The beginning of war in 1914
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-02-14Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 12
AGAINST THE TIDE uchanan, the former British Bambassador to (the Russian capital St Petersburg, speaks with exaltation in his memoirs of "those wonderful early August [1914] days", when Russia seemed to have been completely transformed"* Viennese crowds cheer off the Austr, Hungarian troops, 191 All the European capitals were having equally "wonderful days" in August. They were all entirely "transformed" for the business of mutual extermination.
The patriotic enthusiasm of the masses in Austria-Hungary seemed especially surprising. What was it that drew to the square in front of the War Ministry the Viennese bootmaker's apprentice, Pospichil, half German, half Czech; or our greengrocer, Frau Maresch; or the cabman, Frankl? What sort of an idea?
The people whose lives, day in and day out, pass in a monotony of hopelessness are many; they are the mainstay of modern society. The alarm of mobilisation breaks into their lives like a promise; the familiar and long-hated is overthrown, and the new and unusual reigns in its place. Changes still more incredible are in store for them in the future. For better or worse? For the better, of course - what can seem worse to Popischil than "normal" conditions?
I strode along the main streets of the familiar Vienna and watched a most amazing crowd fill the fashionable Ring, a crowd in which hopes had been awakened. But wasn't a small part of these hopes already being realised? Would it have been possible at any other time for porters, laundresses, shoemakers, apprentices and youngsters from the suburbs to feel themselves the situation in the Ring? are oppressed and deceived by life far affects everybody, and those who consequently feel that they are on an equal footing with the rich and powerful. It may seem a paradox, but in the moods of the Viennese crowd that was demonstrating the glory of the Hapsburg arms I detected something familiar to me from the October days of [revolution in] 1905 in St Petersburg. No wonder that in history war has often been the mother of revolution.
Like revolution, war forces life, from top to bottom, away from the beaten track. But revolution directs its blows against the established power. War, on the contrary, at first strengthens the state power which, in the chaos engendered by war, appears to be the only firm support - and then undermines it.
Hopes of strong social and national movements are utterly groundless at the outset of a war. In September 1914 I wrote: *The mobilisation and declaration of war have veritably swept off the face of the earth all the national and social contradictions in the country. But this is only a political delay, a sort of political moratorium. The notes have been extended to a new date, but they will have to be paid."
My Life groups, national and religious minorities, who are not "nations" but have the right not to be conquered forcibly by aggressors. Socialists would always uphold this right. The people who lived in Kuwait did not invite Iraq in, there was no democratic or socialist movement which sought assistance, Saddam did not intervene to install democracy. It must, therefore, be part of our programme that Iraq should leave and the people of the area should decide the future of Kuwait.
he rich and democratic tradition of our movement has been ditched in favour of much cruder guidelines. Instead of having no country and always advocating the most democratic relations between peoples and nations we are advised to be guided by hostility to certain countries. Hatred of the US or British interests (understandable as an instinct) is paramount. Anything that gets in the way of this gut anti-imperialism, anything that "gives succour" to or even addresses the same concerns as these governments must be silenced, whatever its own merits.
This is what Trotsky once called the politics of pluses and minuses. Instead of working out independently what is in our class interests, we start with our enemy's position and simply say no where they say yes. It is socialism defined as the negative of capitalism. If it continues to grow in our movement then not only will the working class have no country, they will have no politics either.
Scan page 13
Meryl Streep and Shirley Maclaine play daughte noth NI ues Televisic By Jean Lane he first part of a series called "The Land of Europe was shown on Saturday night (Channel 4). It focused on various parts of British country life. A woodcutter, miles from anywhere in the south of England, was asked if he found his work lonely. No, he replied, I find going to London lonelier. In a country village everyone might know your business, but at least it's not possible to be dead in a flat for weeks before anyone