Glasgow guards' victory
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-01-30Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 15 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 15
ASLEF, West of Scotland The second 24-hour strike by guards at Queen Street on Monday 14 January led to a partial climbdown by management on the issue of promotion of five guards to drivers positions.
An initial offer of £12,000 for each guard was rejected on the basis that this was tied to an agreement that the guards would proceed to an appeal and only if they failed this appeal would compensation by granted.
The RMT called for a ballot of all guards in the RMT in the Scottish Region which took place on Friday 19 January, to ensure convinced. Even Congress House officials privately admit that the proposals are "pretty weak" and full of potential dangers (like, what if employers use the 'step-by-step' approach to de-recognise unions?). What about employers who simply get rid of anyone who joins a union?
At a TUC General Council meeting On January 23, no agreement was reached, suggesting that some General Secretaries don't see the proposal as a Stealth, so much as a Tornado — just too easy to shoot down.
he bizarre saga of the TGWU • tinues. As you may know, ballot-rigging scandal conknow, when evidence of an attempt to introduce some 9,000 fraudulent ballot papers into last year's NEC elections came to light, General Secretary Ron Todd immediately stopped the elections, and ordered an internal union investigation.
When this failed to bring the culprit(s) to light, Todd brought in the cops and gave them a copy of his own report into the matter.
Since then, the union's well-organised right wing have been doing their best to spread the story that the ballot-rigging was the work of the union's Broad Left (which presently has a 22-17 majority on the NEC). The right has been aided in the promotion of all members who had passed the appropriate tests as agreed in the "Transport Concept Agreement'.
However, Monday's action was then called off pending talks with management.
The only clear outcome of the talks was the acceptance of the original figure of £12,000 each with possible payment at the higher drivers rate with the guards remaining guards.
Although nobody wants to see anybody driving trains with alcohol problems, the strike was mainly about making adhere to agreements, and not letting "suitability clauses being introduced retrospectively in breach of the Agreement.
The RT and its rank and file guards should be clear about the importance of the Transport Concept Agreement if new rules are proposed in the aftermath of this strike.
this campaign by a number of reports in the national papers, all of which refer to Todd's internal report. But only two copies of this report originally existed — Todd's personal copy and the one he handed over to Inspector Knacker.
So how is it that the secretaries of the union's Regions 1, 4, 5, 8 and 11 all have copies of the report? It turns out that Inspector Knacker sent them out to the Regional Secretaries who had been particularly co-operative and they (or at least, one of them) sent further copies out to the press.
Todd (not surprisingly) has hit the roof at this iatest example of treachery by the right wing regionai barons. He (rightly) sees it as part of a build-up of smears and innuendos intended to jeopardise the chances of his chosen successor, Bill Morris, in this year's General Secretary election.
Todd has actualiy conducted himself quite well throughout this affair. But his obsession with keeping the report secret has played into the hands of the TGWU right, allowing them to smear the union's Broad Left on the basis of no evidence at all. Todd should have realised that he's up against some very dirty opponents. His best bet would have been to have published the report and trusted the membership to draw their own conclusions.