Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

A broader movement

Socialist Organiser no. 472, 23 January 1991 · scan pp. 11–13 · about 2,470 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 11

Barry Finger in New York Sant we a have intensitie ince the bombing began, out the US have intensified.

On the campuses, students have boycotted classes and occupied. 113 demonstrators were arrested at the University of California at Los Angeles last Friday. There is a 24-hour occupation of the administration building. They have demanded a day-long teach-in on the war.

In San Francisco a series of protests in the last few days blocked the Bay Bridge.

Other protests took place in Boston; Albany, New York; Salt Lake City; Fayetteville, Arkansas; and Baton Rouge, Louisiana; and in countless other communities.

40 to 50,000 protestors congregated in the downtown Mission district of San Francisco on 19 January. As the San Francisco and Washington marches were breaking up, the Bush administration announced the activation of 200,000 reservists and the resumption of the draft.

The level of anti-war participation is more cross roller in one In mainstream than during the early years of the Vietnam war. Largely absent however is an identifiable Jewish presence.

While the organisers of this wave of demonstrations are indifferent to the occupation of Kuwait, the sentiment of the rank and file is undisguisedly hostile to the Iraqi rulers. This hostility will serve the movement well. It pre-empts one predictably glaring weakness that the American administration will otherwise surely exploit against it.

Scan page 12

Those who do not remember the past is Sean Matgamna "The State of Israel, is racist, genocidally anti-Arab - hence our definition of it as a regime of the Nazi type - arising from the alliance between the ultra-reactionary Zionist movement and imperialism, supported by the Soviet bureaucracy... The atrocious anti-semitic persecution and massacring of Jews by the Nazis in Europe was used by Zionism and by imperialism to justify the existence of Israel as a colonial enclave and to convert the much-persecuted Jews into persecutors of the Arabs" - 'Correo Internacional' December 1990 f course you know the much-told Oglare, and he saw Dealt he Death place, and he saw Death, and Death looked at him intently, recognising him.

In a panic, he ran to his horse and galloped away desperately, taking the road to the city of Samara.

As he galloped off, Death turned to his companion. "Strange," he said, "that was so-and-so. I was very surprised to see him here, because I have an appointment with him, this evening, in Samara."

Death is all powerful. There is no escape when he reaches your name on the list.

Consider now, and the association is appropriate enough, the fate of poor Adolf Hitler. This heroic son of the German people understood early in life that the Jews were responsible for all the evil in the world.

He knew that the Jews were behind everything! He knew that Socialism and Communism were Jewish, and that the Jews were also behind finance capital.

He knew that modern art was pornography and corruption, and modern culture decadent - and he knew that the Jews were responsible. This genius understood that Jewish Bolshevism and "Jewish capital" were all one. Despite the appearance of difference and antagonism between these things, Hitler could see that all of them -socialism, finance capital, cultural and artistic decadence — were really one thing. They were aspects of one tightly organised and minutely-directed world Jewish conspiracy.

And so Hitler fought the Jews. He roused much of Germany against them. In the middle of the 20th century, he re-created the medieval ghettoes in some of the main cities of European civilisation.

When the Jews who ruled in London, Paris, Moscow and Washington declared war on the German Reich, Hitler set out to do the job properly: he organised the killing of six million Jews.

One quarter of these were children: but Hitler refused to be deterred. He knew the extent of Jew-Zion power. He understood that sentimentality would be fatal. And Hitler — before the Jews finally got him — managed to kill two out of every three Jews in Europe.

Now, you wouldn't say, would you, that Adolf Hitler underestimated the power of the Jews?

The left at the time of Hitler used to say he was a criminal maniac. But the left just didn't understand.

And neither did Adolf Hitler. This great man understood a lot about the Jews. But he didn't understand everything. The truth is that even Hitler underestimated the extent and power of the world Jewish conspiracy.

Not only were communism and finance capital - those seemingly mortal enemies — tools of the international conspiracy of Zion — so were the Nazis, themselves! Hitler and his valiant warriors against Zion - farsighted men like Himmler and Heydrich and Streicher - were themselves mere tools of the world Jewish conspiracy.

The Holocaust was just Hitler galloping off down the road to his own Samara. The Holocaust, too, served Jewish interests! are condemned to relive it Once again, in the Baltics, the rulers of the USSR are using war in the Middle East as a cover for a crackdown against a people within their own empire who are trying to break away. In 1956 Eastern Europe was thrown into ferment when Russia's first reforming Stalinist Tzar Nikita Krushchev denounced his predecessor Joseph Stalin as a murdering tyrant. The Poles and Hungarians led by reformist Stalinists and ex-Stalinists tried to act as independent states.

Without the great anti-Jewish warrior for one moment guessing what was going on, the guiding centre of the world Jewish conspiracy helped him in this work of killing Jews. Why did the Jews help Hitler kill the Jews? That, you see, was the easiest way they could win a Jewish state.

By a process of reasoning inaccessible to the ordinary human intelligence, the Jewish super-conspirators decided that the best way to secure Israel was to kill six million Jews.

Don't waste your time trying to understand this. Neither formal logic nor dialectics will help you understand: the subtlety and evil of the Elders of Zion have always puzzled the ordinary man, who is doing well if he becomes aware that this conspiracy exists, and can raise the alarm about it. Rational explanations are neither possible nor necessary.

The Jews helped Hitler in all sorts of ways, instructing the US government to keep Jews out of America, and doing many other things to help the Nazis, things that would need a cleverer man than myself to chronicle and unravel for you. After all, it was too complicated for even Hitler — who devoted his life to understanding the Jewish conspiracy — to understand. And thus he failed to save himself from being an instrument of the international Zionist conspiracy that he spent his life fighting.

Zionism'. We should strip off ed too clever for poor Adolf Hitler! So Hitler died confused, a Jewish dupe. Israel came into being, and has never done anything but evil in the world.

Were, let me change the note. You will think by now I am mad. The tale I have just sketched in is crazy - as mad as Hitler!

No — madder than Hitler. It is a long stretch further down the road into the dark lands of paranoia. And it is outrageous. To traduce Hitler's victims and his potential victims, blaming the Jews for the Holocaust, outrages both common sense and known history. And it outrages human decency. Yet the crazy thesis I have just set out in the form of a simple, albeit fantastic, story PERSPECTIVE Liberal Stalinists kept a hold in Poland. In Hungary serious fighting broke out into an outright insurrection against Russian rule. After week of fighting the Russians withdrew from Budapest. Then the British, French and Israelis invaded Egypt to reclaim control of the Suez Canal. Krushchev sent his tanks back in, and they crushed the Hungarians, for a generation.

The way history is repeating itself right now is uncanny enough to make your hair stand on end.

lies at the heart of the conventional wisdom of much of the left now: the thesis that "the Zionists" collaborated with the Nazis in one degree or another and that they thus share more or less of the responsibility for the great massacre.

Just as the Protocols of the Elders of Zion were forged by the Tsarist secret police, this anti-Zionist" thesis was formulated by the Stalinist state in the USSR, to justify its antisemitism. It then spread to a wide spectrum of the left, including anti-Stalinists. Books like Lenni Brenner's Zionism in the Age of the Dictators recycle the thesis in qualified, half-hidden form; the recent play Perdition, and dozens of articles and pamphlets restate it partially, if also more crudely, like Correo Internacional.

motional solidarity with the of the credulity with which these fantastic tales and grotesque constructions on real events are accepted on the left.

It is the source of the demand" which "anti-Zionism" supplies, and of the willingness, and even eagerness, to identify Zionism and Israel with fascism, or to come as close as sense can be stretched to identifying them.

It is one of the roots of the criminal tosh quoted at the head of this article. The publishers of the widely circulated Spanish language "Trotskyist' journal Correo Internacional (the "Morenists') are very crass, and say things brutally that others who share their essential ideas and attitudes would not say even to themselves. That is a merit of the "Morenists"

They are insignificant in Britain, but strong in a number of other countries, and numerically they are perhaps the biggest of the so-called Trotskyist currents. They are very strong in Argentina, where not so long ago the right-wing Peronists had as a slogan: "Kill a Jew a day" '. During the Iran-Iraq war they called on the combattants to make peace with each other for the purpose of jointly making war on Israel.

Leftists who accept such ideas don't realise that they — like the bureaucrats of the USSR who first shaped the current left wisdom about Zionism and fascism and put it into circulation — are reproducing the pre-war right wing and fascist thesis about the world Jewish conspiracy.

The whole thing But if Zionists", even while six million Jews were being killed, were nevertheless controlling what happened - stopping the US government letting in Jewish refugees, deliberately organising the killing of one million Hungarian Jews towards the end of the war, and so on, in order to win Israel for the Jews - if "they" could do that during the war, then the theories of a powerful Jewish conspiracy before the war were wrong only as understatements. The prevailing thesis about Zionism-Fascism-Israel can rest on no logical ground except the pre-war world Jewish conspiracy theory.

Of course nobody on the left would explicitly tell the story I told about Hitler. The anti-fascist, anti-racist, and anti-imperialist feeling of the anti-Zionist left prevents them from understanding it and from spelling it out coherently.

Nevertheless, that is the story sections of the left implicitly tell now. If you try to spell out what is said about Zionist collusion with the Nazis in pursuit of the Zionist goal of a Jewish state, then you must come up with some version of the story I told above. If the tale the left now tells could be told openly and honestly, opening out and tracing back the implications which are plainly there in what is said and insisted upon, then it would 'have to be a version of the tale I have concocted. That is the real and only possible relationship that what is now said by the left can be seen to have with what Hitler said on the same subject.

And it is not a matter of parallels that never meet. The assertion about the Zionists' co-responsibility for the Holocaust ties it all together. An honest historical balance-sheet from that point of view would have to place Hitler himself in the perspective of history -that is, of the post-Holocaust working-out of the "international Jewish conspiracy" Hitler lost: the Third Reich fell and Israel rose!

If the "lefts" who demonise Israel could confront the logic of what they say now they would find themselves at a bridge — and on the other side of it, the earlier history of the ideas behind that logic. If it could be thought through logically, free from the powerful inhibitions created by hatred of Nazism and of racism in general, then what the left says now would compel recognition that Hitler was informed and insightful on this question.

The reasons why the "anti-Zionist" left do not tease out such conclusions all speak in their favour — horror of Nazism, disgust with racism, and so on. They are after all socialists, whose basic impulses and aspirations are the same as SO's. Such people must denounce articles like this as foul slander — and go on as before.

But the good side which stops them thinking through the meaning of what they say has a bad consequence here. It allows them, fuelled by sympathy with the Palestinians and hatred of imperialism, blithely to go on peddling a disguised and sanitised version of facets of ideas they would shy away from in horror if ever they were forced to look at the question in its wholeness.

We don't know what terrible things will happen in Israel and Palestine during this war. The Israeli chauvinists are capable of doing — and maybe eager to do — terrible, indefensible things to the Palestinian Arabs; the Palestinian Arabs are allied with Saddam Hussein, who may, if the balance in the war and his technology allow it, drop poison-gas bombs on Israeli cities. We don't know.

We should support Israel's right to defend itself; support the Palestinian Arabs in so far as it is a matter of them trying to gain control of their own territories from the Israeli army; and back the Israeli anti-chauvinists who want a just settlement with the Palestinians. That is all we can do.

We should stand against any reflux of hysterical "anti-Zionism" . We should strip off the masks and the illusions behind which lurk ideas like those I have explored here. We are fighting for sanity and against unreason on the left, so we should not let delicacy stop us from confronting our misguided comrades, brutally, with the brute - Nazi -logic, implications and ancestry of some of the ideas they have adopted from putrescent Stalinism. We must insist, whatever the war brings to the Palestinians and the Israelis: No, Hitler was not right!

Scan page 13

CULTURAL FRONT Socialist Organiser No. 472 page

----- pull-quotes -----

AGAINST THE TIDE

"We should stand against reflux of hysterical 'anti-

the masks and the illusions..." All you need to know is that the Jews prov-

Palestinian Arabs, and therefore emotional hostility to Israel, is the root

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 472

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →