PR would not shackle Labour to the Liberals
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-02-06Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 12
•(SO 11 January) was justified, penetrating, well-written - and ruined by his final sideswipe at the Socialist Society, whom he accused of providing a home for disillusioned ex-Trotskyists (could we have some names?) and of aiming to "shackle Labour to the Liberals by means of proportional representation"
The Society's had worse insults - for example, the writer in Winter 1990's Socialist Action who described us as a trojan horse for European capital within the labour movement — but not manyFor what it's worth, we think that Labour would actually do better under PR; we certainly don't share Richardson's assumption that the only possible result of an election held under PR would be a repeat of the 1987 voting figures, and hence a Kinnock/Ashdown coalition. However, even if this were the case, our support for PR would not merit labelling us as a trojan horse for the Paddy Ashdown fan club.
For one thing, there is a principle involved. At present millions of people who vote for "minor" parties are effectively disenfranchised. Vladimir Derer has suggested (SO, 30 November) that the current system, by encouraging voters to choose one of the two major parties, encourages class polarisation.
Even if the current system did deliver this neat electoral division into two class protagonists - in southern England? in Scotland? - this argument would evince a dangerously instrumental view of democracy. "One person, one vote" is a principle with which few socialists would quarrel; "one person, one vote, one value" seems to be harder to swallow for some reason.
In any case, there are more practical reasons for doubting Richardson's prognosis that PR would equal a permanent Lib-Lab pact. Both the Liberal Democratic Party and the Liberal vote are creatures of the current electoral system. The tactical vote, which is unique to nonproportional electoral systems, has had a bigger part in the post-war Liberal vote than in that of any other party.
Given a system which didn't reward voting for the least-worst" candidate, much of the first-preference Liberal vote would evaporate overnight. (Interestingly enough, the Liberals' preferred form of PR - the Single Transferable Vote - tends to favour second preferences).
If the Liberal vote would suffer from PR, so too would the party. Systems which guaranteed catastrophe, making for a strong pressure for party unity regardless of political differences. This, as SO readers will not need reminding, fosters intolerance and suppression of debate in the name of "electability"
The present-day Liberal Democratic Party, unlike the Labour Party, is a wildly heterogeneous lash-up held together only by the knowledge that the party's hawks and doves, coporatists and decentralisers would fare even worse apart than together. Under PR this would cease to be the case; in place of Ashdown's Liberal Democrats - let alone Steel and Owen's Alliance - we would see a loose constellation of "Liberal" splinters, some of them, though not socialist, to the left of the Labour right on many issues. For Labour to be forced, by its inability to win a majority of the popular vote, to cooperate with forces such as those would certainly not be ideal; but it would hardly be the death-knell of socialism.
This, though, is a worstcase analysis. Labour's past failure to win 51% of the popular vote should be seen in the context of a structurally disempowering electoral system: if not every vote counts, what's the point of voting for change? Under PR electoral participation could be expected to rise, with disproportionate_benefit to parties of the Left.
Moreover, under PR the Green Party would be represented in parliament, and socialists who wished to found an electoral Socialist Party would be able to do so without the disastrous consequences the current system would impose. I can see no reason why Labour under PR should not be able to govern as the dominant partner in a coalition of the Left - no reason, that is, other than the conviction, which Vladimir Derer appears to share with Roy Hattersley, that nothing could stand in the way of a Labour monopoly of power.
This, though, is the tinal absurdity of the anti-PR argument. The fact is that under the current electoral system Labour has frequently shared power, generally with parties of the Right. Before the Lib-Lab pact there was the minority Labour government of 1974, kept in power by the votes of Ulster Unionists; in the "thirties Ramsay MacDonald was the Labour Prime Minister of a Tory government.
Looking back over Labour's fortunes under the current system — the paralysis induced by Wilson's dependence on a majority of three from 1964 to 1966; Labour's highest ever vote in 1951, resulting in a Tory victory; three elections won by a Tory as extreme as Thatcher on the basis of a bare forty percent plurality of the vote — I am amazed that it should be those who want to change it who are on the defensive.
The present system is bad for democracy; bad for working people; and bad for the Labour Party. It must be reformed, and socialists should be in the forefront of those campaigning for reform.
Scan page 13
er
----- pull-quotes -----
I Richardson's pole- A mic against Tariq Ali
penalise small parties turn any party split into a