Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The meaning of the Employment Act

Socialist Organiser no. 473, 30 January 1991 · scan p. 8 · about 1,162 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

be 'not a significant problem' in early 1989. The firm display of rank and file strength by the tube workers and others in the summer of 1989 cannot have pleased a government which had long said inat me evir or trade umonist lay in the leadership, not the members. This Act will force unions to effectively police their members if they are to remain within the law.

The 1990 Act makes unions liable for acts of shop stewards and any member of strike co-ordinating groups of which the steward is a member, unless the action is effectively repudiated by the union. To follow this up, once an act has been repudiated by a union - or where none of those taking action are union members — any of those involved in the industrial action may be selectively dismissed, with industrial tribunals having no jurisdiction whatsoever to hear any unfair dismissal claims. To cap it all, any otherwise lawful action which follows, will be unlawful if it relates in any way to the dismissal of those taking unofficial industrial action. Soon any action to those victimised under the new laws will be unlawful.

A union will now have been taken to have authorised or endorsed acts taken by the following: any person empowered by the rules to do, authorise or endorse acts of the kind in question; the principal excouve communice or me preslucut idant or general secretary; by any other committee of the union or any other official of the union (whether employed by it or not)."

The final part of this new definition is clearly intended to cover the acts of shop stewards but the Act goes further still. It is provided that 'any group of persons constituted in accordance with the rules of the union is a committee of the union' and 'an act shall be taken to have been done, authorised or endorsed by an official if it was done, authorised or endorsed by, or any member of, any group of persons of which [they were] at the material time a member, the purposes of which included organising or coordinating industrial action.* This means that, where a steward is a member of a strike committee - which may or may not be authorised to call action by the union's rules or policy — and any member of that committee calls action, the union will be liable tor that action, unless the union repudiates it within the terms of the Act. This potentially takes the law further than it has ever been before, even further than the notorious Taff Vale decision in 1901.

Making the union liable he legal steps which a union will have to take if it is to 'repudiate' action are ridiculous. In brief, in order to effectively repudiate any action which it is taken to have authorised or endorsed, the union must write to the official or committee without delay, and 'do its best' to give written notice of the fact and date of repudiation to every member who the union has reason to believe is taking part or might take part in industrial action as a result of the call and to the employer of every such member.

The practical and political implications of these provisions are worth some thought. Unions will now be forced to immediately repudiate industrial action called by any member of a group of people who are involved in organising industrial action, where a lay official is a member of that group. If they do not repudiate it, the union will be liable for that action, which will be automatically unlawful unless a ballot has been conducted in accordance with the stringencies of the 1984 Trade Union Act. If there has not been a ballot, the union will have to repudiate the action and then ballot.

This situation is compounded by s.7 of the Act which provides that a ballot shall not be valid if a union has 'authorised or endorsed' action - in accordance with the provisions set out above - prior to the date of the ballot. The only option for a union who wishes to support unofficial action lawfully is to tell all members in writing that they are repudiating the action, then ballot for fresh action.

It is not difficult to imagine employers arguing before the High Court in these circumstances that 'the union could not have effectively repudiated the action, when they immediately balloted to support what is effectively the same action'. It is also not hard to imagine the courts - with their far from sympathetic record on matters involving the labour movementupholding this argument and making it impossible for a union to lawfully support a strike which began unofficially.

The process of repudiation, apart from being time-consuming, costly and likely to lead to mischievous legal arguments trom employers, clearly has substantial ramifications for the role of the union and the way the members will view the union. The union will effectively have to police its own members, being forced to disown each and every unofficial strike if it is to steer clear of the law courts.

The automatic repudiation of unofficial action will often understandably be viewed with dismay and contempt by those who have taken action to protect their genuine interests. It is also likely that a number of unions, who now pride themselves on acting within the government's employment laws, will not put up too much of a fight to avoid giving the impression that they are selling their members down the river. After all, they are required to do so by law!

No defence against sack he whole matter is made much worse by a further provision that states that the written notice of repudiation to members, if it is to be legally ettective, must contain the following statement:

*Your union has repudiated the call (or calls) for industrial action to which this notice relates and will give no support to unofficial industrial action taken in response to it (or them). If you are dismissed while taking unofficial industrial action, you will have no right to complain of unfair dismissal."

If unions are to follow the legal requirements, they will often appear to be in breach of fundamental principles of trade unionism. To always immediately repudiate all unofficial action, even if it is explained as a measure rendered necessary by the law, will give many activists and members generally the feeling that they have been somewhat let-down by the union.

It is also possible that additional comment by the union on the notice of repudiation, which is aimed at communicating to their members that they 'don't really mean it' or were forced by law to repudiate and put the required wording on the notice, could be interpreted by a court as making the repudiation ineffective in legal terms. The courts have only been too happy in the past, for example during the miners' and seafarers' disputes hold unions responsible where

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 473

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →