Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

No way to run an anti-war movemen

Socialist Organiser no. 475, 14 February 1991 · scan p. 6 · about 883 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 6

The splits and dogged the movement against the Gulf war got worse this week.

At the meeting on Monday 11th of the Committee to Stop War in the Gulf, Labour MIPs Jeremy Corbyn and Bernie Grant had to join a brief 'sit-in" as the only way of protesting at the Committee's exclusiveness.

On 4 February the Committee had 'closed' itself to new affiliations. On Monday it excluded even observers from groups which have sought affiliation: the meeting was to discuss further exclusion, namely the exclusion of the Socialist The proposal, moved by Mike Hicks of the Communist Party of Britain, was for all affiliates of the Committee to be required to sign a 15-point plat form - including support for sanctions against Iraq — as a condition for continued membership. In the end the Committee voted by 20 to 9 to defer its decision, but it looks as if the purge will go through next week.

For the past several months the Socialist Movement, Labou Briefing, Women Against War in the Gulf, Socialist Outlook, LPS and Socialist Organiser have been attempting to affiliate. WAWG and Outlook have had affiliation cheques for €50 cashed.

Yet the affiliations have been blocked. And the way the Committee has been run has worried many activists, from CND and the Greens as well as from the left.

A letter circulated by the Green Party at the Committee meeting on 11 February complains of Committee secretary Carol Turner's failure to circulate minutes and agendas ano the fact that votes at previous meetings had included people who should not have been voting.

On top of such irregularities, several times CND chair Marjorie Thompson has tried to sw ing votes by threatening that CND will withdraw from the Committee. Carol Turner then follows up by accusing those who are about to vote the wrong way of wanting to drive CND out of the organisation.

On 11 February I knew we were in for a bad meeting when I saw Marjorie Thompson and three people from Socialist Action — Carol Turner's group caucusing in a coffee bar beforehand. And so it proved.

T points are, in he proposed 15 summary:

• Immediate ceasefire;

• Withdrawal of Iraq from Kuwait, to be enforced by economic sanctions;

• A UN Middle East peace conference;

• A timetable for the withdrawal of US and allied forces from the Gulf, of Irag from Kuwait, and of Israel from the occupied territories;

• A replacement UN force in the Gulf, with major Arab participation;

• A UN relief fund;

• Ban on exports of nuclear, chemical and biological weapon One other point was added: Iraqi self-determination.

The whole idea of basing what should be a broad, non-exclusive movement on such a lengthy platform is wrong. An as lengthy platforms go, the 1i points are not a good one.

For example: if the withdrawal of US and British troops is to be on the same timetable as Iraqi withdrawal from Kuwait and Israeli withdrawal from the West Ba and Gaza, then, short of miracles, the troops will be there for many years. Is that really what the Committee wants?

It is reasonable that the Con mittee should want to distance itself from sectarians shouting 'Victory to Iraq!" That is the good reason' proposed by Tribune, for example, for a purge. It is not the real reason.

The Committee could distance itself from the sectarians simply by adopting and publicising a policy of Iraq out of Kuwait! It need not and should not purge those who disagree with that policy.

In fact it does have a policy for 'Iraq out of Kuwait!' but its leaflets have never carried that slogan. And the Green Party reps even made a formal com plaint about that omission at the 11 February meeting.

Why the omission? Could it be because the secretary of the Committee, Socialist Action supporter Carol Turner, privately opposes Iraq out of Kuwait!'?

The proposed purge will divide the anti-war movement further. The Committee will ex clude not only Socialist Organiser, Labour Party Socialists and such groups, but also a wider range of Labour left opinion, the SWP, and the left of CND. It will become a narrow pro-UN, pro-sanctions group. Only the narrowest factionalism can justify that.

The purge will also give further aid and comfort to the police in their attempts to criminalise anti-war opinion: or the 2 February demonstration, one marcher, Alistair Green, was arrested for shouting Defend Iraq!"

All that is bad enough; and what makes it weird and doubly irrational is that the people at the centre of the Committee -Carol Turner, its Secretary, Mad otte home suppers or allies of Socialist Action, a group which privately holds the same "Victory to Iraq!" line which it wants to exclude others for advocating! How Carol Turner and her friends square it all in their minds I don't know, but the gist of it seems to be that they have two sets of politics, one for private sect-building use, and the other (sanctions, UN, etc) for public political manoeuvres and manipulation.

This business discredits Socialist Action but it can also discredit and confuse the whole anti-war movement. Responsible anti-war activists should call the Committee to order.

Mark Oshorn

----- pull-quotes -----

new pamphlet from Socialist Organiser

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 475

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →