Loach's film making But is it art?
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-02-14Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 14
bad politics can make bad art (SO 47) and I am pleased to note that, by referring to Marx's views on Balzac, Matgamna also agrees that bad politics can make good art, although not consciously SO.
As Matgamna points out, Zhdanov was responsible for reducing all art to the question of what was good for Stalinism. I do not for a minute believe that this was Matgamna was about in his review of Ken Loach's Hidden Agenda. But it is the priorities that count. Matgamna writes off the film because he does not agree with its politics. But, and this is the question which should have been addressed first, he does not give any real consideration as to whether it worked as a film.
In my view, although there are certainly improvements that could have been made, the film does work as a tilm. It is a thriller dealing with the question of corruption and the liberal democratic state. The central character, a John Stalker-like policeman, is faced with the dilemma of an *honest cop" who finds that he is defending not democracy but a state where the army and extreme right wing politicians call the tune to a significant extent.
The film's politics flow from this. It is a sort of "it can happen here" movie. My criticism of Loach's politics is not that he is soft on republicanism but that Ireland is essentially a backdrop to wider issues here. So while Hidden Agenda is billed as a film about Ireland it ducks the Irish Question to a considerable extent.
Does this make Hidden Agenda bad art? I think not. It does mean however that it is not as useful for revolutionary socialists as it might have been. Regrettably there is no guarantee that someone with a 100% ideologically correct line on Ireland Loach doubt which Matgamna, and myself would no [disagree anyway) anything better: Charlie Murray North London EVIE=ON ahe bulk of the far - eft in Britain has in effect -supported the Iraqi missile attacks on Israel.
The Arab states, they say, have the right to hit Israel, which is an oppressive settler-colonial outpost. Support for Iraqi missiles landing on suburbs of Tel Aviv is indeed the logical result of the "democratic secular state" programme held to by most of the left as a solution to the Israel/Palestine conflict.
This formula is supposed to provide the only consistently democratic answer to Palestinian national opnians either.
Support for Iraq against Israel therefore depends on the assumption that somehow Iraq's war will br ing about a socialist revolution: a bourgeois war to im pose undemocratic rule on the Palestinians and the Jews will of necessity, in fact, result in a socialist struggle uniting all the peoples of the region (including the Israeli Jewish working class) against imperialism and Zionism.
So the Iraq attack now is justified not in terms of existing class forces, current issues or real political objec tives, but in terms of hypothetical future class forces: forces which do not yet exist.
It is a stark example of scenario politics, constructing a line of development from current reality (which would depend on a wide range of factors over which
----- pull-quotes -----
WRITEBACK f course I agree with O Sean Maganna that