After truth, another casualty: civil rights
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-02-06Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
Brütsir hesze long end notorions disteny or interning political opponents_ mostarerzrdlmia Iredend u Britann Anvented Ithemapder cpncpatrathon acampıuduringuthesBoemverz9D yearszagpımterningo Borruwomen mud chlldrenen By interning and de porting many Arabs living | lereincluding long-time opponents nf Cadilam Huccain - the Ul Dalual British government is following a shameful example set by its internment of Germans and Italians World War 2. Liz Mill tells the story Of the millions who fled (or tion in the 1930s and '40s, a few thousand were admitted to Britain.
Those refugees who did come here were admitted entirely through the efforts of voluntary bodies who promised to support them.
The majority of refugees were Jewish, and it was due to Jewish organisations in Britain that they were able to reach Britain at all. The British government insisted that refugees could only come if thev would not be a "charge on public funds" . This meant that BAANJ refugees had to overcome mountains of bureaucracy when conditions in Europe hardly allowed for patience.
Despite the red tape there seems to have been a tremendous response from charities and voluntary bodies to provide the labour and money necessary to bring the refugees here.
Various civil servants "oversaw" the work of the voluntary organisations, but the government's policy was to prevent refugees settling in Britain. Yet, by September 1939, over 70,000 refugees were "registered" with the voluntary organisations which had promised to support them.
The largest such body was the Central Council for Jewish Refugees, which was responsible for about 80% of all the refugees. The Central Council spent several million pounds bringing the refugees from Europe and supporting them once here. All the money was donated by private citizens.
Once in Britain the refugees were subject to categorisation. They were all interviewed at least once — and here the government did step in. Refugees were divided into categories A, B and C: As were interned, Bs had various restrictions on their freedom, and Cs could go free. In addition, all refugees were divided, whatever their category, into "victims of Nazi oppression" and others.
Is the Nazi terror increased in A Germany and Austria, the British public became increasingly sympathetic to the plight of the refugees. Some restrictions were lifted and children in parmorderoust, unbend by condilons, An internment camp in Britain, 1940 ticular were accepted numbers.
Some of the refugees (in category C) were allowed to take jobs. Several started businesses - in some cases employing hundreds. Students and academics were found places in colleges, and others helped the war effort in science, medicine. farming, industry and in "pioneer battalions" . With the exception of the people waiting to re-emigrate (mainly to the USA and Palestine] the refugees began to integrate inte British society.
At the beginning of 1940 al category B refugees were to be re interviewed with a view to removing the restrictions on them. It wa: generally accepted that the Bs were the "don't know" category, anc that most of them had been unfairl! treated. But almost before the inter views had started, thousands of the refugees were interned without war ning.
People were taken from thei jobs and homes by police and arm! in May 1940. Secrecy surrounder the internments, and many of thi refugees were not even allowed tr contact relatives and friends befor being taken to camps.
There was little rhyme or reasor to the internments, and there is ne evidence that the instruction to in tern various classes of people wa partıcularly detailed. Initially i "protection" zone was declares around the South and East coasts and refugees were expelled from it Many such refugees were then in terned a few days later because having just moved, they wer unemployed and without anyone to vouch for them. Providing they were under 70, sick and disabled men could be interned - and often were.
The cry of "intern the lot" was raised in both media and parliament, and overnight refugees from Nazi terror were transformed into "fifth columnists", "Quislings" and traitors.
By the end of July 1940, 30,000 enemy aliens" had been interned. But the internment itself was well organised and humane compared to what came afterwards.
Once in the custody of police or army, the internees were totally cut off from the outside world. They were stripped of possessions and money. Their papers, passports, visas — all forms of identification, were taken from them. Many of the refugees, if not a majority, never saw these things again.
No proper record of the internees' names or whereabouts was kept by anyone. When the internees arrived at camps or transit points they could not prove who they were or what their status was. Their families could not locate them.
These were people about whom the state knew everything. They had been granted visas, interviewed and classified. But in a few short weeks all the information was so muddled that no one could say with any confidence who, or where, any of the internees were.
The vast majority of the internees were genuine refugees - Jews, socialists, political activists. A minority were prisoners of war — Nazis, loyal to Hitler. Nazis and anti-Nazis were mixed up, in some cases having to share rooms and even beds.
Medical treatment for the old and sick was non-existent in the camps. Conditions were appalling: accommodation in tents, racecourse buildings, old warehouses, buckets for sanitation, no beds or mattresses, inadequate food, overcrowding, damp, no contact with the outside world, no information. Many of these people had escaped from Nazi concentration camps. They knew that France had handed all the foreign nations over to Hitler after the surrender, after first rounding them up and interning them. In France then there were many tens of thousands of Spanish Republicans, who had lost the recently-ended Spanish Civil War.
Britain's internees had no idea what had happened to their wives and families - and no-one would tell them what was going on. The following is an account from a man interned at Huyton, Lancashire (24 July 1940):
*So much has happened until today that it would fill the pages of a tragic novel. Another suicide, a man who became mad and many who turned melancholic. We are afraid now that they might attempt suicide. Another transport with unknown destination is being arranged for. They say that all men between the ages of 20 and 50 will be deported. This caused great unrest. A meeting was called and the named men protested at being deported and leaving their wives and children behind in uncertainty. We decided rather to be shot than to be deported...
The internees were kept in degradation and uncertainty. It is difficult to see how things could have got worse, short of systematic murder (the internees were already dying of disease caused by the conditions)But things did get worse. The deportation of the internees began. On 2 July 1940 a ship called the Arandora Star, with 1,500 German and Italian internees was sunk on its way to Canada. Over half the internees drowned. This was bad enough. The attempt to cover up the disaster was even worse. T Star had been sunk carving he news that the Arandora internees was first broken to the press. The families of the passengers did not even know that their relatives had left Britain. Until they read the newspapers the relatives and friends of the refugees did not know that deportations were even taking place.
Secondly, no-one in authority knew who, exactly, was on the ship, who had drowned and who survived. Anthony Eden, British Minister for War, claimed that all the passengers were category A internees, and further claimed that they were therefore all Nazis. But many category A internees were anti-Nazis, people who had struggled all their lives against fascism.
To add insult to injury, the government proposed to •communicate a list of the missing to the Nazis in Germany "so that the next of kin could be informed". The next day, while still claiming that all the drowned men were fascists, the government admitted that it had only a "nominal" list of the passengers, but said that the list would be passed to the refugee organisations - again, so that the next of kin could be informed.
If the dead men were all Nazis, the refugee organisations would not need to be told. In fact, many of the passengers were anti-Nazis, and only the most bumbling incompetence (or malice) would have passed a list of them to the Nazis, or be so unsure of who or what they were.
The survivors were bundled on to other ships and out of the country within days of their rescue, before they had the chance to tell their story.
Again neither they nor their relatives were told. Again, Nazis and anti-Nazis were mixed up and deported together.
When the first survivor did manage to tell his story the reasons for the cover-up became clearer. The internees had been herded onto the ships at gunpoint. Some had been made to "volunteer" through bribery with money, others by being told that their wives and children would be in the same convoy, others were told that if they did not go, their places would be taken by older, sick men who would not survive the journey.
The ship was not equipped to carry the internees - once more accommodation was overcrowded and inhuman. There were only enough lifeboats for the crew and the accompanying soldiers. No
Scan page 9
Where we stand