Two pamphlets tha don't make sense
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-02-06Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 14
EMESON Martin Thomas reviews two new pamphlets from the Socialist Workers Party, No to war in the Gulf (50g and Socialism and War (50p)
To to war includes sures of Bush's and Major's war rhetoric.
It should be handy for people who already know what they think about the war and want ammunition to back up their conclusions.
But for anyone genuinely puzzled about the war, or anyone seeking a rounded Marxist understanding of the whole affair, it is useless.
"Although socialists must hope that Iraq gives the US a bloody nose, it declares, "and that the US is frustrated in its attempt to force the Tragis out of Kuwait, we should have no illusions...
That reads as if there is some argument for the basic pro-Iraqi stance (the stance despite which we should have no illusions, etc) elsewhere in the pamphlet. But there is no such argument. Not a word!
Perhaps that is why the SWP published second pamphlet on the Gulf war. Socialism and war makes some effort to fill the gap.
The Gulf war, it argues -or rather asserts - is about national liberation, in the same category as the Vietnam war. We should side with Saddam as we sided with Ho Chi Minh.
But Socialism and war is mainly a general exposition of Marxist ideas about war (a rather wooden and clumsy one, in my view), and it goes no further into the facts of the Gulf. To see why the SWP analyses the Gulf war as like Vietnam, we have to go back to No to war.
With the war underway, it can be argued - indeed, I would argue — that the issues have spread far beyond Kuwait, and Iraq's independence is under threat. To that extent we should side with Irag.
But No to war does not make that argument. In its half-sentence about siding with Iraq - "although socialists must hope that Iraq gives the US a bloody nose" etc - it defines the war as about Kuwait.
It seems to locate the lional liberation issue, analogue of the Vietnamese Stalinists' struggle to unify and free their country, in Irag's seizure of Kuwait. It is on Kuwait - where Iraq's behaviour is indefensible and monstrous - that it seems to side with Iraq.
Its chapter on Kuwait says nothing about the abuse and oppression of the people living there by the Iraqi military; declares that "the al Sabahs (the Kuwaiti ruling family were far from being innocent victims of Iraqi aggression"' (SWP's scarequotes — so it wasn't aggression?), and approvingly quotes an 'unnamed diplomat from a nearby Gulf emirate" applauding the invasion as a move to stop the West playing off one oil country against another.
Yet the pamphlet never states that the seizure of Kuwait was liberating or progressive. On the contrary: its "After chase we the argument from one pamphlet to another and summary statement is, Saddam moved into Kuwait not to fight imperialism or to help the Arab people but to get control of the means -oil - to pay back the debts he had incurred waging a war in alliance with imperialism" (emphasis added).
After we chase the argument from one pamphlet to the other and back again, it vanishes! Saddam's anti-imperialism is like the Cheshire Cat: when we look at it, its body disappears, leaving only the smile.
Even stranger, the SWP argues that this same Saddam Husssein, only a couple of years ago, was a mere catspaw of the US. "Saddam" (according to Socialism and War "fought an imperialist war on the United States' behalf against Iran in the 1980s" (emphasis original).
Neither pamphlet offers any explanation for Saddam's supposed switch from imperialist stooge to anti-imperialist. Nor do they consider the more plausible argument that Saddam's attack on Kuwait had just the same basic motive as his attack on Iran: the sub-imperialist ambitions of the Iraqi ruling No to war criticises Saddam Hussein. Yet its denunciation of his regime's "torture and murder" are i perfunctory, devoid of the colourful illustrations given for its condemnations of the Saudi and Kuwaiti regimes and, in every case, followed by the word "But..."
The one criticism of Saddam that does get expanded coverage and illustration is that he has not attacked Israel sufficiently. "When war broke out between the Arab states and Israel in 1973, only two divisions of the Iragi army played any part..." etc.
The chapter on Israel in No to war is as baffling as the argument (or lack of it) about supporting Iraq. Most of it is a one-sided list of atrocities from the history of Israel's relations with the Arabs. The point of this list, presumably, is to prove that Israel should be wiped off the map and Saddam should be urged to attack it as hard as possible (or criticised for not doing so). That is nowhere clearly stated, either, but it is the message you get from the half-thoughts.
Why are Israel's atrocities in a different league from Iraq's? Because Israel is *the US's watchdog in the Middle East". "In order to defend their oil supplies in the Gulf, Western powers have backed a state formed on the basis of the expulsion of the Palestinians..."
But how can that make sense? Israel has no oilfields. The West Bank, the Gaza Strip, the Golan Heights have no oilfields. Southern Lebanon has no oilfields. Israel does not directly facilitate Western control over any oil at all.
And when Iraq's invasion of Kuwait threatened US oil interests, the US did not turn to Israel to hit back on its behalf. On the contrary, the alliance it sought was with Turkey, Saudi Arabia, Egypt, Syria and other Arab states. It urged Israel to stay out of the conflict! Right now, Israel is a giant embarrassment for the US, and a major liability.
Just as the SWP assumes that Saddam's attack On Kuwait was anti-imperialist and propagates the idea by hints and half-thoughts, without ever actually arguing it, so here it assumes and propagates a pan-Arab nationalist viewpoint (Israel oppresses the Palestinians, the Palestinians are Arabs, Iraq is Arab, therefore Iraqi attacks on Israel are a blow for freedom) without arguing it.
Nowhere do the two pamphlets rise above the level of threading together strings of ¡lustrations to justify anti-imperialist* and anti-Israeli attitudes: they never attain the level of coherent argument.
----- pull-quotes -----
again, it vanishes!"