Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

New pamphlet dissects the lies

Socialist Organiser no. 474, 6 February 1991 · scan pp. 9–10 · about 1,665 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

Air started. oat drill" was held.

When the ship was hit the only ople who were properly escorted the boats were — the Nazis and sir officers. The refugees heard alarm, were given no instrucns, and in some cases were held Ck from rafts and boats at yonet-point.

Most of the refugees who managto get over the side simply clung bits of wood. The ship was in a avoy - 1½ hours steaming time ay from the nearest ship (a stroyer). But the Arandora Star it out no Mayday call and the vivors were not rescued until six urs after the ship had sunk. Had Arandora Star sent out an SOS, ny more lives would have been ted.

any tales of horror are told, quite rightly, of the Nazi concentration camps. Some the internees who set sail on the andora Star had escaped from h camps. They thought they te coming to a free country ose government and people were dged to fight Hitler and all he od for. far, far fewer people died as a alt of British internment than in cist camps. But they were the ne people - Jews, trade onists, communists. They were rned alongside their Nazi torers, and had to watch the Nazis better treatment from the tish than they did themseives. ey knew the Nazis wanted to kill m. They thought the British ated to help them. he refugees were probably the st well "classified" people in the intry. The government (until it berately "lost" them) probably better records of the refugees n it did about British seremen. But when it came to hun¡ for "traitors" the government lared the only course was "to ini the lot" t is possible, even probable, that ne of the refugees were spies. But y wouldn't have been very good s - with poor English, little edom of movement, no access to military or the civil service. Intil the beginning of 1940, the ernment had had a relatively nane attitude to refugees. What pened? he government argued that the sure of public opinion and "Aropinion" had forced the internits. But until the government -berately set about changing it, -lic opinion was sympathetic to refugees.

Mass Observation survey in i 1940 proved that the public, far as they knew about the gees, did not call for mass internment. But the same survey repeated a few months later showed that people had changed their minds. The change came after internment had begun, and after a press campaign vilifying all Germans, Austrians and Italians.

Papers like the Daily Mail carried leading articles, lumping the whole German people together, insulting them, and blaming them for Hitler. Stories included phrases like "the man and you cans never d SerBoche" , and concluded that mass internment was the only way of removing the threat.

The shift in public opinion was engineered by the very people (like Lord Rothermere, proprietor of the Daily Mail) who had been most vehemently against going to war with Hitler. These were the peole who supported Hitler's fight against "the Bolsheviks". The most ardent demands for internment came from the very people who had been the most ardent champions of appeasement before the war. Rothermere himself was an active supporter of the Mosleyite fascists in the mid-1930s.

"Army opinion"" was simply the opinion of the most senior officers, who reported to the Cabinet. Their opinion may have been based on panic after the fall of France, but more likely they were unable to distinguish between the Nazi party and the German people.

It was also easier for all the "decision-makers" and "opinion The shitish governments livinguhere reicher formongterminternment,# or -ar wordllike -execution., attheimhim pogovernment, withomt charges oweven mine right to know he pue suspected of.

pianned Ion Britishicities.

native Iraqis and those formers" to look for "fifth columnists" and "traitors" amongst foreign nationals than amongst themselves. The most likely traitors would be found in the ranks of the ruling class who were friendly with Hitler before the war. Many such people thought Britain was fighting "the wrong war" — we should have been fighting with Hitler against Stalin.

he truth is that there was no good reason for interning these thousands of refugees. There was no excuse for keeping them in such inhuman conditions. The policy and practice of internment in World War 2 has never been explained or apologised for by successive governments and remains shrouded in secrecy.

It was a disgraceful episode, and the longer the Gulf war continues, the more likely it is to be repeated. Categories of Arabs other than Iragis and Palestinians may become "enemy nationals" if alliances shift in the war, as they may well shift. The current government has little regard for civil rights in peacetime, it is likely to become more authoritarian as the war progresses. Newspapers like the Sun would be quite happy to scream "intern the lot!" and all Iraqi nationals, pro-Saddam and anti-Saddam, would be at risk.

Incompetence, racism and bureaucracy will do the rest.

• Statistics from Francois Lafitte, The Internment of Aliens Palestenhans whomevereleil WI notabe errestern cham ed convictions amoull be Internments thout aal, ів сотов в irerm andi wes Russ erand South A micato state of ent Gerry Bates reviews the new Socialist Organiser pamphlet, War in the Gulf: Issues for Labour This pamphlet - dissects and destroys the lies and propaganda used to justify the atrocious war in the Gulf.

The war is not about liberation or democracy. It is about US and Western control of oil.

It is not a step towards a harmonious "new world order" but a step back into revived colonial or semi-colonial imperialism. The US and Britain are not fighting just about Kuwait, but about US-British political and military control the strategic oil area It will not be — is already proving not be - a quick, "surgical" police action, taking out Saddam Hussein and then leaving the region free and peaceful. The war will be long and bloody; and it is breeding the conditions for further wars. The US's attempt to re-establish semi colonial power in the Gulf cannot fail to lead to further clashes between it and Arab nationalist movements.

The war is not an enforcement of the authority of international law; the United Nations has been dragged in as a rubber-stamp for US imperialism by the balance of power politics, and nothing loftier.

The US and Britait do not represent democracy in the region, as against the tyranny of Saddam Hussein. On the contrary - as a section of the pamphlet on the history of imperialism in Arabia shows the US and Britain have been imperialist tyrants, or the imperialist backers of local tyrants, in the region for over 150 years. Iraq won real independence from Britain as recently as 1958.

The pamphlet also takes a cold and critical look at the actions and apologies of Saddam Hussein. Il traces the logic of war and police-state terror in Iraq - "the Middle East's first totalitarian society" - and condemns Iraq's seizure of Kuwait. Saddam's appeals to Arab unity it describes as "cynical, self-serving PEACE-JOBS "Peace, Jobs" - Labour Party slogans from the early *80s. But Kinnock now back and demagogic".

Cutting through the lies and apologetics of the governments on both sides, the pamphlet carves an independent working class viewpoint which is also distinctive on the left.

The majority view of the Western left is summed up on CND's ›lacards: "Ceasefire, Sanctions, Negotiate", But effective sanctions would mean an economic blockade light enough to strangle Iraq's economy. An economic blockade that tight would mean military force to stop trade - and to strike back when Iraq tried to break the blockade: In short, it would mean war.

Economic sanctions are an attractive policy o many on the Western left because hey seem to respond to the feeling that "something must be done about Saddam Hussein" while avoiding the horrors of war. But they are not a coherent ilternative to war; an is "something" to be *done about Saddam Hussein" they cannot se evaluated in the abstract, without regard to who is "doing something", governed by what Interests and motives.

Since August, it has been the imperialist US and its allies "doing something", in the interests of Western oil power and not of democracy or liberation.

The other common view on the left is "pro-Iraqi" where the CND view is implicitly pro-Western.

War in the Gulf is also "pro-Iraqi" in the sense that it supports the defence of Iraq against the American-led blitzkrieg. But it draws a distinction between the defence of Irag and support for Saddam's ambitions and acts of aggressions, a the war. Photo: John Harris distinction not respected by many on the lett.

and Militant, for example, support Iraq not only in its nationa self-defence but also in its seizure of Kuwait and (SW) in its attacks on Israel.

Even Socialist Outlook, which has been much better on this issue than SWor Militant, declares in its latest "Gulf war special" that "the Ba'athist government [in Iraq], in however distorted a way, is an Arab nationalist force Arab nationalism sinc World War 2 has meant continual conflict [with] the aims of imperialism. This is rather like Outlook's view that the old Stalinist states in Eastern Europe were *in however distorted a way" workers' states.

Obviously the Iraqi government is Iraqi nationalist. But to imply that it is doing anything real, in however distorted a way" ', to unify and liberate the Arab peoples, is to conceds to Saddam's demagogy.

The pamphlet also contains the text of the moving speech made by Eric Heffer when, despite grave illness, he went to Parliament to speak against war in September last year, and an article by Leor Trotsky which casts light on many of the underlying theoretical • 75p plus 17p postage from SO, Box 823, London SE15 4NA.

Scan page 10

ganiser OUR H

----- pull-quotes -----

Duringna weed Ba şcrutiny Sable Hussedn

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 474

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →