The Palestinians, Israel and the war
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-01-23Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 7
In the House of Commons debate on the Gulf war, had it pointed out to him that the exiled Emir of Kuwait had said he did not object if Kuwait was levelled to the ground provided he got it back. Major's answer, in so far as there was one, was to say that there were big principles involved (and too bad for the people in Kuwait). It was the spirit of the US general who said of a Vietnamese city that he had to destroy it in order to save it. They say there is a war to liberate Kuwait - but in fact the people living in Kuwait are likely to be among its chief victims.
So are the Palestinian Arabs.
The Palestinian Arabs in the West Bank and Gaza have been under Israeli occupation for over 23 years. Their intifada has gone on for four years.
Militarily, they have little chance against Israel. Israel ignores pro-Palestinian UN resolutions, and its backers, in the first place the US, allow it to.
So most Palestinians support Iraq and Saddam Hussein. They may choose to step up their intifada now to help Iraq.
They are likely to be caught in the middle in this war. They may face an opportunistic drive by the Israeli government, or freelance Israeli chauvinists, to drive them, or some of them, out of the West Bank.
Socialists must defend the Palestinians. But that is only part of the picture. Israel too is under threat. If he is able to, Saddam Hussein will attack Israel in the hope of thereby dividing his Arab allies from Bush. Israel has the right to defend itself; and Israel, of course, has the military might to hit back.
Israel, too, has every motive to encourage the hiving off of Bush's Arab allies, because if the alliance survives the war then there will be immense pressure on Israel to get out of the West Bank and Gaza. Israel will be shown to be not the necessary ally of the West in the region, but a liability.
This jigsaw of conflict does not lend itself to easy or glib sloganising. But it clarifies certain things.
It shows up for nonsense the long-time common leftist view that Israel (and not the Arab bourgeoisies) was essential to the West's influence over and sometimes domination of the Arabs.
The Palestinian with Saddam Hussein, based on their understandable hope that he will smash Israel for them, shows up tor utopian daydreaming the idea that the solution to the ArabJewish conflict lies not in two states for the two peoples - Israel and an independent Palestinian-Arab state - but in a single "secular democratic state" which welds them together in a common and equal citizenship. Whatever the conquest of Israel by Saddam Hussein might create, it would not be democratic.
Socialists have to keep all the sides of this picture in mind. Supporting Israel's right to exist, we must defend the Palestinian Arabs and support their intifada. We must support the right of the whole Arab people to unite and to be free from foreign conquest. Support for that right is not conditional on the Arabs' acceptance of Israel, but the question is how the Arabs can unite. Socialists advocate a democratic - and not a "Prussian"-Iraqi — unification, and Arab acceptance of the national rights of minority nations in the region such as the Kurds and Israeli Jews.
Supporting the Palestinians" drive for their own independent state in the West Bank and Gaza, and understanding why it is that they come to be militants in Saddam Hussein's cause, we must continue to reject the demonisation of Self-determination for all the peoples in the Middle East Palestinian Arabs, Kurds, Israel Jews included - is the answer. In Palestine: two nati ens, two states!
Scan page 8
Troops out d roops out • Irag out rac out of K ah salar
Scan page 9
t the Gufuwait! THE 'HTERpice ou pence weekt
Scan page 10
Socialist Organiser No. 472 page 10
----- pull-quotes -----
STOP SLAU