Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Defence, defeat and socialists

Socialist Organiser no. 473, 30 January 1991 · scan pp. 3–4 · about 869 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

Iraq, without killing tens of thousands of people, without creating ecological disaster, without sowing the seeds of a protracted series of wars in the Middle East, then no rational socialist or democrat could object.

It can't be done like that: big scale slaughter and ecological disaster are already upon us little more than a week into a war that is likely to be a long one. Other hor"The samencipation off theawarong CENse on emancipation ossell MON DRANCS SELI DrMORE."

Marvin sprais urgeniser PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA Newsdesk: 071 639 7965 Latest date for reports: Monday Editor: John O'Mahony Published by WL Publications Ltd, PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA Printed by Tridant Press, Edenbridge Registered esse eyes permafithe BoisemOffice Articles do not necessarily reflect the views of Socialist Organiser and are in a personal capacity unless otherwise stateli The French Communist Party,"

complains the French revollutionary journal Lutte de Classe, "condemns Iraq's missile attack on Tel Aviv, as if the fact of being the attacker or the attacked was the most important thing in this war, and as if Israel had not been attacking the Palestinians for years."

In similar vein, a public meeting in London last week saw SO's editor John O'Mahony condemned from the floor as someone who would defend Israel *even against those who have a right to attack it"

Israel does oppress the Palestinian Arabs. It has been attacking them for years. If Palestinians attack Israeli military targets, we're on their side, even if they 'shoot first'. Attacks on Israeli civilian targets are a different matter; but even there we would feel an obligation to qualify condemnation with explanation.

But Iraq, not the Palestinians, attacked Tel Aviv and Haifa. Israel does not oppress Iraq. Israel has not been attacking Iraq "for years"

The thinking of those who justify Iraq's attacks on Israel is apparently that the Palestinians' "right to attack" Israel is somehow transferred to Iraq by tie fact that both Iraqis and Palestinians are Arabs. But that thinking extrapolates the right of the Palestinian Arabs to fight back against overwhelming oppression into a "right" of as many of the 200 million Arabs as can be gathered into a military force by an imperialist-minded demagogue to blitz, kill or drive out the three million Israeli Jews who occupy a tiny corner of traditionally-Arab territory. It would extrapolate the right of resistance of the oppressed into a right of revengeseeking conquest.

SO says that the Israeli Jews have a right to live as a nation, a right not to be conquered, suppressed, massacred or driven out. They have a right to defend their existence as a nation against attacks by such as Saddam Hussein.

That does not mean we support Israel blitzing Baghdad, still less that we support Israel "retaliating" against Iraq by attacking the Palestinians in the occupied territories. It does not mean that we would "support Israel" in a blanket way in a war where the fate of the Palestinians and other factors were also involved. It does mean that Israel is not fair game for any Arab attack, and that we are against "defeatism" in the sense of wishing for the full-scale military defeat of Israel: for such full-scale defeat could only mean the annihilation of the Israeli Jewish nation.

A false, dogmatic, stereotyped notion that the only permissible socialist attitudes in war are "defencism", meaning full support, and all-out "defeatism", obscures thought here. And likewise on Irag. Some socialists say that if you support Iraq against US conquest you must support it in Kuwait.

SO is for the "defence" of Iraq - for its right to resist conquest. That does not mean political support for Saddam Hussein, support for his attacks on Israel or support for his land-grab in Kuwait; in general, it does not mean support for all Iraqi military action in this war.

Nor does it mean expounding finely calibrated criteria about exactly which military operations are legitimately "defensive" and which are not. No more on this issue than on others do we formulate our ideas as tactical or technical advice for the powers that be.

Socialists cannot and should not play at being second-guessing military strategists, as if we thought the armies in the Middle East — Iraq's, Israel's, or any other country's — were pawns to be moved according to our advice. Our job is to understand and explain the issues as best we can to the working class — to explain what the working class should seek to defend, and what it should seek to oppose, by its own methods and with its own forces. perialism of parts of Arabia.

The only people who can *do something" about Saddam Hussein and achieve a positive, progressive outcome are the peoples of Iraq themselves — the peoples that Britain, France and the US helped Saddam to beat down and control.

Grehen Back Vial Wire Decer Jatin Haria (Labour Party BlankSectiansi Eriowilla flen wAP Dorothy Miassro Jpen Martmo bha Vellroy John Nicholson Peter Tatchell Mamhers nt the Advisory CommitEe dre drawn from a broad cross-section of the left opposed to the Labour Party's Views expressed esponsibil re andin Ivisory Editoriel Bpard

Scan page 4

Socialist Organiser No. 473 page

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 473

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →