Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

[Wine tie wo hey an ine armongers love…]

Socialist Organiser no. 475, 14 February 1991 · scan pp. 10–12 · about 1,406 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

Wine tie wo hey an ine armongers love bombir the last world war, the Vietnam war and the RussoAfghanistan war (1979-88).

From the point of view of an al tacking army, bombing makes a lot of sense. Rather than wade in with infantry against entrenched positions in unknown territory — begin any campaign by blasting and weakening the enemy from afar or from above.

Bombing has two stated aims, and one big advantage. The aims are to weaken the enemy by destroying useful installations -armaments factories, for example — and to demoralise the civilian population. The advantage is that the destruction and the casualties suffered by those on the ground will always (in theory) be higher than those in the air.

The problems are not in the theory, but in the practice. The things an enemy ideally wants to bomb are usually (a) difficult to spot from the (especially at night), and (b) the best defended.

Bombing of easy-to-spot, undefended "targets" (ie. cities) has the result of hardening civilian resolve rather than weakening it, and does the aggressor no good in the eyes of the world.

All the technology in the world has not solved these problems for La Billiere and Schwarzkopf.

The problems facing the "allied" forces in the Gulf are essentially the same ones that taced the allies in World War 2. World War 2 British bombers had to fly at night, because daylight raids across Europe were too dangerous. Fighter aeroplanes did not have the fuel to provide cover all the way to Germany, and the bombers were too slow to escape German fighters. Even the American Flying Fortresses with their superior defences suffered heavy losses in daytime raids.

Night flying meant that the bombers often missed the target: altogether, or didn't do the damage necessary to put them of action. Allied policy was originally to bomb "targets" like munitions factories, oil and synthetic oil plants and communications.

These were supposed to be "precision" raids but they were largely unsuccessful. For example, on 17 April 1942 a daylight raid on Augsberg's MAN diesel engine factory caused some damage to the works, but did not seriously affect production. Of the 12 Lancaster bombers which were involved in the raid, seven were destroyed, and the rest damaged.

The British also favoured *area bombing" which overcame the problems of not being able to hit the target. Policy never entirely switched from "precision" to "area" bombing because the decision makers could not agree amongst themselves.

The "compromise" was large London in the Blitz

Scan page 11

›se who do not remember the past are condemned to relive i Over 100,000 people died when the Allies bombed Dresden on 13 February 1945 - more than in Hiroshima and Nagasaki blitz last time scale bombing of industrial cities, like Hamburg, where an estimated 42.000 people were killed between July 24 and August 2 1943. Firestorms were created; Hamburg was left in ruins. But of 791 planes involved in the first night of the bombing, only 12 were destroyed and 31 damaged.

By contrast the fantastically acthe truth about the last few weeks, months earlier did breach the Möhne and Eder dams. Parts of the Ruhr were flooded and large numbers of people drowned. But the German war economy was hardly affected; and only 5 out of 19 planes came back undamaged.

Even with hindsight it is impossible to say whether "area" or "precision" bombing was the more "successful" in terms of allied war aims. Precision bombing, even when largely unsuccessful didn't help the German war effort, and mass destruction of people and buildings on the scale of the Dresden raids must have made the civilians hate the allies, and probably didn't help the war effort. The Blitz may have helped unite the British people, but the damage to London's docklands, factories and warehouses must have harmed the British economy.

The bombing of Iraq is currently shrouded in secrecy. In Britain at least, it will probably be 30 years before we have access to the truth about the raids of the last few weeks. Reading between the ULTIC HELE lines of propaganda and disinformation it would ceem that "nrec PAUN sion" raids are being tried again and, as in World War 2, they are not quite as precise as the politicians who front for the soldiers and air forces would have us believe.

"Area" bombing is not the allies' stated strategy, but many the alleged military targets are suspiciously close to city centres. Saddam Hussein is blamed for the civilian casualties because Iraqi military "installations" were built near centres of population.

But if the same "installations" were to be bombed in Britain, the! too would be found to be close to centres of population - for exam ple, tanks are built almost in the centre of Newcastle, Britain's major chemical and oil works are all close to big cities.

Funeral pyres burning in Dresden's city squares How much easier it would be declare a whole area to he a target! Flattening the whole of MOVINE IVAN SEVE IN Baghdad is much easier (and safer for the pilots) than "precision" raids — and would be bound to hit the "military" installations as well as the residential areas.

In Britain, the equivalent would be to bomb the whole of Newcastle from a great height, rather than risk expensive planes trying to hit the only Vickers plant, which would be properly defended.

It is quite possible that the US and British airforces are already carrying out "area" bombing raids, or that they will start to do so in the near future.

Dresden was the victim of such a raid in February 1945. Upwards of 100,000 people were killed in the worst firestorms of the war, -808 city flattened.

The firestorms in Dresden created by incendiary bombs arr now used as a "model" for wol ing out the consequences of nuclear war.

Firestorms occur when a fire feeds itself on oxygen from the above the City Hall looks Socialist Organiser No. 475 page 11 surrounding area creating winds which are so strong that they can pull people into the fire.

The fires also take all the OXygen out of the air, making it impossible to breathe.

*There was not a house anywhere in the street which not turned into a blazing firebrand. Above the sea of flames, a glowing cyclone raged over the town; and whenever it caught the bodies of people in flight, it shrivelled them in a second to the size of a child, and the next day they lay all over the streets, hardly burnt, but like mummified children.

*I kept to the edge of this burn ing hurricane, but at one time hac to clutch at a tree with both arms to avoid being swept into a burning house by the draught...

(Contemporary account of the bombing of Darmstadt in 1944)In Britain in 1940 during the Blitz 60,000 civilians were killed. Raids on towns like Coventry dic not result in the destruction on ti scale of Dresden, but even so death and homelessness struck London's East End on an unprecedented scale.

People spent every night for months in cellars, shelters and underground stations, and came out in the morning in the hope that their home would still be standing. Even the shelters were no defence against a direct hit, and there were many casualties amongst firefighters, air raid patrols, and other auxiliaries.

It may be that Schwarzkopf the others are genuinely trying avoid bombing civilians and residential areas, but we can't judge because we are only given propaganda. What they say now what they would say even if the truth were the direct opposite. But the longer the war drags on, and the longer the Iraqi people hold out, the more likely it is that area bombing will be used against Iraq's towns and cities.

These people are already without fuel, and food and water supplies are low. All the bombing raids of World War 2 (on both sides) hardened the resolve of the civilian populations. Far from causing a drop in morale, the evidence is that people on both sides worked harder and for longer hours - and hated the enemy more.

Even if the "allies" bomb into submission they will not welcomed as liberators.

Scan page 12

ganiser I PERSPECTIVE

----- pull-quotes -----

qurate "Dam Busters" raid two "It will probably be 30 years before we have

N PERSPECTIVE the past

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 475

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →