An uneasy relationship
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-02-14Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
ahe relationship between the modern lesbian and gay movement and socialism has always been an uneasy one. But the socialist tradition, prior to the 1930s, did take up the question.
A number of isolated socialists in Europe and the USA raised the need for gay liberation as they then conceived it from the 1880s onwards. The overall ideological climate was, of course, appalling, with homosexuality regarded as at worst a crime against nature and at best a disease or deformity of the mind. Socialists on the whole remained dominated by these views. Most of them were silent; those who spoke, like Engels, simply expressec the reactionary prejudices of thei time: he condemned the "perversion of boy love'"
One or two visionaries, like Edward Carpenter, had some influence, and the new psychology (especially Freud) began to produce a more liberal and enlightened view within the intelligentsia.
But the only real political campaign was in Germany. With some limitations, the German SPD took up the issue and campaigned for the abolition of the law which outlawed homosexual behaviour. The renowned German sexologist Magnus Hirschfeld, who was gay, was an SPD member.
It was from the SPD rather than directly that the Bolsheviks adopted the liberal sexual policies which followed the revolution in Russia. For a brief period of a decade or more a more liberal attitude prevailed in Russia though there were no statements on the question, so far as we are aware, by Bolshevik leaders and those of them who were gay stayed firmly in the closet.
The dark reaction was simultaneous in Germany and Russia. The Nazis abolished Hirschfeld's institute and burned his ettigy and outlawed homosexuality; later they were to consign thousands of homosexuals to the concentration camps and gas chambers. In the USSR Stalin's 1934 law outlawed homosexuality again. He too sent many homosexuals to lifelong imprisonment and flavour. Early experiments like che Gay Liberation Front tended to disintegrate (rather acrimoniously, and often over the perennial question of the relationships between lesbians and gay men).
The movement has never been as strong in Britain as in some other countries, most obviously the USA, but also some southern European countries and the more industrially developed parts of the Third World (for example, Mexico). You only have to compare the relatively small "scene" in London (never mind the rest of Britain) with a city like Barcelona to see how true this is.
In part, the strength of the lesbian and gay movement in the "There now exists in Britain a network of relationship to the labour movement has tended to be financial dependent on unreliable grants from Labour authorities. A new kind of relationship needs to be developed."
USA, in particular, is due to the existence of large "ghettoes" in major cities like San Francisco. The lesbian and gay community, if community is not too strong a word, in Britain has always been more dispersed.
But there have been some important developments. The annual "Pride" march, although increasingly apolitical, is these days a big event, ignored, however, by the media. The miners' strike of 1984-85 saw a small but significant campaign of solidarity which had some impact on the thinking of the labour movement; the NUM, not known before as one of the most progressive unions on the question, voted for the lesbian and gay rights motion at Labour Party conference in 1985.
Smaller support groups have been formed for other big strikes, like the printers!
Defensive struggles, like the one over Clause 28, brought forward a powerful movement, the main effect of which was to demonstrate visibly the extent to which thousands of lesbians and gay men are "out of the closet" and determined not to be recriminalised. The current campaign could prove as powerful. And even if not successful, as the campaign against Clause 28 was not, the extent of the protest certainly has an effect in limiting the impact of the reactionary laws.
There now exists in Britain a network of groups, newspapers, centres and a commercial scene which links together large numbers of lesbians and gay men in a fragmentary movement. Often their relationship to the labour movement has tended to be financial - dependent on unreliable grants from Labour authorities. A new kind of relationship needs to be developed.
The lesbian and gay movement has had an effect on the climate within the Labour Party and the trade unions. Caucuses exist in some unions, and some have had good paper policy for lesbian and gay rights.
Struggles for sexual liberation need to be knitted together with the broader struggle for human freedom.
----- pull-quotes -----
groups... a fragmentary movement. Often their