Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

TV detectives and oddballs Bears that TV versions

Socialist Organiser no. 475, 14 February 1991 · scan p. 14 · about 1,248 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 14

J Siddon (SO 474)

of detective stories level them down "into a glossy sameness"

Agatha Christie's Poirot, which Siddon cites as an exception to this rule, seems to me on the contrary a prime example.

Detective stories have a conservative bias because they must tend to assume a world put awry by individual villains and put right again by individual saviours. Yet they also tend to gain some critical bite because the villain will be an apparently respectable person (while the more villainous-seeming are innocent), and the detective will usually be a maverick, an outsider, an incongruous figure.

Despite Agatha Christie's personal politics — very orthodoxly conservative, as far as I can make out - her stories have that sort of critical bite.

The twittering little old lady (Miss Marple) or the blathering travelling salesman (Montague Egg) turn out to be more use in a crisis than the high and mighty.

Poirot, too, is meant to be a ridiculous, incongruous figure. Yet the TV series, on the evidence I've seen, makes him only slightly eccentric, less ridiculous than Hastings or Miss Lemon.

Poirot is short, a pipsqueak; David Suchet, far from being "perfectly cast Student Federation Against the Gulf War and Student CND "Israel/Palestine: what's the solution?" Oxford Poly, 2.00. Speaker Mark Osborn Anti-war meeting, Bolton Institute, 4.30. Speaker Mark Sandell Luton Campaign Against War in Gulf meeting. Methodist Church 7.30 Thursday Anti-war meeting, West Sussex Institute, 7.00. Speaker Mark Sandell Friday 22 February Ireland: Geoff Bell debates Austen Morgan. Jacksons Lane Community Centre, 271 Archway Road, Londor N6, 7.30. Organised by Pluto Book North West Labour Against the War meeting, Manchester Town Hall, 7.30 CND Lobby of Parliament Against the Gulf War Saturday 23 February Sheffield Socialist Organiser day schi "Gulf war — the issues for socialist: 12.00-5.00 Monday 25 February Workers Liberty Forum: "Lesbian and Gay Liberation: the socialist agenda", LSE, Houghton St, 7.30 Speakers include Peter Tatchell i Janine Booth for the role" as BJ Siddon would have it, is a rather imposing figure.

Why did Agatha Christie make Poirot a Belgian? She made him a foreigner to spice the stories, and if she made him French-speaking his verbal foibles would be familiar and comprehensible to her readers.

But why Belgian rather than French? Because by conventional prejudice the Belgians are a dim, slow, provincial, dull, small nation: that is how they figure in the conventional humour of the French (in contrast, of course, to the . supposed metropolitan wit of the French themselves).

All that dimension is lost in the TV version - and, unless they have picked exceptional duds from Christie's work, most of the cleverness and pace of her plots too. Instead we have a self-indulgent parade of "period" settings - in a phrase, "levelling down into a glossy sameness".

Alan Gilbert Islington Tuesday 26 February Student anti-war lobby of parliament, Central Hall, Westminster, 12.00. Organised by Student CND and NUS Wednesday 27 Februar Anti-war lobby of the TUC. Assem ble 8.15, Congress House, Great Russell St, London. Called by NUJ Book Branch Thursday 28 February 'Israel. Palestine and the Gulf War", Leeds SO meeting. Packhorse pub, Woodhouse Lane. 7.30. Speaker Joh O'Mahony Saturday 2 March Workers Liberty dayschool. St Mary's Centre, Middlesborough 11.00 start Anti-war demonstration in London by the Committee to Stop War in Monday 6 March Anti-war meeting, Brighton Cor change, 7.30. Speakers include Benn and Bruce Kent Friday 8 March International Women's Day anti-wa tion. Meet 5.00, Albert Er abankme march to St Thomas's Ho pital to highlight health cuts. Vigil: 6-7 in ment Squarę. Women only pression. Its advocates argu that a smaller Palestinian state next to a Jewish one cannot give the Palestinians justice: they will by definition be excluded from the Jewish state (at least to the extent that Jews maintain a majority). A single state, within which all citizens will have equal rights, is the onl programme socialists could support. Such is the argument.

There is a version of this attitude which argues that the "democratic secular state" cannot be achieved by a purely bourgeois nationalist struggle. There wil have to be a working class, socialist struggle.

Many Middle Eastern revolutionary socialists would add that this in turn entails joint struggle by Palestinian Arab and Israeli Jewish workers. (Some socialists prefer a different formula to "democratic secular state", but maintain the idea of a single state in Palestine.)

Joint socialist struggle by Jews and Palestinians is not the same thing as a blitzkrieg from the air by the most brutal and repressive regime the Arab world has ever seen. How is it, then, that many on the left think there is at least some similarity?

The connection depends on a viewpoint in which Saddam Hussein's military gamble is imagined to be a kind of primitive, lower level expression of the same basic struggle. Socialism, from this perspective, is merely a preferable form of Arab nationalism. It would be nice if the struggle - or the war - against Zionism was waged by a class-conscious workers' movement; but wars waged by bourgeois Arab states — against not just Zionism, but the entire Israeli Jewish people - will do in a pinch.

Suppose Saddam's war stood a real chance of defeating Israel. Unless, during its course, the preferred socialist movement came into being, a full military victory for Saddam - the smashing of Israel, the declared aim of anti-Zionism" - would clearly result in a state that would be neither democratic nor secular, if any Jews were left alive. It would not be democratic for the Palesti we have as yet no control), allowing only for a "good' outcome, and then reading backwards to give to the events of today a character which they plainly do not have.

When Socialist Organiser objected to the democratic secular state formula that in practice it could only be achieved by the bourgeois Arab states conquering Israel, the formula's socialis supporters insisted that they did not support the bourgeois Arab states.

Yet support them - in this case, Saddam Hussein - they do: "critically", though critical of what, in this instance, is not clear.

From a socialist point of view the Iraqi attacks on Israel are indefensible.

If our objective is workin class unity against all the ruling classes of the region, and imperialism, the Iraqi attacks are self-evidently (to put it mildly) counterproductive. In what magical way are Scud missiles landing on residential quarters of Tel Aviv to be translated into the united workers' struggle on which any socialist future depends?

The only standpoint from which it makes sense to support the missile attacks is undiluted Arab chauvinism: a nationalism in which the enemy is seen not as specific capitalist class relations, including those which exist in Israel, but the Israeli Jewish people as such.

These indeed are the real politics behind the attacks. Saddam Hussein is an Arab chauvinist: ask the Kurds. His decision to attack Israel has absolutely nothing to de with liberating Palestinians. (Liberating" "Palestine"

- as a hunk of territory -perhaps; but socialists are concerned with people, not bits of land.)

The left's support for the Scud attacks (logically, even if the Scuds had chemical warheads), supposedly in the name of the democratic secular state, shows what formula means in the real world. It is an Arab chauvinist programme, whatever the intentions of the Palestinians who thou of it, which leads in practi to support for completely reactionary actions by a completely reactionary regime.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 475

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →