Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The rule of the rip-off

Socialist Organiser no. 469, 8 December 1990 · scan p. 15 · Chris Reynolds · about 653 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 15 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 15

Books Chris Reynolds reviews. 'Liar's Poker', by Michael Lewis (Coronet, £4.50)

This is a sort of companion volume to Barbarians at the Gate', , reviewed in SO a few weeks ago.

Like 'Barbarians', it strips away the myths about the fair and efficient free-market economy, and shows us what capitalists actually do. They spend their time and energy not on developing better products or streamlining work, but on ripping people off.

'Barbarians' showed us the sharks of Wall Street in action. "Poker" shows us how relatively decent middle-class young men are turned into beasts by the financial markets.

"Life as a Salomon trainee [Salomons is the big Wall Street firm for which Lewis worked in New York and London] was like being beaten up every day by the neighbourhood bully. Eventually you grew mean and surly."

The atmosphere in the trading rooms is something between a raucous student boys' club and a tank full of fish-eating fish. Every other human aspiration is stamped underfoot in favour of money"Watching the faces of people as they emerged from their meetings [with management on their annual bonuses] was worth a thousand lectures on the meaning of money in our small society...

*The look on their faces was always the same no matter what the size of their bonus: they looked sick to their stomachs. It was as if they had eaten too much chocolate pie."

What does this do to the traders' human relations with each other, let alone to their feelings for people outside their office? Lewis records the advice he was given by a sharpwitted trader.

*When you arrive at six thirty a.m., having had no sleep the night before, and having lost your best friend in a car accident, and some Big Swinging Dick walks over to your desk, slaps you on the back, and says, 'How the hell are you?' you don't say, I'm really tired and upset. . You say, I'm great, how the hell are you?' These are the people who control the wealth of society under this capitalist system. ed fiction. June, who's no writer, but who has sold herself to keep Miller in pens and paper, feels cheated. She at least has lived, and now both Miller and Nin are using her to write about. She wouldn't mind so much if the writing was good. But it's not. She finds Nin's word "poetic, •sorta" , but she thinks Miller's is trash. "I thought I was getting Dostoievsky," she rails at him.

Nin and Miller come across as people who cannot feel, who only try emotions on, and thus have to substitute thrills for feeling. Their sexual experimentation is a cover for shallowness.

Despite its length, the film gives no sense of any connection at all between any of the characters: we can't see what attracts June to Nin. or Nin to Henry, or why Hugo remains devoted to Nin. No-onc develops as a character. The film sees them only from the outside. even in their most intimate moments. But its politics vacillate between sentimental semi-Stalinism and anarchism. With half its heart, it mourns some socialist hope or intention which it divines beneath the brutal front of the old regime; with the other half, it believes that all power corrupts and the only real revolutionary programme is one of opposition to all and every authority.

Probably this vacilation corresponds to real impulses in the mind of the writer, David Edgar, a former libertarian socialist who in recent years has written for the CP's Marxism Today.

An oddity of the play is its women characters. They are all pointedly assigned subordinate roles (secretaries and so on) in their various political camps. From a Western leftist writer in 1990, this must be designed to make a point: but what, I don't know, unless it is just that the new post-Stalinist order promises no better for women than the old regime.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 469

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →