Another sophisticated liberal backs the slaughter The reluctant warmongel
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-02-14Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
son, on the other hand, can hegemony over the Middle from the fan club.
PREISISEGIANIG don't suppose it would bother him (even if he ever heard about it) but Neal Ascherson has just lost a devoted member of his fan club: me.
seem to recall once describing him here as the best columnist in Britain" When he switched over from the Observer to the Independent on Sunday I followed. His grasp of history and ability to make telling analogies is often breathtaking. His understanding of such matters as inter-communal strife, nationalism and Eastern Europe, ought to shame most avowed "left" commentators (even if he does seem to hold the likes of Tom Nairn in rather too high an esteem).
But this Sunday, the Great Man came out as a "reluctant middle-of-the-road warmonger" over the Gulf. His "confession" seems to have been brought on by an article by Paul Foot in the London Review of Books which I haven't seen, but which Ascherson considers lacking in "heaviness" and a "dashing reduction of the whole crisis to an American war for oil" (an analysis, Ascherson concedes, that has its charm").
Now, I am no fan of Mr Paul Foot either, and having heard him speak at a recent rallv SWP as a political meeting, I am quite well aware that a lot of Foot's "arguments" are nonsense from any rational standpoint and, at best, boil down to the profound observation that American presidents tend to be hypocrites when it comes to defending democracy.
But Foot is at least clear in opposing the war and (together with the majority of his fellow Mirror columnists) has said so in print. Foot's crass views on the Middle East question in general are another matter. Neal AscherBally so Tall 22,000 refuse to serve with the Gulf tas! once *Embargsne?: **lagklugre contribution..
the words used by the Mail. It did not enen monstder whe wreumen apridemihal o iraanyayoangu mans take a stand against shedPORCA than bleat world which cannot stand up to a tyrant and aggressor like Saddam Hussein will soon become uninhabitable" widely held and not entirely unreasonable view, but one that comes ill from a writer who then proceeds to destroy his own case by observing that "the costs of fighting him [Saddam] are very great; a brutal and indiscrimate war whose bill in blood will be paid mostly by civilians and helpless conscripts; a probably botched 'settlement" afterwards which will iry to impose a new Western from the Gulf?
Sün East and which will leave Israel as the unchallenged regional super-power"
Yet Ascherson inexplicably adds at the end of this dreadful scenario: "even those things are less terrible than leaving intact Saddam's conquests and power to conquer".
I suppose the war has simply exposed the main trouble with sophisticated, decent, liberal commentators like Ascherson (and the Guardian's Hugo Young): they're not socialists. Still, I'm genuinely very sad to resign againsi and this inparatied злоск погог neisuricomes quf by poll tax bills being sent to troops in the Gulf or in barracks in Britain. And what does the Sun say about poll tax bills for the underpaid healthwerkers whoeve beideling with the wounded UDR Aris ansiver to the problems of the Gulf: the Queen should pray for victory! It's over the-top screeching - followed up the next day by a front page carrying a call from, of all people, soccer commentator Jimmy Greaves, for the Queen to abdicate - must reflect a dim awareness that the traditional guff about Queen and Country no longer has the grip it the fundamental nature. • The setting up of a centre for research into simple nervous systems, with implicaLions for developing artificial intelligence as well as for understanding the workings of the brain.
There will also be reductions in research in information technology, engineering design and computing in engineering. "Small" scientific projects in chemistry, physics, biology and medicine will also be affected, as a group of SERC members made clear in a letter to the press. Projects will be delayed, disrupted or cancelled because research workers and students will be unable to be guaranteed salaries, grants or funds.
Situations like the MRC's recent freeze on recruitment because they had run out of money will become more common.
The sort of approach that limits research to those areas where an immediate result or application is guaranteed is dooming us to a wider ignorance. "Pure" research frequently has value beyond the wildest imagination. As Michael Faraday said when asked by Gladstone, the then Chancellor of the Exchequer, what was the use of his newly discovered electricity: "Sir, one day you will be able to tax it.
----- pull-quotes -----
Les Hearn's COLUMN