Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

A little idealism is a dangerous thing

Socialist Organiser no. 473, 30 January 1991 · scan p. 12 · Patrick Murphy · about 954 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 12

little idealism is a dangerous thing.

standing attachment of the mainstream left to the United Nations. Neil Kinnock has used the idea of UN sanctions against Iraq quite cynically to make it easier to carry his MPs with him in craven support of war.

Even wavering Labour MPs went along with Kinnock's petulant machismo because the UN were seen to have taken the initiative. The "allied" troops were sent, they deluded themselves, on UN business. Faith in this august body doesn't stop there.

The serious left in Parliament, the anti-war left, also place great store in the UN. Its original policy was working, they say, sanctions should have been given more time, the UN has been tragically hijacked by the US and her allies. Perhaps the most tragic consequence of this whole crisis, said one dissident, will be the long-term loss of credibility suffered by the UN. Leaving aside the chilling compacency this sort of judgement implies about the other consequences of the war, I beg to differ. The sooner the UN loses the aura of respect it enjoys with the mainstream left the better.

The vague ideal at the root of this is the hope to see a "world government". On one level it is a tremendous internationalist vision but, as with most of their ideals, the traditional left believe in it half-heartedly and hope that it will evolve out of existing institutions. The Labour Party between the world wars came to have a tremendous respect for the League of Nations, the forerunner of the UN. The record of the League is now infamous, it was highly inconsistent, unable to act against aggression without the say-sos of the dominant powers within it, at this time Britain and France.

After World War 2 the idea of an international body to avoid conflict was revised and the UN established. The problem of the League was considered to have been lack of teeth, so the UN had troops, but in fact the problem was more complicated. On the one hand it was in no way independent of the major powers and nor could it be. In addition, the relations between powers in the 1930s had been rapidly changing so that no one power could give the League authority and power. Nevertheless, the UN carried over the optimism of liberal and reformist politicians, with Labour central again.

n the post-war era the UN had to take account of the developing cold war. Its troops were used in Suez, Cyprus and Lebanon when the major powers, and particularly the US, wanted a minimum level of stability for the least political cost. A better understanding of the UN can be gained, however, by considering the times when its troops, or indeed any other sanction, were not used.

The Soviet Union invaded Hungary, and Afghanistan, the US invaded Vietnam, Grenada and Panama, and destabilised Nicaragua. There was not the slightest possibility that the UN would act against these crimes, and nor will they in the future. The structure of the UN gives five powers (US, USSR, Britain, China and France) a permanent veto on any decisions by the Security Council. This not only enables them to act with impunity, it also extends protection to their closest allies.

The UN's various bodies have passed comprehensive resolutions demanding a Palestinian state and Israeli withdrawal from the Occupied Territories, but Israel is an important ally of the US with considerable influence in US politics. Powerful resolutions on South African apartheid and destabilising of neighbouring countries have existed for years without the swift action taken against Iraq. This again is because South Africa was doing an important job in the region, however clumsily, and the alternative was considered to be communism, The League of Nations stands condemned in history for much less serious inconsistencies and in much more difficult circumstances. "The structure enables the big act with impun Consider the behaviour UN members during the internationally-inspired China has chosen this mor the leaders of the Tianan of some prominent first weeks of the Gulf initiative. nent to try and jail men Square uprising, in which thousands died and the UN did nothing. Burma has been rounding up dissidents and strike leaders who came close to toppling the brutal regime there recently. The Soviet Union, in the best known case, chose this time to move troops in to crush Lithuanian independence.

Across the world, governments used the conflict to further their own interests, Israel and Syria for more financial aid, Bush and Major for domestic support in the midst of a looming recession.

one of this would alter if the UN were reformed because the decisive divisions in the world are between classes not nations, and the members of the UN are all parts of the same class. The UN can keep the lid on disputes between minor miscreants who disrupt their exploitation of the world's markets and resources, but in any conflict between the major powers it is impotent.

War between the US and USSR after 1945 was avoided only by the bluff and counterbluff of mutual destruction, when it was not fought out by surrogates in the developing world. Now that the eastern bloc is cracking the UN may become the permanent cover for a US-dominated new world order, but one point at least should be clear. The UN can only reflect the interests of the dominant imperialist powers — it is not neutral between, or independent of, their interests.

Socialists should stop looking to a convention of capitalist governments to end wars and conflicts and concentrate instead on dealing with the real cause of these conflicts - the rapacious systems these governments defend to the death.

----- pull-quotes -----

HEEPOLITICAL FRONT

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 473

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →