The arguments about "Iraq out of Kuwait! Workers of the world unite?
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-02-14Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 12
familiar and essential idea of A Marxism is the assertion that "the workers have no country". It sets us the task of convincing our class that we have no interest in nationalism and patriotism, that we have more in common with workers in other countries than our own bosses, and that ultimately we want to see the end of national boundaries.
Nations have no great attraction for us. Why then, the more cynical often ask, do you all make such a fuss when nations are invaded? Why are you constantly marching for national rights for this group, self-determination for that, when it really doesn't make any difference to workers which country they live in?
First there is the matter of democratic rights. Nationalism, like religion, might be a wholly wrong-headed answer to humanity's problems, but the forcible repression of such beliefs is not the best way to convince people of this. Secondly, nationalism, at certain times, has played a progressive role in human history. The creation of larger national units from fragmented states was a big step forward.
In 19th century Europe and the 20th cen= tury world the nationalism of oppressed nations has been the desire to remove an occupying power, the desire for a parliament of their own, more democracy, self-rule. These things can never end the oppression of workers - that exploitation is conducted first by their own 'national bosses - but they do change significantly the conditions under which that oppression takes place.
Recent arguments arising from the Gulf war, however, suggest that a healthy dip into the Marxist tradition would work wonders for the British left.
longside the main argument - that Western forces should get out of Kuwait — Socialist Organiser has consistently raised the demand that Iraq should pull out of Kuwait. In a discussion with a supporter of Militant I was confronted Iraqi tanks roll into Kuwait, August 2 1990 with the following "logic": "..Iraq shouldn't have invaded Kuwait, but now that hey have it would be a mistake to call for "The slogan 'Iraq out Kuwait' is part of the programme with which the working class of the region and internationall should respond to the whole Gulf crisis."
their withdrawal." Why? We *it would add comfort to th the warmongers, and reinforc war aims, and second because we favour Arab unity. Saddam has removed a national division between two Arab states which is exactly what we want to do. OK, it hasn't happened in the way we would want but to undo it would set back international unity and should be opposed"
The most worrying part of that argument is the indifference about how Arab unity is achieved. This is the reverse of the approach I outlined earlier. Here "Arab national unity" is the primary concern, the consent of the workers, the conditions for them, their involvement, all democratic considerations are entirely secondary. For us these things are central; who unified, for what reason, and with what practical results for the working his connects with the other main objection I've heard recently. Socialist Organiser don't believe that Kuwait is a "nation" at all, we have said that if it were annexed by a socialist or even democratic Iraq our attitude would be different, "but not by this murderous Iraqi regime". This is petty moralising, I am told (by a supporter of Socialist Action). SO has no significant reasons for making a major issue of Kuwait, no reason of national rights, only the "liberal" concern that Iraq has a murderous regime. Once again this appears to miss entirely the place of democratic concerns in working class politics.
The ability of trade unionists and socialists in Kuwait to organise freely, to act independently, and to struggle for their own interests will be worse so long as they are under occupation by the Iraqi army.
Not only that, but the task of fragi workers will also be much harder so long as their regime forcibly occupies its neighbour. That occupation strengthens the military and Saddam's dictatorship, as was his intention.
The slogan "Traq out of Kuwait" is part of the programme with which the working class of the region and internationally should respond to the whole Gulf crisis.
The fact that Kuwait is not a nation is neither here nor there. There are all sorts of
----- pull-quotes -----
LE POLITICALI FRONT