Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

A world of dog eat dog

Socialist Organiser no. 474, 6 February 1991 · scan p. 13 · about 737 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 13 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 13

Grifters ryters, a tale of small-time Gon merchants, is directed by Stephen Frears and produced by Martin Scorsese. The film is reminiscent of previous films by these two: Scorsese's Television BJ Siddon investigates th strange case of Inspector Morse and the TV detectives ong before the current (repeated) TV series of Inspector Morse, - read some of Colin Dexter's books. I didn't read many because they aren't very nice. The literary Inspector Morse isn't very nice, Goodfellas and Frears Dangerous Liaisons.

Grifters, like Goodfellas, is seedy and bloody, and resembles an old thriller movie. Not surprisingly, since it's taken from a 1950s pulp thriller. Grifters also contains some of the sexual friction that Frears did so well in the nicely unpleasant Dangerous Liaisons.

Two things go on in Grifters: sexual conflict between the main characters and quite a bit of general grifting (slang for conning) and either. Set amongst the dreaming spires Colin Dexter invariably finds squalor and soullessness.

The telly Morse is attractive to women, lonely and introspective. In the books his main interest women is sex (and because of his age, their availability. It is possible to imagine falling for John Thaw but never for Dexter's Inspector Morse. The telly character is based on the books, but the telly does not plumb the sordid depths of the books. Which is a good job really (for the producers) because it would be lousy entertainment. gangsterism.

Roy is the conman. Lily, Roy's mother, works for the mob. Myra, Roy's girlfriend, has a history of rather more impressive cons ("long cons') than Roy. She has now fallen on hard times. Lily dislikes Myra for sleeping with Roy. Lily and Roy are attracted to each other. Yes, it's a triangular story!

While the personal relations work themselves out amid stealing and skulduggery, the mob closes in on Lily. Lily has been ripping them off Agatha Christie's Poirot is brilliant entertainment. It does not have either the intellectual pretensions or the 'realism' of Inspector Morse. Consequently it raises far more interesting questions. Was ever a person so perfectly case for a role as David Suchet is for Poirot? If Hastings is living in the same flat as Poirot (as it appears) what, exactly, is their relationship, especially given Poirot's mincing walk? And why does Miss Lemon always get the out-of-period dialogue?

As if Poirot and Morse were not enough, the telly is also offering Devices and Desires (from PD James), The Ruth Rendell Mysteries and there are books. of Bergerac and Van Der Valk.

Spenser for Hire (Robert B Parker) and Perry Mason (Erle Stanley Gardner) were both on last year. Perry Mason is repeatedly described in the books as tall and lean. In the TV series he is played by a fat man. Spenser is supposed in the books to be intelligent, resourceful and macho. On telly he is a dumb wimp.

Devices and Desires the TV series is such a travesty of the original that I have only been able to watch it in 30-second bursts (the time it takes to leave the room). The Bergerac books are unreadable.

I can see that there is a case for the telly making literary works more accessible by adapting them for a different medium. But detective stories are amongst the most accessible printed words the and if they catch her they will kill her. The film slowly (rather too slowly at first) builds up to a crescendo, relying on atmosphere, flashbacks and one-liners to hold the audience's interest. This is quite cleverly done.

This is not a world of socialist cooperation — it's dog eat dog, and the weak and vulnerable lose out. Just like one of the more unpleasant sides of the real world, the story ends without the guilty suffering. Well, that's life.

Inspector Morse world. Sometimes, the telly takes what is written, focuses on a part of it, and builds something new and delightful. This has happened with Poirot.

But the most common reason for the proliferation of TV detectives is the battle for ratings (and money)

and the most common result is a levelling down of the books into a glossy sameness. Inspector Morse the book is much less attractive than Inspector Morse the TV series, but much more human.

The book of the TV series is nearly always unmitigated crap.

Why should the reverse be different? Do yourself a favour.

Read the book instead.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 474

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →