Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Building a working class movement - or empty posturing? An open letter to an honest sectarian

Socialist Organiser no. 474, 6 February 1991 · scan pp. 10–11 · about 921 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

Dear Jeff Be had yet another very heated argument on the coach down to last week's Gulf demo. Quite possibly our row generated more heat than light and I accept my share of the blame for that.

But the matter at the heart of our disagreement is of crucial importance — how to build a principled, effective anti-war movement capable of mobilising the working I think it's worth pursuing my side of the argument in this form because you are a serious, honest socialist (I wouldn't necessarily say the same about the organisation to which you belong) and your views are fairly typical of quite a few would-be 'revolutionary' organisations and individuals.

Your case, as l understand it, can roughly summarised as follows: the basis any principled anti-war movement has to an understanding that the war is an act 'naked imperialist aggression', It theref follows that slogans such as 'Stop the War" or even "Troops Out Now' are inadequate. A principled campaign has to be based upon clear slogans along the lines of 'Victory to Iraq', 'No to Sanctions, Break the Blockade! Send Unconditional Aid to Iraq'. In other words, we need an explicitly "anti-imperialist' campaign.

I think we can agree that the US/ British side in the war are behaving in fairly classic "imperialist' fashion and that Iraq, even under Saddam Hussein, has a right to defend itself from invasion and subjugation. I know that we agree about the role of the UN in all this and that sanctions were never seriously intended as an alternative to war but as a preparation for it.

Our disagreement comes on whether an acceptance of this be the basis of the campaign precondition for joining it.

Whether we like it or not, most socialistminded workers who might naturally be inclined to oppose the war, do not accept our analysis. Many have illusions in the UN and sanctions; many more believe 'something has to be done about Saddam Hussein" I'm not talking about caricature Sun readers here; I mean the mass of honest, serious workers who think about the issues and are not particularly impressed by fancy sloganising and rhetoric about "imperialism'. These are the people we must win over if a real anti-war movement, capable of doing the matter of analysis must - indeed, a something to stop the war, is to be built.

Such people are not only not impressed by sloganising and rhetoric: they are positively repelled by it. They have genuine doubts and worries that need to be discussed, debated and — yes — even argued through. But just lecturing them about the evils of imperialism doesn't help here. And certainly, giving the impression that we give willy-nilly, blanket support to Saddam Hussein is guaranteed to drive them away.

Unfortunately, you and your comrades do exactly what I've just described. You may satisfy your personal need to be ever-so 'antiimperialist' and 'r-r-revolutionary' but to most workers you just make us all look like a bunch of bloody-thirsty wild, nutty people.

And, actually, such 'anti-imperialist' posturing is not even genuine ultra-leftism (in the way, for instance, that syndicalist supermilitancy is in industrial disputes); it's really a right wing deviation, giving support to petit-bourgeois nationalism, and displaying an astounding indifference to such things as the fascistic treatment of the Kuwaitis - not to speak of the Iraqis! — by Saddam Hussein.

None of the above is intended to give comfort to the middle-class pacifists who want to limit the anti-war movement to abstract pleas for 'peace' and outlaw serious, political debate within the movement; it is intended to wake people like you up to the need to conduct yourselves responsibly and Yours, to have some regard for the mass of working class people who are unhappy about the war but need to be won and convinced by our argument.

Not all their instincts - their dislike of Saddam Hussein and their concern for the lives of "our boys/girls" , for instance — are misplaced. The conclusions they may draw from such instincts are often wrong, but we need to relate to such sentiments, not simply denounce them or (almost as bad) reply with empty sloganising.

I can almost hear you growling with rage at such 'rightist' arguments, Jeff. As I've explained, it's not really me who is 'rightist" here — it's you. Read Lenin on 'Left Wing Communism' (yes, I know it's a much misused book, but it is relevant here or Trotsky on 'A Sectarian Caricature' or almost anything by James P Cannon. Or were they all right wing and soft on these matters?

Finally, you will note that I have deliberately avoided any mention of the issue that sparked our row: whether there can be any socialist justification for Saddam's missile attacks on Israel and whether the "Zionist state' has any right to defend itself under any circumstances. Frankly, I find your position on this revolting and — yes -objectively anti-semitic. Or perhaps we'd better stick to open letters.

Jim Denham.

Scan page 11

shipyards, 1943 FIGHT, WORK and Daily Worker ALLIES HAD "EVERYTHING portant atstement on the present rituation anything like it.

The strike was a resounding victory for the Barrow men, in spite of all. Their ability to win through in the face of such odds lay in the Socialist Organiser No. 474 page 11 demonstrated with placards outside the Hall, and leafletted other delegates as they went in, appealing to them to fight to make the Executive the servants of the member-

----- pull-quotes -----

AGAINST THE TIDE

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 474

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →