When a leg was worth £1.87½p per week
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-02-14Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
Soldiers are naturally appreShensive as they wait to go into battle. They wonder whether they will be killed or injured. If the worst happens, they fear that proper provisions may not be made for their families.
Equally, if they are maimed for life, they are worried that they may have to eke out the rest of their Painful existences on the poverty All these misgivings were present in the Second World War. This was particularly true as the troops awaited the opening of the Second Front. That, they knew, would entail immense casualties.
But a staggering fact confronted them: war pensions were lower than they had been in the First World War. Translating the figures into current decimal currency, the loss of both legs, the loss of sight, facial disfigurement in 1943 led to a weekly pension of £1.87½p; in the First World War the figure had been f2. Similarly, for loss of an arm or below the shoulder, the award had been reduced from a weekly £1.60 to £1.50 in the Second World War.
1943 Jimmy Maxton, the Clydeside rebel MP, told parliament that injured soldiers were actually receiving smaller amounts of compensation then than they did in the Crimean war.
How was it that pensions were so inadequate? At the end of the First World War, Britain reaped a grisly harvest. It had to face the problem of how to deal with the enormous number - three quarters of a million men - who had been wounded. Obviously pensions were going to be a burning issue.
For this reason, JT Murphy, one of the leaders of the Shop Stewards' Movement, fought the minister responsible for pensions at Gorton in the 1918 general election. He was not concerned about winning. What Murphy sought to do was to spread the message that the war had primarily been fought for profits; it was out of profits that adequate pensions should be paid.
The minds of some members of the armed forces were moving in the same direction. In the closing stages of the First World War, the Soldiers', Sailors' and Airmens' Union was formed. This trade union had three mains aims: first, to improve the pay and conditions of serving personnel; second, to hasten the demobilisation of the overwhelming majority who wished to return home; and, third, to fight for adequate pensions for the families of those who had been killed and also those who had been maimed.
The authorities clearly were alarmed by the creation of the Ray Challinor is the author of several books on labour history including The British Bolsheviks
Soldiers', Sailors' and Airmens*
Union. In the immediate post-war period, they were witnessing the unprecedented wave of industrial unrest that had distinctly revolutionary overtones. The question was whether they could rely upon soldiers to smash demonstrations and break strikes if they themselves belonged to a trade union linked to the organised working class movement. They were also alarmed at the prospect of mass campaigns tor higher pensions led by limbless exservicemen. Forceful language might be used to contrast their pitiful poverty with the immense wealth accumulated by capitalists as a result of the war. Naturally, the authorities wanted to strangle the new trade union before it grew and became a threat. Dr David Englander, an historian at the Open University, has done some first-class research on how this was accomplished. In Labour History authorities recognised there was a need for exservicemen to have formation of the (April 1987), he describes the immense amount of surveillance conducted by the intelligence services on the armed forces throughout the First World War. All letters from soldiers at the front were opened and read. Not only were the authorities concerned to monitor soldiers' morale, they wished to weed out any signs of disaffection. These techniques, Dr Englander says, were extended when the Sailors' and Airmens' Union. His article in History Today (March 1987) entitled "Troops and Trade Unions, 1919", describes how this was subsequently extended: The raid on SSAU offices of 5 May 1919, coupled with the targetting of leading activists, extensive demobilisation and pre-occupation of ex-soldiers with industrial struggles, led to the organisation's demise.
Nevertheless, the authorities recognised there was a need for exservicemen to have a voice. Therefore, they encouraged the formation of the British Legion in 1921. Though ostensibly meant to represent the interests of exservicemen, the British Legion quintessentially was a friend of The Establishment - its leadership coming from the upper echelons of society and having over-riding conEL potatoes in cern not embarrass that be.
This even extended to the administration of its own funds. Despite the relatively small number of officers compared to other ranks, and the exceedingly high pensions they received, the Legion's benevolent fund discovered the officers had a disproportionately large number of needy cases. Widespread anger among the armed forces was aroused when soldiers discovered that the British Legion Benevolent Fund had, between its inception in 1921 and 1943, given more than 40 per cent of its money to officers. In that time its total expenditure had been £6,333,734; out of which officers had been given £2,889,432.
Since the Second World War, the British Legion has retained apathetic indifference to the welfare of soldiers and their families. In the 1950s, for example, many servicemen were deliberately exposed to radiation at the nuclear tests in Australia. Subsequently, many have developed various forms of cancer, particularly leukaemia. But the campaign to secure compensation for the men and next of kin has not been led by the Legion. Rather it has depended on an ad-hoc organisation, largely run by victims, aided in Parliament by Bob Clay MP. Likewise with the scandal of the war widows that only secured settlement two years ago: the Legion did nothing to bring to the public's attention the plight of these poor women.
The present conditions may make it propitious to think again on the subject of organisation. Councils in the North East, like Gateshead, have been pressured to make up the incomes of its staff who have been sent to the Gulf. Obviously this is a non-starter: local authorities, many rate-capped, have insufficient funds. to maintain essential services, let alone for extra payments to soldiers. Yet it does raise once more the question not only of pay and conditions of members of the armed forces but also of the pensions of their dependents. The struggle to improve these needs to integrated with the organised working In recent years, we have witnessed a concerted onslaught of hostile governments upon the trade union movement. Established freedoms have been stolen from workers. In places like GCHQ at Cheltenham, they have even had their right to be trade unionists taken away while in education teachers' organisations have been denied the right to collective bargaining.
In the present climate it may be appropriate to recall a military adage: attack is the best form of defence. As the John Major-Neil Kinnock coalition presses ahead with Desert Storm in the Gulf, perhaps union storm should be launched here in Britain, a campaign to organise all workers, including those in the Territorial ArmyBy Liz Millward
----- pull-quotes -----
a voice. Therefore, they encouraged th
British Legion in 1921."