When bad politics makes bad art
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-01-30Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 12
Scene from Hidden Agenda Sean Matgamna "The book is devoted to the Chinese revolution... A fine and well-knit style, the discriminating eye of an artist, original and daring observation - all confer upon the novel an exceptional importance. If we write about it here it is not because the book is a work of talent, although this is not a negligible fact. but because it offers a source of political lessons of the highest value. Do they come from Malraux? No, they flow from the recital itself, unknown to the author, and they go against him. This does honour to the author as an observer and an artist, but not as a revolutionist. However, we have the right to evaluate Malraux too from this point of view; in his own name and above all in the name of Garine, his other self, the author does not hesitate with his judgments on the revolution.
This book is called a novel. As a matter of fact, we have before us a romanticised chroni cle of the Chinese revolution...
(Leon Trotsky, "The Strangled Revolution", February 1931 - commenting on Andre Malraux's novel "Les Conquerants").
hdanov (mentioned in Charlie Murray's letter, SO 472) was Stalin's ideological and cultural policeman in the 1940s.
He proclaimed that Soviet art had to serve state-decreed goals and that it should be produced in conformity with, and in the service of, the ruling Stalinist ideology. It was the job of the ideological police of the totalitarian state, backed by the political police, to enforce this ruling; and they did. Charlie Murray can't possibly be accusing me of wanting some system like that, so I'm not sure what his very laconic letter meant to accuse me of.
Hidden Agenda is an explicitly political film. Its subject is politics, and it is shaped — indeed, made lumpy and twisted! — to make it a vessel able to carry the makers' views on the political subjects dealt with. With their blinkered propaganda they come close to "voluntary Zhdanovism". Charlie Murray seems to me to be "dangerously close" to equating with Stalinism all political judgment and assessment of anything presented as a work of art — even when, as in this case, it is a work of political propaganda thinly fictionalised.
The crime of Stalinism against art was to try to make art a handmaiden of politics and a slave to the various dogmas peculiar to Stalinism and to the bureaucratic social class that Stalin represented - that is, to make art a mere illustration of predetermined propaganda.
It stifled living art within prescribed forms favoured by the top bureaucrats, forms to which the bureaucratic pope and his cardinals ascribed an imaginary significance. In fact this was often a matter of semi-ignorant bureaucrats erecting their own taste in art and music into a rigid, arbitrarily-prescribed standard for everyone and for all time: for example, Beethoven and mid 19th century painting, given a quasi-religious Stalinist gloss.
And - as the prerequisite for everything else — Stalinism locked art and music, like the whole of society, within a totalitarian state repression. The Stalinist treatment of art was regulated by the state's need to dominate everything, its need to paralyse the collective mind of society, rather than by artistic or literary concerns.
To go from condemnation of Stalinism to rejecting all political judgment or criticism, even of crude propagandist "art" like Hidden Agenda, is to rule out politics completely. It is, in general, to abandon an important part of the ideological struggle.
Or does Charlie Murray object to the comment in my article that Loach's film proves that you can't have revolutionary art without revolutionary Marxist theory? That was overstated and one-sided. What I wanted to say would have been better put with the qualification "conscious revolutionary art".
For, of course, it is true that you can have revolutionary art produced even by reactionaries. Marx once explained that about the novels of Honore de Balzac, who wrote honestly and truthfully about French society in the first halt of the 19th century and thereby, said Marx, produced revolutionary art, though in politics Balzac was a pretty thorough reactionary.
And not only on Balzac's level. Erle A Stanley Gardner's Perry Mason stories have — to go by two or three I've read - characters a great deal more stiff and one-dimensional, and stories more mechanical, than most other mass-sale detective writing — and yet Gardner's portrayal of the system of American justice, with conniving attorneys and an irresponsible collusive press, is a startlingly radical (and, I believe, true) picture of reality. Believe it, and scales will fall off your eyes.
Without being consciously revolutionary or Marxist, you could produce a truthful, and therefore, in Marx's sense above, revolutionary, work of art about Northern Ireland. The real John Stalker proves the point in his own way - that truth is revolutionary - and he wasn't trying to write fiction or be a revolutionary!
But, conversely, you can set out to be very revolutionary, in a sincere spirit of devotion to socialism, to the working class, and to Irish freedom, but set out so loaded down with preconceptions and prejudices that you cannot comprehend reality. You don't even try: instead you use facets of reality to illustrate wnat you already know, maug land.. Sland mabina not an honest objective exposition of your subject, but a "commercial" for your political prejudices.
You can veer so enormously from what Marx described in Balzac - truth, honest recording — that you do not depict reality at all. You destructure and fillet reality to fit your own dogmas and preconceptions. You get from your false revolutionary dogmas not a Balzacian-revolutionary relationship to reality, but the relationship of someone who erects aspects of the reality into dogmas through which to try to "view" the whole, instead of experiencing and assessing it in a fresh and open way. That is what Loach and Allen get, looking at Ireland through old dogmas and outmoded ideas, sustained by a culpable suppression of outstanding facts (their entire viewpoint depends on the pretence that two thirds of Northern Ireland's population does not exist). Hidden Agenda does illustrate the point I made, even though I expressed it inadequately. For the conscious would-be revolutionary artist, dealing with a subject about which he or she holds finely worked out, emotionally charged ideas, there is — outside of accidents and serendipity - no artistic practice without revolutionary theory, that is, fresh Marxist understanding of the reality he or she is consciously trying to recreate and reconceptualise as a revolutionary artist. Perhaps I generalise too sweepingly here, yet again: but I have no doubt it is the truth about what went wrong with Hidden Agenda.
Over to you, Charlie Murray...
Scan page 13
ey shoot children don't they?
Street children of Brazil. Here, too, these children have been Oh that this pen could heal the minds of women, men That Love and Peace could transfuse their veins That hearts could pump these words around in chains Lock the hatred out that feeds their minds to boil Oh that these words could stop their cries of •Blood for Stop now the Death drums beating from the West Those who think they've played their only Ace should ti Players, jokers on their decks — all B-astard 52 of them Televisi here are many programmes make you cry. Films like My Left Foot, documentaries on the brave struggle of AIDS sufferers to survive, and so on. Everyman's They Shoot Children, Don't They was not one. A lump in the throat, even tears, are not adequate responses to this film.
It is a documentary about children living on the streets of Guatemala, surviving only by sniffing glue to blot out reality and hold hunger at bay; preyed upon by right-wing police squads who kidnap, torture and murder them.
Guatemala was described by the commentator as "a new democracy" . Can this be so? Is it possible to describe a society in which seven or eight year old children have their eyes burnt out and their tongues and ears cut off before being kicked to death and dumped on a rubbish tip a "democracy"?
Guatemala fairly recently was kitted out with a parliament and elections. In reality the army still rules, but elections give illusions that working class people have a say in how society is run. What goes on in between is beyond their control. This is bourgeois democracy.
The film showed how attempts are being made to bring the policemen responsible to justice. The records of those on duty have been tampered with, identities changed, witnesses and even judges too frightened to turn up to the courts to give or hear the evidence. The police get off.
At my first anti-war meeting a couple of weeks ago, a young man stood up and said: "The Westerr governments say they are going into the Middle East to defend democracy. How dare they preach to the Middle East about democracy. Look at London. Look at New York. Rape, murder, robbery, hunger and homelessness. Is this your democracy? You can keep it. I want no part of it."
Bourgeois democracy describes the mechanisms of the system - the way it is run - not the horrors that go on within it. And there are grades of this democracy, grades of horrors. I would rather live in the London so eloquently described by the young man than be a child of the Guatemalan street. Nevertheless, it is the same system - the same "democracy". A democracy that I want no part of either.
Oh that the ink could flow from her to them Oh send the war birds back to their home nest Sucklings still, who once embraced the breast - now embrace the orders of sick men Oil wells suckle them.
Oh that a mother's milk could be expressed And stored within the wells in place of oil Then weanlings would take flight, desert The cards of peace would then upon the tal Then justice could begin to surge and swell I am not mad, still, for all my hopes - I can smell Hell. beaten to death by vigilante groups.
Democracy is not a dirty word. It has been made dirty by the bourgeoisie. But even that is better than dictatorship, feudalism, or military rule.
The young man ended his speech by saying "I speak for Islam" . But the system ruled by god is not a democracy and will not stop the murders, the rapes, the abuse of children.
Many people will blame their mothers. Why are they letting them turn to the streets? Or their families: why don't they keep their children at home?
I don't blame the mothers, or the families. I blame the system. I don't ask god to sort it out, either. We have to take the responsibility for changing society into our own hands: the ordinary people, the working class, the mothers and the families - the people who have been fobbed off with a vote every Jenny Evans E CULTURAL FROM once in a while in the name of democracy, while they live in hell.
Our version of democracy is different. It is good. It is one in which ordinary people rule: in which police, politicians, administrators, officers are accountable to the peoMike Grayson Havana Cuba, Christmas 1958. A of revolution. Dictator Batista's secret police terrorise the population...and history again becomes a backdrop for director Sydney Pollack's favourite theme of mismatched lovers finding brief happiness before the inevitable separation.
The basics: Robert Redford plays Jack Weil, gambler, loner and Very Boring Person. Lena Olin plays Bobbi — a glamorous, Swedishborn revolutionary (stop laughing). No one else plays any character sufficiently defined to be worth mentioning.
Jack and Bobbi meet and get the hots for each other. But they are torn apart by the unlucky circumstance that Bobbi's husband turns out to be not as dead as we were led to believe.
Yes, I am deliberately ple who put them there, and are removable when they fail, immediately. Our kind of democracy is one in which the weakest in society - the children - are protected by us all, not preyed upon. No god can do that for us. No individual, If you want to know who Castro was, don't go and see this film the film's ending so that you will not waste your money going to see it. It's for your own good, believe me.
The Bobbi character makes a very unconvincing revolutionary. We never get any real insight into why she turned away from a wealthy background to help Castro.
Her poor, disenfranchised mother do it, just for her own children have to do it ourselves for the u of society. Don't cry when yo this programme. Don't waste ears. Determine, instead, to or real, workers" democracy.
Looking well-coiffed and manicured at all times, to me she suggests a vision of someone sprinting to the barricades by way of the beautician's, pausing only to grab pistol and eye-shadow.
Her political convictions do not, however, run all that deep since she quickly accepts Jack's offer to get her out of Cuba on the first boat.
Now I suppose that, given the choice between battling a brutal dictatorship and sailing the Caribbean bonking with Robert Redford, she would be forgiven a moment's hesitation, but even a little bit of soul-searching would have been much more real.
The Jack Wild character is too dull even to be worth poking fun at.
If you go to see this film hoping to learn about the Cuban revolution, you won't. There is a single, short scene in which it is made clear that the US government was propping up the Batista dictatorship and that's it.
Pollack simply isn't interested in etuation in tany depths He just wants some eye-catching scenery to back up a very mediocre love story.
Go and see Arachnophobia instead.
can • We /hole u see your fight
Scan page 14
Socialist Organiser No. 473 pag t is somewhat unfair to the memory of George Lansbury to compare him to Michael Foot.
Foot, with the rest of the Tribune group, supported the campaign to get rid of Lansbury. William Mellor, the initial editor of Tribune, did not, but they got rid of him.
The Socialist League was in the main a Popular Frontist (i.e. Stalinist fellowtravelling) organisation, though Reg Groves led a Trotskyist minority. It did not therefore campaign for Lansbury, indeed it was to be part of the campaign against him.
The Third Period was still on when Lansbury was elected, so that the Socialist League had not yet adopted the stance it later took up. No doubt individual members of the Socialist League would have campaigned for Lansbury, but the three groups that later fused into the League as remembered (two splinters from the Independent Labour Party and one from the Fabians) would not have had a unified position.
Lansbury had come to the leadership a lot earlier than these battles: the Stalinists were calling him socialFoot opposed Lansbury fascist, and saying that left social-fascists were worse than right. The upsurge that put him into power - not much was needed, as he was the senior Labour Cabinet minister left after the defections of Ramsay MacDonald and his gang — was before Write to SO, PO Box London SE15 4NA the secession of the ILP, and thus before the creation of the Socialist League.
Laurens Otter, Wellington, Salop. By Tim Cooper Splayed a key role in ocialist Organiser has the development of one of the best, united campaigns in the country.
Behind the slogans 'No to Gulf!* Troops out of the and Iraq out of Kuwait', CND, Labour Parties, trade unions, black, Muslim and Jewish organisations, Green Party and Poly Labour Club and Nottingham Against the War in the Gulf said: "It was excellent. Over 500 people
----- pull-quotes -----
AGAINSI THE TIDE
Oh that these words could suckle them
nfair to ry WRITEBACK
500 JOIN ANTI-WAR PROTEST