Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

1 glimpse of the backroom deals A Kinnock's-eye viet of the Labour Party

Socialist Organiser no. 474, 6 February 1991 · scan p. 12 · about 749 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 12

Phil Edwards (vice-chair, Socialist Society) continues the debate on PR Books Stan Crooke rev Rebuilt by Coli Patrick Wintour his book is sick glorificatic Kinnock and model party".

The bad guys in the book are, of course, anyone to the left of Genghis Khan. Benn supporters are portrayed as "intellectually stagnant and politically regressive' and the Benn-Heffer leadership challenge of 1988 is described as "two ageing stars completing the last date of an ill-advised comeback tour"

The left spends its time "chanting well-worn rubrics". It is guilty of having imprisoned the Labour Party in an "intellectual perma-frost" Calls to defy the poll tax are "sterile and ritualistic". Arguments over the defence of basic trade union rights are an unnecessary and time-consuming dispute". Attempts to defend unilateralism are equated with "a shameful insularity" and "an obsessive and superficial debate".

Right-wingers are portrayed in very different terms by the book's authors. Did you know, for example, that "the small featured handsomeness and released antipodean charm of Bryan Gould appeals perfectly to middle Britain"? Do the words "young, confident, ebullient and brimming with energy" spring to your mind when asked to describe Neil Kinnock?

*No other leading Labour Party figure," we are told, "could have been so systematically successful in persuading the party to change". Kinnock, the Great Helmsman, a sweetlyof Neil his *new *expended every last ounce of to heave the party to its feet".

But the book does offer an insight into the thoroughly manipulative way in which Labour's new model politics have been foisted onto the membership.

The reader of the book has a glimpse of the Party leadership's backroom deals with union bureaucrats in order to reach agreement on the preservation of Tory anti-union legislation.

The curtain is lifted on the tortuous and secretive process whereby the policy of unilateralism was ditched, and on how party statements such aS "Putting People First" were sent to the printers before they had been discussed by the National Executive Committee, never mind the membership.

The message of the book is that the views of the Party membership "The struggle of ordinary working class people - the NHS dispute of 1988 for example, for the mass non-payment of the poll tax — are equally absent from this book."

counted for nothing — neither in the eyes of the Party leadership nor in those of the book's authors. The latter define Kinnock's task as to "shove, cajole and arm-twist the Party". As far as responses from Party members to proposed policy changes were concerned, "none of it made much difference to the review groups' thinking"

This was hardly surprising. As Hughes and Wintour write: *The most important decisions influencing the outcome and management of the review were taken by Kinnock at the outset when he personally selected the members and convenors of the groups...He designed each group to ensure the kind of political mix which he believed would bring about the results he wanted."

Given the authors' obsequious desire to glorify "Kinnock's version of perestroika" (with the left playing the role of the Baltic states?), there are countless omissions in the book: the expulsion of Party members, the suspension of Labour Party Constituencies, the suspension of Labour councillors, the effective closure of the LPYS, the imposition of candidates on CLPs, the falling Party membership, the growing financial crisis of the Party, etc, etc.

None of this, of course, fits in with the description of Kinnock and his cronies as "preparing the Labour Party for survival into the twenty-first century."

The struggles of ordinary working-class people - the NHS dispute of 1988, for example, or mass non-payment of the poll tax - are equally absent from the pages of this book. If they are mentioned at all, it is only to dismiss them as a liability and obstacle to the Kinnockite project: *The 1984 miners' strike rubbed out the first year of Kinnock's leadership"

This epitomises the outlook of the book's authors and their less than credible hero. Workers' struggles are a diversion and a liability, just as the Party membership either merely so much voting fodder for manipulation or an irksome nuisance deserving only to be ignored.

But the central question provoked by the book is this: why is Tribune offering it as a free gift with a year's subscription to the paper? Is this a sign of the ultimate degeneration of Tribune? Or is it the only way the book's authors can divest themselves of their stocks of this unwelcome object?

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 474

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →