The failure of Gorbachev's reforms
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-02-06Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
Bae collapise of the centre ne gron l00 eth0 COniL Es ground in ihe-Cenine Asipn Moscow have ended supplying the - nex s ewe umren andl the DuD SANS pe enne tam, mod inm rei au for rai the nationalist Rukh ear not to allow non-Muscovites to velit hun herm HACECOHEO Shppwp nscaw. on the - pak! are ent endis Byelorussia, which exports 80% routinely ignores Soviet legislation exporting meat, as a retaliation for the moves towards independence, tankerde ither krea mup mi itherpper hoilga paden eup.
OYCE Nagorny mor ingito warde e imari and towards Scandinavia and GerKarabakh in 1987, Georgia is well ace much more r'apir many.
Soviet epuble aTesenG and the growing food shortages Georgia itself, the national Yegereptepere pato contit expor thus reinforce each other. Under South Ossetians are pressing for in- ood produce to other Soviet movements different depeenence. epub esc republics have cut back their expopulation die dine matertto theiest on th other consumer goods. At the same Soviet Union. Uzbekistan: : and time, the growing shortages have the republic. ISt 15 AAL pari movements ere conindin g onerin and many Mregippe imnd to the support for separatism. vouchers for tours abroad in the Russian republic. The going exchange rate is four kilogrammes of meat for one bottle of vodka. More and more enterprises are paying wages in the form of goods in kind, via plant shops or mailorder catalogues, rather than in roubles.
Rather than sell their production for cash and then attempt to purchase commodities with the money from the sale, a number of cities and even republics find it safer to use barter: Königsberg swaps fish for pipes for heating systems; Karelia swaps wood for food; Uzbekistan swaps cotton for food; and Moscow swaps various products for tomatoes.
Why are there such shortages? 15% of Soviet agricultural production rots in the fields because it is not harvested at the appropriate time. Of the rest, a further 60% autonomy or outright independence Thee prov iden ae ort and economic crisis in the Soviet Union.
er seased Russian populations have opposed KANCI ing achieved.
Armenia and Azerbaidzhan have srrcenane seruptn olaches aşoniika dependence from Moscow. Within In MolDar LOW re-named, HOldI the Romanian majority PR idürseıw fbıym iMnssp gaw erki nanon shiploads of flour, meat and sugar were standing idle in Leningrad. Even when food finally reaches the shops there is no guarantee that it will get as far as the shelves. In many shops staff hoard food in the back rooms and sell it privately at inflated prices whilst the shelves remain bare.
The food shortages are made even worse by the activities of criminal gangs and of certain sections of the Stalinist apparatus opposed to Gorbachev's reforms (though there is often a very thin dividing line between the two. The gangs limit the amount of foodstuffs reaching the shopshelves and the markets in order to keep prices high and thereby maximise their profits. The Stalinists block and hold up supplies of food in order to promote popular discontent and thereby reinforce dissatisfaction with government policies. no w conso hah tastası mail. of Lithuania, Ing the-hearw have Union tih é Russian Soviet more futile than ever.
Production TELECES and of civil war aRdale he Buseis and ang aer nine notren onu and La inaner pag ned | thệu Tood mect ,oyer en ded The economic reforms implemented since Gorbachev came to power in 1985 have proved to be irrelevant or counterproductive.
The greater freedom from centralised control given to Soviet enterprises and the growth of cooperatives' (ie. small-scale private enterprise) have generally added to the problems rather than solving them.
Enterprises have exploited the relaxation of centralised control to switch production from lowprofitability goods (especially basic consumer goods for children and pensioners) to goods on which they Moscows decision in June or last INIlMe of its production of televisions and fridges to other Soviet republics, HA SONIN hasanponncedpla wuture aft the decision of the central planners' to reduce deliveries of animal TỈI MG MIRASI NO VARUNS нАГрійнокЕпе SI ME MOw otber Soviet republies. mine Ergnemiets in mil vocatei a completes СЕ-N republic, traderaway коми рекор' benım mang maçinag influence of nationalist dro tonnen gorgus ntént sendr nel expect to realise a higher rate of profit. Cooperatives have sought the most pressing gaps in the market and exploited them by charging inflated prices. This is especially so in the case of foodstuffs.
As for joint ventures with foreign companies: only 7% of the nominally agreed 13,000 or so joint ventures have actually got off the ground, and few of those are involved in manufacturing.
Attempts to improve the quality of output have resulted in fewer consumer goods reaching the shops (as more goods are rejected by quality control in the factories), cuts in workers' wages (as workers lose their bonuses dependent upon the achievement of the production target), and more blockages in the supply and distribution network (as warehouses are filled up with the rejected output).
Yet there has been no improvement in the quality of output: in 1985, 900,000 tape recorders were returned for repair during their guarantee period; by 1988 the figure had risen to 1.2 million - a fifth of the total output.
Attempts to crack down on alcoholism and improve labour Azerbaidzhan: "on the brink of civil war" crates of coffee, 18 sacks of groats, and also 25,000 packs of cigarettes), the director's excuse was: "But I was only getting ready for the transition to a market economy"
The PEC provides, at a price, the foodstuffs and consumer goods otherwise in short supply (often because of the operations of the PEC itself). Meat is sold at 25 to 30 roubles a kilogramme, eggs at up to 20 roubles for ten, and a bottle of vodka at 25 roubles. Pornographic magazines such as Playboy and Penthouse fetch 150 roubles.
Application forms for visas cost 15 roubles. On a larger scale, a oneroomed flat in Moscow can be bought for up to 25,000 roubles, and a two-room apartment for up to 70,000 roubles.
However, for transactions in the PEC the preferred currency is the American dollar. There are now an estimated two billion dollars in circulation in the Soviet Union, the equivalent of 40 billion roubles at the PEC rate of exchange.
27% of the Soviet population buy clothes and shoes in the PEC, and a further 15% buy food in the PEC Every third rouble of profit in the PEC is 'reinvested' in bribes to officials. In the trade in foodstuffs and consumer commodities in the PEC an estimated 112 billion roubles is in circulation, nearly a quarter of the total volume of money in circulation in the Soviet Union.
When the income from drugs, prostitution, extortion and foreign currency speculation is added, the total amount is 170 billion roubles, a third of the volume of money in circulation.
Attempts by the authorities to crack down on economic crime have been unsuccessful. In the big cities in particular the criminal gangs often know of impending raids before they are carried out. The government has therefore resorted to using the KGB to combat economic crime.
In November 1990 the Supreme Soviet ordered the KGB to organise a campaign against economic sabotage and to control the distribution of imported goods. According to KGB vice-chair Victor Grushko: "In their opinion (ie. official and business circles in the West) ours is one of the few Soviet organisations which still has its integrity and is not corrupt. Chekists are experienced in protecting the most vital branches of our economy and transport, and know the real situation there."
Scan page 7
has failed