A socialist policy for wars
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-01-23Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 14
The case was withdrawn.
Needless to say, he's still not Labour council plan As we go to press, the Labour-controlled council in Newcastle. under-Lyme are taking 37 non-payers to court in order to commit them to prison, though it is thought that this will be postponed for 28 days. Local ac tivists are planning a national demonstration to mark the first jailing by a Labour authority. Last December, the first person to be imprisoned for non-payment, Bryan White, was Saturday 26 January. Anti-war paign. Non-payment remains is to jail non-payers released early, following a hastily organised demonstration in Grantham.
Pass this resolution in your Labour Party against this threat:
This CLP/DLP/branch (1) Is appalled by the planned jailing of 37 poll tax non-payers by the Labour controlled council of Newcastle-under-Lyme.
(2) Calls on all Labour councils not to threaten, or start, commital proceedings against non-payers of the poll tax. ference, 10.30-5.00, Drummond Community School, Edinburgh. Speakers include Jeremy Corbyn Saturday 16 February. 'A strategy for the Labour Left', London LPS conference, Camden Town Hall, 10.00-5.30.
weekend school Saturday and Sunday.
Mandela Building, Manchester Poly Students* Union, Oxford Road, Manchester.
Cost: £5 waged, £2.50 unwaged. More details: phone 071-639 7965, or write to PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA.
t is only half true that *the fact, for example, that Lenin was for the defeat of Russia in 1914 in no way meant that he was for the victory of Germany" (Patrick Murphy, SO 471).
As Brian Pearce demonstrated in an article some 30 years ago, Lenin's arguments in the earlier part of World War 1 certainly contained the idea that the military defeat of Russia, in particular, was especially to be desired, and the idea that the military defeat of their own government was to be desired by socialists of all nations. He denounced Trotsky bitterly for arguing that socialists should desire "neither victory nor defeat" but simply the prosecution of the class struggle.
Pearce showed that in the later part of the war Lenin shifted to a position similar to that of Trotsky (and other Marxists like Rosa Luxemburg, who also opposed the war without using Lenin's formula of 'defeatism').
From the 1920s, however, the formula of defeatism' became a sacred principle in the new cult of 'Leninism' The exigencies of factional struggle against the Stalinists did not allow Trotsky to write freely on the question, and he gave the formal title "defeatism' to his policy on World War 2, although plainly he was not arguing that British or French socialists should desire the military defeat of Britain or France.
The formula 'defeatism or defencism' ', I think, obscures rather than clarifies thought, driving some socialists toward the idea that in war they must either be gung-ho for the military victory of their government or gung-ho for its military defeat.
'Defeatism' made some sense for the wars of the 18th and 19th centuries, when the military defeat of a country would mean the loss of colonies or outlying territories, and maybe adverse treaties, but not the oppression of its people. In the wars of the 20th century it rarely makes sense.
In the South Atlantic war, for example, it made sense to say that both in Argentina and in Britain the working class would benefit from the military defeat of its own government - its loss of credit, the blow to its imperialistic ambitions, etc. But what about the Iran-Iraq war? To oppose the war on both sides, to say it was a predatory war between rivals for the status of regional subimperial power, was one thing; to say that the military conquest of either country was to be desired is another.
As Patrick Murphy wrote: "the issues at stake in the conflicts between capitalist rulers are important only in so far as they affect the ability of the working class of all countries to organise, become self-conscious, overthrow their rulers and govern for themselves." The task of socialists in any war is to analyse the issues at stake and to prosecute the class struggle independently on that basis.
Colin Foster
----- pull-quotes -----
Socialists and the trade unions Organiser and