Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Glasnost South African stvle

Socialist Organiser no. 469, 8 December 1990 · scan pp. 14–15 · Colin Foster · about 2,841 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 14

Robert Fine, author of the recently published book, "Beyond Apartheid', surveys developments in South Afric since the release of Mandela and the unbanning of the African National Congress in February this year. Reform from above holds no less dangers to the rulers in South Africa it does Eastern Europe and in South Africa despotic regimes have found themselves confronted by the consequences of their own forms of misrule, as they led to economic stagnation, social misery and political revolt.

In both situations the forces for change have been parallel: first, a nationalist intelligentsia dedicated to the achievement of democracy and national independence; second, a 'modernising' reformist wing of the existing government and bureaucracy; third, external pressures from 'western' capital and a hands-off policy from the Soviet Union; and lastly, mass protest movements among the people. In both contexts these pressures mounted dramatically in the 1980s.

In South Africa the initiative came from the government nine months ago, when it released Mandela, legalised the ANC and other political opposition groups, agreed to release political prisoners and allow political exiles to return, entered into talks with ANC representatives and proffered negotiations over a new constitution. For the ANC, this marked the end of the period of armed struggle which had lasted since the mid-1960s and in which any form of "official' negotiations or participation had been ruled out by the nationalist politicians.

Democratisation from above has been closely linked to 'marketisation'. In South Africa, this has taken a number of related forms: a government programme of privatisation and/or deregulation of the huge nationalised and parastatal sector; the de-nationalisation of ISCOR, the iron and steel combine, being the first case in point; government efforts to persuade the Amounts township roadblock ANC and its allies in the Communist Party and the trade union federation, COSATU, to drop its prior demands for the nationalisation of the mines and major monopolies; government and business policies favouring the growth of a black bourgeoisie, and an ideological offensive designed to dissociate capitalism from apartheid. From the Soviet Union a number of statements have been made indicating that the Soviet government considered South Africa to be 'unripe for socialism' and a legitimate part of the "western' bloc.

The prospects of democracy are better than they have been, but remain precarious in the face of huge economic problems, entrenched authoritarian tendencies in both government and opposition movements and the channelling of popular discontents into nationalist, ethnic and racialist forms.

In South Africa the violence between the Zulu-nationalist Inkatha movement and the Africannationalist ANC has only been the visible symptom of the fragmentation of identities (like the "African nation' or the 'people') and intolerance of political ditterences. The sharper the conflicts within civil society, the more likely it becomes that the new state, however composed, will use its authority to impose order from above.

he working class is weak as In South Africa 'social movement' trade unions have played a leading role in organising workers, fighting for economic demands and mobilising opposition to the old regimes. At present the trade unions are the most representative body in South African society.

However, the leadership of COSATU has come under the sway of nationalist politicians, so that the union has found it difficult to combine organisational with political independence. In South Africa COSATU is for the time being firmly attached to the ANC-Communist Party nexus, in spite of opposition from the Pan African Congress, Black Consciousness groups and a few independent socialists.

Some previously independent socialists and trade unionists like Moses Mayekiso have been drawn to the Communist Party in spite of its Stalinist heritage, out of conviction that the SACP has now abandoned its old ideas and methods, or out of a belief that the SACP can be turned into a democratic mass - -EH Can the deal hold? workers' party or out of fear of the consequences of not supporting the Se in at ser than o of the his heo order they have so long fought for.

Communism is less discredited in South Africa than in Eastern Europe for reasons not hard to fathom: the SACP had been banned for 40 years, the Soviet Union gave political, financial and military support to the movement, the SACP is closely allied to the ANC, it is the only apparent socialist party in South Africa.

The relative lack of success of the SACP has been in part a function of a lack of viable socialist alternatives. One major problem in Trotskyist circles has been the identification of Stalinism with a 'right wing' deviation, especially two-stage theory' and the postponement of socialism, and conversely the identification of anti-Stalinism with a yet more revolutionary form of nationalism.

Not only does this paint a one-sided picture of the history of the SACP, which has shown itself capable of swinging from "right' to "left' and back again - as its 'left' turn in the mid-1980s witnesses -but it turns 'anti-Stalinism' into little more than the extreme 'left' face of that which it opposes. In the current period, this attitude has led the 'anti-Stalinist' groups into the dangerous revolutionary nationalism' shown by the Pan African Congress and Azapo or the dead-end of opposing negotiations in toto.

oth with the trade union movement and in left public opinion more generally, there ure important attempts to instil an "Violence between the Zulu-nationalist Inkatha movement and the Africanidentities (like the intolerance of political differences independent workers' voice into both the form and content of negotiations.

For example, the Clothing and Textiles Workers Union have put forward a draft workers charter for adoption by COSATU which it wants introduced into the negotiations between the ANC and government and then into any new constitution. The charter contains important clauses on union rights (including the right to strike), industrial democracy (including the right of union representatives to sit on boards of management) and workers rights (like those against unfair dismissal).

It is a superior document to the SACP's draft workers charter which does not seem to be aimed at inclusion in the new constitution. The SACP document also contains dangerous Causes about institu tionalising in law the principles of 'one industry - one union' and 'one country - one federation'. If this were done, it could make a mockery of the right of workers to join a union of their own choice, and buttress the hold of the SACP or any other union bosses over their members.

In other areas of political life like in the radical journal Work in Progress' - there are to be found criticisms not of the principle of negotiations but of how they are being conducted. The issues being taken up include: the new membership entering the ANC (in some areas homelands heres rand chiefs, entrepreneurs, "securocrats'); the appeals of the ANC to business for funds for in one case for a fleet of BMWs); the inability of the ANC to protect their supporters from the terrible violence in the townships particularly in the recent killings in the Transvaal); problems of internal democracy within the ANC (the national conference has been postponed from December 1990 to June 1991); the appointment of Winnie Mandela to head the department of social welfare (while she is on trial for her part in the murder of Stompie Moeketsi and the kidnapping and beatings of other youths, and while leading sections of the mass democratic movement have condemned the reign of terror' of her "football team' bodyguards); lack of communication between the ANC and people in the townships; the two hats worn by ANC leaders who are also SACP; and so forth.

Equally important are the economic and constitutional ideas with which the ANC and its allies are going to enter negotiations. There is a lot of confusion over the role of planning and nationalisation, since South Africa already has a highly nationalised and planned economy, and most people are talking in terms of some kind of mixed economy and a constitution which protects the rights of minorities.

The most important item on the left agenda is to limit the power and scope of the new bureaucracy likely to emerge in post-apartheid South Africa. The state bureaucracy already huge and powerful but the growth social programmes, Africanisation, the construction of new career ladders, the protection of old white jobs - all these factors are capable of creating a monster that could suck the country dry. Critical voices on the left are widely to be heard but they have not been able or willing to form any cohesive opposition. Troice for wokers, but This is he new situation offers space voice for workers, but this is bound to be a rocky road. There is a fine socialist tradition in South Africa, but it has long been overshadowed by the combined forces of nationalism and Stalinism.

A few years ago the trade unions offered a political alternative, but the more naive expectations concerning the potential of independent trade unionism was probably exaggerated on the left. The trade union left could perform this role in the future, but not apart from a renewed battle for socialist ideas.

Scan page 15

tles: ludicrous but lucrative! We sent Thomas P Carlyle, SO's special investigator int Xmas movies for kids, to check out the Ninja Turtles film. This is his report Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles' (TMNT), which came out at the beginning of December, is the only new children's movie this Xmas.

It is a sad farce of a movie. The whole cult of TMNT is an enormous money-spinner, with no conscience at all.

The story is as follows. A rat once owned as a pet by a Ninja (an Belinda Weaver reviews "Henry and June" Hoe excusable as and t mean enry and June' would only But this long (and I mean long) and squirmingly reverent look at the relationship between the writers Henry Miller and Anais Nin is played absolutely straight as if every word from their lips was a pearl to be cherished.

Wrong on all counts! What the film can't help but show is a couple of shallow posers dramatising themselves and apeing great emotions. You feel Nin and Miller wouldn't bother doing anything they couldn't boast about later, and for all their supposed liberation, they're hopelessly shackled to their own egos and their burning desire for celebrityThe film is utterly pretentious, treating its Americans-in-Paris-inthe-thirties milieu as if it were heaven itself. Perhaps it is to filmmaker Philip Kaufman, but it's hell for the audience. The only light relief in 'Henry and June' is provided by the pifflingly ponderous dialogue (along the lines of "He made me a woman) which provoked whoops of (unintended laughter from the audience.

The film is full of ancient Japanese martial arts warrior) finds four baby turtles in a sewer, and is mutated along with them by a flask of radioactive waste. They all develop a human level of intelligence.

Stop giggling! Here comes the really stupid bit: The rat (Splinter) teaches the four turtles the fighting art of the Ninja.

The explanation for the rat being able to do this is that he mimicked his master, watching him through the bars of his cage, until he himself became a Ninja...

The ludicrous (but lucrative) foursome, along with their master, spend 15 years training in their New York sewer headquarters. In that time they develop a passion for pizza! Their reason for training is never clearly told, you just have to imagine them fitting themselves inLeft is Maria de Madeiros as Anais Nin, right could say and hope to keep his dignity; the whole thing is mortifyingly stupid. It treats these shallow people as gods.

At the beginning, Nin is bored by her dull banker husband; she longs to meet a "real man" - When Miller turns up, rude, balding, grubby (and with a killer five o'clock shadow) he seems to fit her bill. She pursues him. One minute he's not interested; the next it's blissful rape (for her). Haven't we already seen one film too many where the heroine is overpowered by a man, tries to fight him off, then happily to one of the old comic-book fighters scenarios.

Anyway, after 15 years of prancing around in the sewers the turtles start fighting the crime wave that is supposedly engulfing the city of New York.

They foil the mugging of a top news reporter, April O'Neal, and she soon becomes the ally of the TMNT, After a few confrontations, pizzas and corny jokes, and lots of violence, their great enemy becomes known: The Shredder.

He is a sort of martial arts Fagin, recruiting a gang of kids for his martial arts army, to rob New York. A masked knight in jagged armour, his real identity remains unknown until the end of the film.

The film doesn't get more stupid as it unravels, it is always ludicrous, is Uma Thurman as June Miller surrenders? I know I have. And this happens not once, but twice!

Why any filmmaker would put up Fred Ward's Miller as the acme of male desirability is a question I wouldn't even try to answer. And why anyone would swoon over Maria de Madeiros's Anais Nin is also a puzzle; she's just a blank, a big gaping hole on the screen.

The only person in the film with any presence at all is Miller's wife June (played by Uma Thurman), who burns up the screen. But we get too much of her; she should be glimpsed, not feasted on the way yet it is already a money maker of gargantuan proportions, preying on the easily-led. Twenty eight thousand young people a week (in Britain) now join the Turtles fan club.

Let the truth be told: TMNT is just a ludicrous story out of a 1950s horror comic, revived by clever people who breathed life into it with money, and good special effects (the only attraction of the film for me were the special effects), and lashings of hype.

The Turtle memorabilia industry is a lucrative part of the hype: pizzas, bed covers, T-shirts, video games, cartoons, comics, hats, bum bags, posters, teddy bears, toy figures you name it, the shops have it.

But, the movie I'm afraid, doesn't "have it"! she is here. With her smudgy eyed beauty, and her great sensual presence, she's worth looking at, but in scene after scene, she's forced to come on like a silent movie vamp, all narrowed eyes and pouty ups, and her role becomes embarrassing.

Her best moment is when (after almost seducing Nin), she rejects her, saying that Nin has no real feelings, that all she wants is experience. After two hours of Nin's nonsense, this is a pretty welcome summing up.

June is outraged by the "cannibalism" of both Miller and Nin, who digest their friends and lovers and spit them out as thinly disguisiocialist Organiser No. 46. Colin Foster reviews David Edgar's new play. 'The Shape of the Table', now at the National Theatre in London this play about the East European revolutions of 1989,t turns out, paradoxically, that the only real revolutionary is the old Stalinist despot whom the revolution overthrows.

The script is closely modelled on events in Czechoslovakia. The character corresponding to Gustav Husak, the old CP leader, makes his entrance as a murderous thug.

Even then, though, he is allowed a dry intelligence. As the play unfolds, he becomes a tragic and sympathetic character.

A former working-class organiser, a survivor of the Nazi concentration camps, a man who helped organise the CP seizure of power after World War 2 with the highest hopes of building a new society, and a veteran of Stalinist prisons too (jailed in the 1950s as a Titoite), he ends up blaming himself for the abuses of Stalinism; but he goes to the prisons of the new post-Stalinist order with dignity.

The play makes vivid and finelypainted characters out of other leading figures of the old regime, too. In contrast, the anti-Stalinist "With half its heart, it mourns some opposition leaders are pallid.

A washed-out Vaclav Havel figure proclaims that the aim of the revolution is to get the country back to "normal" , ie. the model of Western capitalism. The radical in his camp is no more than a loutish student loudmouth and, as it turns out, a charlatan too.

There are no characters corresponding to the figures in the real Czechoslovakian opposition which most dramatise the dilemmas of the revolution. None corresponding to Vaclav Klaus, the architect of the new regime's free-market economics, who was not a persecuted oppositionist under the old regime but simply an economist who didn't get as much promotion as he might have done with other views; none corresponding to Petr Uhl, Trotskyist, founder of Charter 77, and founder of Left Alternative'.

The play is not Stalinist. It is clearly on the side of the revolution.

----- pull-quotes -----

nationalist ANC has only been the visibl symptom of the fragmentation of

'African nation' or the 'people') and

A revolution revolutionaries Theatre

socialist hope intention."

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 469

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →