of them rejected that at the start!

At the centre of much of the new left's politics was what was regarded as the revolutionary potential of lifestyle politics. A powerful counter-culture of drugs, permissiveness and hedonism were strictly in vogue. On one hand the left was dogmatic, doctrinaire and Stalinist, whilst on the other it shunned working class socialism and chose instead a self-indulgent, individualistic and sometimes nihilistic culture.

It the end of 1968, despite huge demooffensive on Vietnam, over 30,000 American troops had died, and countless more Vietnamese; mainstream careerist US "liberal" Bobby Kennedy, and Martin Luther King had been assassinated; in Britain Tory MP Enoch Powell had made his racist "Rivers of Blood" speech; in Northern Ireland Catholics were in rebellion; Soviet tranks had invaded Czechoslovakia and ten million French workers had staged the biggest strike ever in history. Society was in ferment, yet the politics of the movement had been successfully neutered and hollowed out.

The Stalinist and "socialist" official organisations of the labour movement had helped the capitalists to survive.

History, it is said, never repeats itself exactly, but even so lessons should be learned. Our role as the Gulf war's impact increases polarisation in society is to assert working class politics forcefully.

Already the American labour movement is moving to take centre stage in opposition to the war. Our central task is to build a powerful anti-war movement. But we have other tasks, too. We must ensure that radicalised people do not become miseducated with the nationalism of the Ba'athists, the utopianism of Third World ideologies, or the moralistic anti-consumption politics of the Greens.

Those who can learn the lessons of history can hope to avoid reliving it!

MA

Scan page 10

N PERSPECTIVE

----- pull-quotes -----

In 1965, '66, '67 and '68 the people of the black ghettoes all across America erupted in

ree contra cobtion "Women fought hard for their equal place in the movement"

OLALPAN NOW

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 476

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →