Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

No War the Gue

Socialist Organiser no. 473, 30 January 1991 · scan p. 16 · about 544 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 16 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 16

If Neil Kinnock had campaigned against the war, the first demonstration would have been not five thousand, but fifty or five hundred thousand. Photo: Mark Salmon have been not tive thousand, but tity or against war, the campaign could have transformed that feeling into a force. And that could have made a difference.

According to the Financial Times and the Economist - both pro-war - Britain was the only country where there was a fairly solid majority for war before 15 January. The majority for war in public opinion was narrow; but in the "political class" , in the media, and in Parliament, it was enormous.

Opinion in the US was much more divided. Congress approved the war only very narrowly. Memories of Vietnam made for sober thinking - and not only with the calculations that the costs for American capitalism would outweigh the benefits.

Yet the decision was swung for war. And heavy among the factors giving weight to the push for war must have been the unswerving, solid, reliable support for that war drive from another country - and, as it happened, only one other country, Britain.

What if Britain had responded like Germany, for example — the labour opposition standing against the war, and the conservative government's support for George Bush consequently very tepid, and qualified by an eager eye to every possible get-out? War would have been much less likely.

It was within the power of the Labour Party leadership to make sure that Britain did respond in a divided, weak way to Bush's appeals for support. If Neil Kinnock had campaigned against war, the first demonstration against war would have been not five thousand handead shaucand Photo Mark Salmon strong, but fifty or five hundred thousand.

Yet Neil Kinnock did not once divide Parliament against the Tories on the war issue. He did not once appear on television to debate against the Tories on their push to war.

The "soft left" could have changed that. The "soft left" could have told Neil Kinnock that he must choose between opposing war and seeing half his Shadow Cabinet and more than half the PLP defy him. Who knows, faced with such an ultimatum, Neil Kinnock might even have rediscovered his longdisused faculty of thinking for himself on an issue, and saying what he thought, instead of just mouthing what the PR people say will sound most safe, respectable, statesmanlike, and inoffensive.

In any case there would have been much stronger opposition than the brave stand of Tony Benn and a few others on the "hard left" and a few quiet resignations at the 13th hour by "soft lefts" (Maria Fyfe, John McFall, John Battle, Tony Banks)., It wasn't done. You and the "soft left" played "safe" -"safe" for you, that is, murderously unsafe for tens of thousands of people in the Middle East. You allowed yourselves to be fobbed off with meaningless words from Neil Kinnock and Gerald Kaufman. The words in Neil Kinnock's Parliamentary speech just before 15 January about wishing that sanctions could be given more time were weightless when combined with the clear statement that he would support the government in immediate war anyway.

The support

----- pull-quotes -----

among radicals or left-wingers. Many conservatives opposed war

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 473

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →