Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The Gulf war: the environmental threal

Socialist Organiser no. 473, 30 January 1991 · scan p. 6 · about 954 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 6

of US terror in Vietnam...and how many like that are there already in Ofirepower, Tragi ford from the basis of relative likely to be expelled from Kuwait. However, as an assortment of Labour MPs, the Green Party, environmental campaigners and King Hussein of Jordan have pointed out, Saddam has another sort of firepower up his sleeve.

If his forces were to fire the oilfields as they left Kuwait, not only a few oil billionaires would suffer. Massive amounts of soot, carbon dioxide and other pollutants would pour into the air for weeks, if not months. And it is widely accepted that Iraq has mined the oil wells.

That much seems certain, but it is the effects of this military vandalism that are in question. At the World Climate Conference last November, King Hussein raised the possibility of increased acid rain, accelerated global warming and a form of 'nuclear winter"

Similar, though less drastic, claims were made at a conference in London a week before the outbreak of war. This was organised by CND and the Green Party, and introduced by Abdullah Toukan, Jordan's chief scientific adviser. The keynote contribution to the meeting was a paper delivered by leading CND member John Cox, a chemical engineer by profession.

In it, Cox estimates that Kuwait's oilwells could burn some 3 million barrels of oil a day, comparable to the output of the wells before the invasion. The fires would continue until all Kuwait's reserves had been burnt (about 10% of the world's reserves) or until the fires were extinguished. This is because the oil is under pressure and would naturally flow to the surface, feeding the flames.

This would, according to Cox, add less than 5% to the global output of CO. Thus, those who think the fires would accelerate the greenhouse effect are barking up the wrong tree. "In reality," says Cox, "the main dangers arise from the major by-products of uncontrolled combustion - carbon monoxide, sulphur dioxide, nitrogen oxides and, above all, smoke."

The latter he estimates at 500,000 connes a month and most experts agree it would take several months, perhaps even a year, to put all the Iraq? Ollwell tires out.

Now, smoke is composed largely of tiny particles of carbon (soot) which, being black, are very good at absorbing heat. A cloud of it would absorb the Sun's heat and re-radiate it in all directions. The result would be less heat and light reaching the ground and therefore reduced temperatures.

Such an effect has been observed in the case of massive volcanic eruptions which have put fine dust particles into the stratosphere. Soot particles would have a greater effect than dust. That is the science of smoke.

The questions remaining are how much smoke will be produced, *The smoke of oilfield fires would certainly be enough to affect the climate of the Middle East and the Indian subcontinent."

where will it go and how long will it last. There is, of course, some disagreement between experts but all agree that the amount is unlikely to affect the climate of the world. At worst, the total quantity of smoke would be a few percent of the total dust raised by a full-scale nuclear war.

Comment such as that Gulf fires will cause ecological catastrophe for all mankind' are therefore unjustified. Indeed, they allow others to dismiss all warnings of damage and danger as scaremongering.

The smoke would certainly be enough to affect the climate of the Middle East and, because ol prevailing wind patterns, the Indian sub-continent.

Latest predictions for 'nuclear winter' theories suggest falls in temperatures of 10 to 20C. But ever a small fall in surface temperature! over the Indian sub-continent would have serious consequence: for the formation of the summel monsoon. The rain-bearing mon soon winds sweep in from the sea a: a result of convention current: above the hot land. They are effec tively colossal sea breezes.

Any reduction of lanc temperatures would lessen the forci of the monsoon winds so that les: rain would be brought. Thi agriculture that sustains a billior people could be devastated. At thi very least, the resulting deaths fron famine would dwarf the casualties of the war.

Few scientists consulted on this theory disagree violently with its conclusions. Debate centres on such questions as whether the heat of the fires would push smoke high into the atmosphere where it would last longer or on how much smoke would be produced by fires in which there was a lack of oxygen.

This didn't deter Energy Secretary John Wakeham stating that "suggestions of a global environmental disaster are totally misplaced. " However, further on in his statement, Wakeham agrees with Cox (the object of "anticommunist" witch-hunts on CND by the Tories in the mid-'80s) on the rate of burning of Kuwaiti oil. And a Met Office report released a week or so ago agrees with Cox in all important details.

There are precedents for the sort of scenario predicted by Cox. Volcanic eruptions in Rakata (Krakatoa) in 1883 and in Iceland in 1783 are said to have significantly reduced the intensity of sunlight in France, a considerable distance away from the explosions, and to have been followed by an unusually severe winter in much of the world. And in 1915 major forest fires in Siberia generated some 30 million tonnes of smoke, leading to a drop in temperature of 2 to 5C in much of Siberia.

The lack of rain in the Gulf region and the intense heat of oil fires may combine to produce longlasting clouds of smoke, high up in the atmosphere where they may be blown large distances. Conditions seem ripe for perhaps the greatest man-made disaster of all time.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 473

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →