Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The Gulf War: issues for Labour What's wrong with pacitis

Socialist Organiser no. 472, 23 January 1991 · scan p. 10 · Patrick Murphy · about 1,752 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

Betty Williams (right, beside folk singer Joan Baez) the IRA, and presently a Labour peer), founders of the failure to address the real issues of Northern Ireland and Mairead Corrigan (left, beside Jane Ewart-Biggs, Peace Movement, lead a 30-000-strong demonstration led, eventually, to its demise. wife of a British ambassador to Ireland blown up by in London, November 1976. The Peace Movement's n 18 years of living in Northern Ireland it was rare for me to see mass demonstrations which genuinely cut across the sectarian boundaries. In 1976, therefore, it was hard not to be impressed by the sudden rise of the *Peace Movement"

Two Catholic women, who had suffered a tragic loss in one of many violent incidents, decided to organise a grassroots campaign "against violence and for peace'. There was, deliberately, no attempt to suggest any solution to the underlying problems of Northern Ireland. This was my first confrontation with "pacifism' and the moral force and potential power of it impressed....for a short while! The demos were remarkable; tens of thousands, Protestant and Catholic, overwhelmingly women, genuinely furious at the destruction and chaos being inflicted upon their communities. The beginnings were spontaneous, but the British press quickly latched on and used the protests in their own propaganda war. That in itself would not condemn the movement, any crosscommunity project could be exploited in that way. But I also remember vividly the fall of the apparently unstoppable Peace Movement, and it was educational.

In August 1976 in Whitecross, Co. Armagh, a 12 year old girl called Majella O'Hare walked down a country road with her friends. They passed a group of blacked-up soldiers from the Parachute Regiment hidden in a ditch; a cold brief exchange occurred, the girls walked on and minutes later Majella O'Hare lay dying, the victim of a Paratrooper's bullet. It made national news.

rad at war From page 7 would accept it, political regime.

In fact that unity is impossible. Even after facing down Britain and France over Suez in 1956, Nasser could not unite the Arabs around Egypt, which already had a quarter of all Arabs.

Newspapers like Socialist Worker have said that Saddam Hussein is now "objectively anti-imperialist". But he is not! And pan-Arab nationalism is not really anti-imperialist either!

Socialists should support the unity of the Arab people if the Arabs wish it. The achievement of such unity would be progressive, in part because it would clear the minds of the Arab working class and help them to deal with their own ruling classes.

But popular pan-Arab nationalism today is an ideological system which ties the working class to the petty bourgeoisie and sections of the bourgeoisie.

The crimes of the imperialist powers against the Arabs are many and they are great. But it is the Arab ruling classes that control the Arab states today, and it is the Arab ruling classes that perpetuate the divisions.

To accept as even provisional good coin, for now, the anti-imperialism of Saddam Hussein is to betray the Arab workers and peasants, especially because we are forced by events to side with Saddam against the US-allied drive to blitz and maybe occupy Iraq. For Iraqi national rights? Yes! For Saddam's policy? Never!

The real anti-imperialist programme in the Middle East today is the programme of working-class action, and the real revolutionary unifier of the Arabs is the creation of the Socialist United States of the Middle East.

Iraq's national rights et there is more to Vit. The Tragi aline class pursues Iraqi aggrandisement. But in the war now unfolding Iraq risks being reduced to a semi-colony, or shattered completely, with Turkey, Iran and Syria grabbing portions of its territory.

We should support Iraqi self-determination and Tragi self-defence against the American blitzkrieg. Such support does not mean any political endorsement for Saddam Hussein, nor any let-up in the Iraqi workers' struggle against him.

It is wrong to give Saddam credit as an 'antiimperialist", It would be it was a savage crime, everyone in the nationalist community waited for the Peace Movement's condemnation. They waited in vain. The Movement reacted quickly to IRA and, to be fair, to loyalist violence, but there was a limit. The 'security forces' were there to stop violence, to keep law and order, to criticise them could undermine confidence, encourage the real men of violence — and so on. Thus the old argument ran. The Peace People lost influence shortly after this incident. Catholics became more disillusioned and the Peace leaders seemed more concerned with being internationally feted (they won the Nobel Peace Prize) then the concerns of their communities.

equally wrong to deny support for Iraq's self-defence against the US-allied assault on the grounds that, Iraq being sub-imperialist, the war is only a quarrel between thieves.

A sub-imperialism is an aspirant regional imperialism, usually a client or semi-client of a fully-developed imperialist state -Argentina and Brazil in South America, for example, Iran and then Iraq in the Middle East. The term was first . coined by Latin American Marxists in the '60s to describe Brazil.

Iraq is sub-imperialist. Yet as recently as 1958 it was a semi-colony of Britain. In the course of its over-ambitious contest with the US now, it may well find itself faced with conquest and subjugation again. The sub-imperialist drive can collapse into its opposite.

When Iraq confronts the US in all-out war, the imperialism is that of the US.

Socialists have no interest in seeing Iraq subjugated or pulverised.

This war is different from the Falklands war. Argentina was not threatened, and was never likely to be threatened, with invasion, subjugation, dismemberment, destruction of its military-industrial base, or a blitzkrieg from the air.

The Northern Ireland Peace People did not represent all pacifism, nobody does, but it was fairly typical. It was not dishonest, the intentions and instincts were genuine. The problem was its failure to address the reality of the world. For a sizeable part of the Northern Irish people the main chaos and fear in their lives was brought about by the police and army. The republican violence began as a selfdefensive response to this. The instinct to oppose rule by force, violence against humans, is a good one.

Is a political guide to action, however, pacifism is fatally disarming. To insist that all force is equally bad and that all should abandon in principle the use of force is, in practice, to support those already in power. It is a matter of tactics, for example, whether and when the blacks of South Africa should use force to defeat apartheid, but experience suggests that such powerful people as the rulers of South Africa will not be beaten without it. Whatever the course of that struggle it would be absurd to insist in advance that force be renounced. The renunciation of force in principle in all situations is an abstract self-indulgence in a world in which all things are not equal.

In reality, that is in actual historical experience, the role of pacifism has been to persuade the oppressed to use no force; it has had no effect on the oppressors. Gandhi, for demanded rigid adherence to a code of nona police force.

Pacifists do not usually appreciate the causes of violence. They would acknowledge that there are serious conflicts in society, inequalities which lead to low level individual violence very day and which can explode into mass violence or civil war at points of crisis. In practice, most pacifists deal with this threat by accepting the 'need' for a police force, and in fact accepting the existing forces as legitimate, natural bodies which can minimise crime and violence. Between nations they look for a similar, neutral, independent police, hence the great faith in the UN.

The there bodies above and independent of the conflicting interests in society is, however, utopian. The police are controlled by, and accountable only to, the political and legal bodies which run this society, where the rights of property and profit are paramount.

The UN was shaped consciously by the world's leading powers to preserve their own domination. It should be no surprise to anyone that it treats US conquest of Panama, or Soviet invasion of Lithuania, much differently than Iraq's invasion of Kuwait.

It is not, in truth, violence as such to which pacifists object; it is 'new" or additional violence to that which already exists, that which is necessary, controlled and proper. Thus it is impossible to change the existing order with pacifism. This is ironic since it is that divisive, exploitative order which of necessity brings us wars. So as long as we have pacifism we shall have wars.

one of this should lead any socialist without violence is obviously more desirable than civil war. A society without violence or serious regular bouts of war is a realisable and essential part of our programme. But we must speak the truth. Historical experience suggests that progress has depended, at key moments, on the force from below becoming so great that the old rulers could no longer continue. Consider the victories of colonial peoples across the world after 1945. The same experience suggests that failure to meet a violent challenge at certain times will lead to deeper reaction and even more savage and systematic violence. Think only of the failure of socialists and democrats to prevent the rise of fascism in the inter-war years.

Pacifism is a fatally mistaken means, even to its own ends. It allows a world based on violent rule to enjoy a longer life. It applies to all wars an abstract response; above history, outside the specific circumstances which cause conflict when in fact an examination of each case is an indispensable guide to action. The inconsistency of all practical pacifism is no less dangerous for not being deliberate.

Something else I remember about the Peace Movement in Northern Ireland is the response of the Republican movement. For all their faults, they captured the limits of the campaign in their own slogan: 'Peace — Yes but with Justice'. Revulsion at war as a way of settling human conflict is a healthy instinct but to call simply for peace in South Africa or Northern Ireland, or in the struggle between workers and their bosses, not necessarily progressive, democratic or even anti-violence.

----- pull-quotes -----

HE POLITICAL FRONT

example, took British imperial force for granted, it was his own followers of whom he

"In practice, most pacifists deal with this threat [of civil war] by accepting the 'need' for

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 472

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →