Labour, democracy and the wal
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-01-23Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 3
The members of legislative bodies are selected by political parties, largely financed or otherwise influenced by private capitalists who, for all practical purposes, separate the electorate from the legislation.
"Under existing conditions, private capitalists inevitably control, directly or indirectly, the main sources of information (press, radio, education). It is thus extremely difficult, and indeed in most cases quite impossible, for the individual citizen to come to objective conclusions and to make intelligent use of his political rights."
Thus wrote the greatest scientific "The emancipation of her working dress i alson human beings without distinction of sex or race."
Karl Marx a sil Organiser PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA 11. 639 7965 Lettersi dave for repons! Monday I LIN Elitomı Johni QManony Published by WL Publications Ltd, bruce Registered as a newspaper at the Post OfficE Articles do not necessarily reflect the views of Socialist Organiser and are in arpersonal icapenty uness omery a thinker of the 20th century, Albert Einstein, in the course of explaining why he was against capitalism and wanted to replace it with socialism. He was explaining why he rejected the claim that a democracy like ours can ever be a properly functioning, that is a real, democracy.
Look around you now, 1l you need a fresh example of what Einstein had in mind. Britain is in a war that may last for many months, a war certain to cost many tens, and probably hundreds, of thousands of lives, large numbers of them British lives. This war may do unforeseeable damage to the environment, and it may dislocate the world's capitalist economy into, chaos and the worst slump for 50 years.
Yet Britain has been hustled into this war with little serious discussion of the issues, and a discussion of war's likely consequences nothing short of grotesque in its disproportion to the probable human, economic and ecological results of war.
The House of Commons, let alone the electorate, has had no control over Britain's five month drift to war, in tow to a gung-ho US government In theory, the House of Commons does have control, and it could, in principle, have countermanded the government's decision to steer for war. But that theory covers the operation of a ditterent House of Commons! This is the House of Commons where most MPs are, most of the time, mere puppets of the party machines.
This is the Britain of the Sun Star, with their obscene chauvinistic yelpıng and bayıng. The Britain of the Guardian, which opposed war, until war started, then switched sides. And, above all, it is the Britain of Neil Kinnock!
You can not have real discussion, real debate or real democracy where the main party of opposition does not - dares not - question or probe or debate or oppose. But that is how things are in Britain now. The Labour front bench dare not even be as independent as some rightwing politicians in the US are.
Kinnock and his friends dare not defend the rights of members of the Labour Party to disagree with this war. To vote against the government is to face instant dismissal from the Shadow Cabinet. They do not dare even to protest at the lynch-mob atmosphere being whipped up in Britain now by the high priests of gutter Toryism - the Sun and the Star. The Sun, usually facttree, lists the 34 MPs: "34 MPs who won't back our boys". The Mail calls them "Labour's Desert Rats"!
And listen to the demented jingoism of the Star denouncing the 34 Labour MPs who voted against the government last Monday (21 January):
*The 34 Labour MPs who voted against supporting our forces in the Gulf are a bunch of treacherous swine. For they have betrayed their country and their party.
*They have betrayed the men and women who are prepared to lay down their lives in the fight to rid the world of a tyrant. They have slighted the captured air crew who - right now - are being tortured by Saddam Hussein and chers.
"They do not deserve to sit in our respected Parliament. They should be kicked out on their ears"...etc.
So much for free speech; so much for the freedom these blood-thirsty behind-the-line-heroes think Britain is fighting for in Kuwait!
So much for Neil Kinnock. Despite Kinnock, the labour movement - including those who support war - should speak out in defence of free speech, and in favour of the freedom to discuss the issues raised by the war.
Advisor/ raham Bash MadicirDerer latinararian Late Pens lace Sectonsi Eric Heffer MP Dorothy Macedo Joe Marino John M1 loy John Nicholson Peten etchel Members of the Advisory Committee are drawn from a broad cross-section of the left who are opposed to une Labour dry s wutch hunt asains socialist Uruaniser Views expressed in articles are the asponsibi Of Che duisory Editorial Board.
Scan page 4
Organiser GRAFF