Socialism and war
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-01-30Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
What Lenin and Zinoviev wrote in 1915 Only a fool believes the Oin alt modern wars the waare In all modern wars the warmakers use ideas — to mobilise support, to confuse or disarm enemies - and that means that they use lies and misrepresentations. Wars generate hails of lies, like they generate hails of bullets and shells, and for the same purpose: they too are weapons in the struggle.
The governments present themselves in the best light, their opponents in the worst. They proclaim as their aims in the war the most widely acceptable aims they can plausibly (or implausibly!) lay claim to.
Thus, in the early build-up to the Gulf war, some US representatives said it was for oil, while others said it was for the liberty of Kuwait - before they finally settled on their "story", that is, for Kuwait's "liberty" as the best rallying cry.
Today, even many Tories would ad mit that World War 1 was a monstrously tragic and futile event: millions of casualties, the world economy dislocated for a generation, and the seeds of the Second World War sown within the half-sealed wounds of the First.
At the time both sides told lies abou freedom and about the liberation of small nations. Germany claimed to be winning the freedom of the seas from Britain. The eventual victors promised to create a new world order after the slaughter was over: it would be "war to end war".
Socialists have always condemned war Shut our atitude towards war is huh:
But our attitude towards war is fundamentally different from that of the bourgeois pacifists (supporters and advocates of peace) and of the Anarchists.
We differ from the former in that we understand the inevitable connection between wars and the class struggle within the country; we understand that war cannot be abolished unless classes are abolished and Socialism is created; and we also differ in that we fully regard civil wars, ie. wars waged by the oppressed class against the oppressing class, slaves against slave-owners, serf® ainst landowners, and wage-workers agair urgeoisie, as legitimate, progressive ar We Marxists differ fr the Anarchists in historically (fror tical materia history t spite fe bingwaxm Sessie movemems BSOY dustrial action in emergency cover socialism in the workplac.
What do we mean by a rank and fall of the NOLB • Workplace bulle produce them • Sexual harassment at work! the ambulance disputét Professional creche • Social on Saturday Cost E5 waged/E2.50 unwaged/E2 per daylE1 per se Full timetable in next week's SO More details, write to PO Box 823, London SE15 4NĂ Millions of workers believed them and went out to slaughter each other, instead of turning their guns against their own ruling classes.
enin and Zinovie explained that Marxists have no general good-forall-time response to wars. Socialism will abolish war. War is always savage and barbarous. But we are not pacifists who reject all wars and proclaim all wars equally bad.
Some wars help take humanity forward. For example, when, in the '30s and '40s, the Chinese people fought a war to stop Japan enslaving China, that was a just war, a "good" war in a cause that deserved to win and a cause that could, in the circumstances, only be won by war.
By contrast, twenty years earlier, when the bloc of countries led by Britain and France talked about their war as a war to free "gallant little Belgium", invaded by Germany, Lenin and Zinovie scoffed at them. Not thai Belgium didn't matter: if, they argued, it really were a ganging-up of states to force Germany out of Belgium, and that only, then it would be a just war, deserving of support. Belgium had been invaded, and the British and French did want to drive the Germans out. But in fact Belgium was only a piece in the jigsaw of a world conflict which was not about Belgium but about who should have the right to plunder the colonial world.
Today, Kuwait is not the issue. Oil is. Without oil, the US wouldn't care about Kuwait. And now they have started talking about bringing down the regime in Baghdad - that is, is that the not over sary and only 'ecabout conquering and perhaps occupying Iraq. That in turn means turning the clock back 30 and more years, and re-colonising part of the Arab world.
Even if Iraq is not occupied, such a destabilisation of the region is likely to come from the war that the British and US governments will maintain garrisons in the region to protect the interests they fought the war for - in the first place, oil. Since August, when the Iraqi butcher Saddam Hussein inEvaded Kuwait, we have moved a long way, politically speaking, from Kuwait! In this war there is a confusing mixture of types of war. Three decades ago Iraq was still a British-run client state. In invading Kuwait it acted as an imperialist power. It is a savage and brutal oppressor in Kuwait, even though intra-Arab politics place IraqiKuwaiti relations on a special plane. In responding, the old fully-fledged world-dominating imperialist powers -exuberant after their victory in the long struggle with the USSR, and using the cloak of the United Nations - have embarked on a programme which will quickly bring Iraq's national independence into question and maybe to an end, and which, on present evidence, will quickly pit the US and Britain against vast sections of the Arab people.
Despite our hostility to Iraq's invasion of Kuwait, in this situation socialists must also look at the broader issues, refuse to fall for the "gallant little Belgium" ploy revived for Kuwait, oppose the moves towards recolonisation, and support Iraq's right to defend itself against conquest.
Lenin and Zinoviev's text can, naturally, tell us nothing about the Gulf war. It can teach us how to analyse and understand it.
pression.
Therefore, those were progressive wars, and during such wars, all honest, revolutionary democrats, and also all Socialists, always sympathised with the success of that country (ie. with that bourgeoisie), which had helped to overthrow, or sap, the most dangerous foundations of feudalism, absolutism and the oppression of other nations.
For example, the revolutionary wars waged by France contained an element of plunder and conquest of alien territory by the French, but this does not in the least alter the fundamental historical significance of these wars, which destroyed and shattered feudalism and absolutism in the whole of old, serf-ridden Europe.
In the Franco-Prussian war (1870-71], Germany plundered France, but this does not alter the fundamental significance of this war, which liberated tens of millions of German people from feudal disintegration and from the oppression of two despots, the Russian tsar and Napoleon III.
The difference between defensive war The epoch of 1789-1871 left deep traces and absolutism and alien oppression were overthrown, the development of the proletarian struggle for Socialism was out of the question. When speaking of the legitimacy of "defensive" war in relation to the wars of such an epoch, Socialists always had in mind precisely these objects, which amounted to revolution against medievalism and serfdom. By "defensive" war Socialists always meant a "just" war in this sense.
Only in this sense have Socialists regarded, and now regard, wars "for the defence of the fatherland", or "defensive" wars, as legitimate, progressive and just.
For example, if tomorrow, Morocco were to clare war on France, India on England, Persia a] or China on Russia, and so forth, those would be "just", "defensive" wars, irrespective of who attacked first; and every Socialist would sympathise with the victory of the oppressed, dependent, unequal states against the oppressing, slaveowning, predatory "great" powers.
But picture to yourselves a slave-owner who owned 100 slaves warring against a slave-owner who owned 200 slaves for a more "just" distribution of slaves. Clearly, the application of the term "defensive" war, or war "for the defence of the fatherland" , in such a case would be historically false, and in practice would be sheer deception of the common people, of philistines, of ignorant people, by the astute slave-owners. Precisely in this way are the present-day imperialist bourgeoisie deceiving the peoples by means of "national" ideology and the term "defence of the fatherland" in the present war between slave-owners for fortifying and strengthening slavery.
The present war is an imperialist war N an imperialist war, but in most cases this term early everybody admits that the present war is is distorted or applied to one side, or a loophole is left for the assertion that this war may, after all, have a bourgeois-progressive, nationalliberating significance. Imperialism is the highest stage in the development of capitalism, reached only in the twentieth century. Capitalism now finds the old national states, without the formation of which it could not have overthrown feudalism, too tight for it. Capitalism has developed concentration to such a degree that whole branches of industry have been seized by syndicates, trusts and associations of capitalist billionaires, and almost the entire globe has been divided up among the "lords of capital", either in the form of colonies, or by enmeshing other countries in thousands of threads. of financial exploitation.
Free trade and competition have been superseded by the striving for monopoly, for the seizure of territory for the investment of capital, for the export of raw materials from them, and so forth. From the liberator of nations that capitalism was in the struggle against feudalism, imperialist capitalism has become the greatest oppressor of nations. Formerly progressive, capitalism has become reactionary; it has developed the forces of production to such a degree that mankind is faced with the alternative of going over to Socialism or of suffering years and even decades of armed struggle between the "great" powers for the artificial preservation of capitalism by means of colonies, monopolies, privileges and national oppression of every kind.
War between the biggest slave-owners for preserving and fortifying slavery To explain the significance of imperialism, we will quote exact figures showing the division of the world among the so-called "great" (ie. successful in great plunder) powers:
Division of the World Among the "Great" Slave-owning Powers. Colonies Metropolises Total 1876 1914 1914 Squace Inhab- quare Inhab kilome itants kilome- tact Inhab- Square Inhab- itants kilome- itants trEs millions France England Russia Germany 22.5 251.9 33.5 393.5 0.3 46.5 33.8 440.0 17.0 15.9 17.4 33.2 5.4 136.2 22.8 169.4 0.9 6.0 10.6 55.5 0.5 39.6 11.1 95.1 - 0.3 19.2 0.4 53.0 0.7 722 2.9 12.3 0.5 64.9 3.4 77.2 Japan United States of America 0.3 9.7 9.4 97.0 9.7 106.7 Six "great" powers 40.4 273.8 65.0 523.4 16.5 437.2 81.5 960.6 Colonies belonging not to great powers (but to Belgium, Holland and other states) 9.9 93.4 45.3 Three "semi-colonial" countries (Turkey, China and Persia) 361.2 Total 105.91,367.1 Other states and countries 28.0 289.9 Entire globe (without Polar regions) 133.91,657.0 From this it is seen how most of the nations which fought at the head of others for freedom in 1789-1871, have now, after 1876, on the basis of highly developed and "overripe" capitalism, become the oppressors and enslavers of the majority of the populations and nations of the globe. From 1876 to 1914, six "great" powers grabbed 25 million sq. kilometres, ie. an area of two and a half times that of Europe! Six powers are enslaving over half a billion (532 million) inhabitants of colonies. For every four inhabitants of the "great" powers there are five inhabitants of "their colonies". And everybody knows that colonies are conquered by
Scan page 11
fire and sword, that the populations of colonies are brutally treated, that they are exploited in a thousand ways (by exporting capital, concessions, etc, cheating when selling them goods, subordination to the authorities of the "ruling" nation, and so on and so forth.)
The Anglo-French bourgeoisie are deceiving the people when they say that they are waging war for the freedom of nations and for Belgium; actually they are waging war for the purpose of retaining the colonies they have inordinately grabbed. The German imperialists would free Belgium, etc, at once if the British and French would agree "fairly" to share their colonies with them. The peculiarity of the situation lies in that in this war the fate of the colonies is being decided by war on the Continent.
From the standpoint of bourgeois justice and national freedom (or the right of nations to existence), Germany would be absolutely right as against England and France, for she has been "done out" of colonies, her enemies are oppressing an immeasurably far larger number of nations than she is, and the Slavs who are oppressed by her ally Austria undoubtedly enjoy more freedom than those in tsarist Russia, that real "prison of nations"
But Germany is fighting not for the liberation, but for the oppression of nations. It is not the business of Socialists to help the younger and stronger robber (Germany) to rob the older and overgorged robbers.
Socialists must take advantage of the struggle between the robbers to overthrow them all. To be able to do this, the Socialists must first of all tell the people the truth, namely, that this war is in a treble sense a war between slave-owners to fortify slavery.
This is a war, firstly, to fortify the enslavement of the colonies by means of a "fairer" distribution and subsequent more "concerted" exploitation of them; secondly, to fortify the oppression of other nations within the "great" powers, for both Austria and Russia (Russia more and much worse than Austria) maintain their rule only by such oppression, intensifying it by means of war; and thirdly, to fortify and prolong wage slavery, for the proletariat is split up and suppressed, while the capitalists gain, making fortunes out of the war, aggravating national prejudices and intensifying reaction, which has raised its head in all countries, even in the freest and most republican. War is the continuation of politics by other' lie. violent) 'means"
his famous aphorism was uttered by one of the profoundest writers on the problems of war, Clausewitz. Marxists have always rightly regarded this thesis as the theoretical basis of views concerning the significance of every given war. It was precisely from this viewpoint that Marx and Engels always regarded different wars.
Apply this view to the present war. You will see that for decades, for almost half a century, the governments and the ruling classes of England, and France, and Germany, and Italy, and Austria, and Russia, pursued a policy of plundering colonies, of oppressing other nations, of suppressing the working class movement. It is this, and only this policy that is being continued in the present war. In particular, the policy of both Austria and Russia, in peace-time as well as in war-time, is a policy of enslaving and not of liberating nations.
In China, Persia, India and other dependent countries, on the contrary, we have seen during the past decades a policy of rousing tens and hundreds of millions of people to national life, of liberating them from the oppression of the reactionary "great" powers. A war on such a historical ground can even today be a bourgeois-progressive, national-liberation war.
It is sufficient to glance at the present war from the viewpoint that it is a continuation of the politics of the "great" powers, and of the principal classes within them, to see at onçe the howling antihistoricalness, falsity and hypocrisy of the view that the "defence of the fatherland" idea can be justified in the present war.
The example of Belgium he favourite plea of the social-chauvinist [on the Allied side is the example of Belgium.
But this example goes against them. The German imperialists shamelessly violated the neutrality of Belgium, as belligerent states have done always and everywhere, trampling upon all treaties and obligations if necessary. Let us suppose that all the states interested in the observation of international treaties declared war on Germany with the demand for the liberation and indemnification of Belgium. In such a case, the sympathies of "You will that for decades, for almost half a century, the governments and the ruling classes of England, and France, and Germany, and Italy, an Austria, and Russia, pursued a policy of plundering colonies, o oppressing other nations, of suppressing movement.
Extracts from Socialis by Lenin and Zinoviev. later re-wrote history! the pamphlet to Lenin / Unis Socialists would, course, many's enemies.
But the whole point is that the "triple (and quadruple) entente" is waging war not over Belgium: this is perfectly well known, and only hypocrites conceal this. England is grabbing Germany's colonies and Turkey; Russia is grabbing Galicia and Turkey, France wants Alsace-Lorraine and even the left bank of the Rhine; a treaty has been concluded with Italy for the division of the spoils (Albania, Asia Minor); bargaining is going on with Bulgaria and Rumania, also for the division of the spoils.
In the present war waged by the present governments, it is impossible to help Belgium without helping to strangle Austria or Turkey, etc! How does "defence of the fatherland" come in here? Herein, precisely, lies the specific feature of imperialist war, war between reactionary-bourgeois, historically obsolete governments, waged for the purpose of oppressing other nations. Whoever justifies participation in the present war perpetuates imperialist oppression of nations. Whoever adovcates taking advantage of the present embarrassments of the governments to fight for the social revolution champions the real freedom of really all nations, which is possible only under Socialism.
What is social chauvinism?
Social-chauvinism is advocacy of the idea of "defence of the fatherland" in the present war. Further, this idea logically leads to the abandonment of the class struggle during the war, to voting war credits, etc. Actually, the social-chauvinists are pursuing an anti-proletarian, bourgeois policy; for actually they are championing not "defence of the fatherland" in the sense of fighting foreign oppression, but the "right" of one or other of the "great" powers to plunder colonies and to oppress other nations.
The social-chauvinists repeat the bourgeois deception of the people that the war is being waged to protect the freedom and existence of nations, and thereby they go over to the side of the bourgeoisie against the proletariat.
In the category of social-chauvinists are those who justify and embellish the governments and bourgeoisie of one of the belligerent groups of powers, as well as those who, like Kautsky, argue that the Socialists of all the belligerent powers have an equal right to "defend the fatherland". Social-chauvinism, being actually defence of the privileges, advantages, robbery and violence of one's "own" (or every) imperialist bourgeoisie, is the utter betrayal of all socialist convictions. AUTOCRACY: one-person rule SERFDOM: the form of exploitation typical of the Middle Ages, under which peasants (serfs) were tied the land and had to give produce or labour to the landlord.
PARIS COMMUNE: the workers* government which held power in Paris for nine weeks in 1871 before being suppressed by the joint efforts of the French bourgeoisie and the Prussian army which had invaded France.
THE REVOLUTIONARY WARS WAGED BY FRANCE: from April 1792 the revolutionary regime in France — where the absolute monarchy had been overthrown in 1789 — was at war with most of the other major powers in Europe.
FEUDALISM: the mode of production typical of the Middle Ages, dominated by hereditary landlords exploiting peasants through relations of serfdom (qv).
ABSOLUTISM: as capitalism developed in the cities of feudal Europe, the kings and their state bureaucracies gained more centralised power, balancing between the landlords and the rising capitalist class. The kings claimed 'absolute', ie. dictatorial power.
FRANCO-PRUSSIAN WAR: 19th century Germany was divided into dozens of small states. Prussia was the biggest. In 1870 France (then ruled by the Emperor Napoleon III) invaded Prussia. Prussia quickly turned the tables and invaded France. On the basis of that victory it unified all the German states except Austria.
(The king of Prussia became emperor of Germany).
MOROCCO: was in 1915 a colony of France, and India of England. Persia (Iran) and China were under the joint domination of various powers, including Russia.
IMPERIALISM: from the mid-19th century this term took on the meaning of a drive by big powers to acquire colonies and spheres of influence and to tie them together into a cohesive economic unit.
BELGIUM: was invaded by Germany in World War AUSTRIA: here signifies the Austro-Hungarian Empire, then one of the great powers of Europe, ruling modern Czechoslovakia, part of Poland, etc.
GALICIA: the bit of Poland then ruled by Austria.
ALSACE-LORRAINE: border area between France and Germany.
TURKEY: then ruled a large empire, which was up after the war; Britain took Iraq, Jordan and Palestine; and France Syria and Lebanon.
Scan page 12
The left and the United Nations
----- pull-quotes -----
"But the whole poin
triple (and quadruple) entente' is waging war
Belgium: thi is perfectly well known,
hypocrites conceal this.