['Parvus' (Alexander Helfand) was the pioneer, with Trotsky…]
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-12-08Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 12
'Parvus' (Alexander Helfand) was the pioneer, with Trotsky, of the idea that a workers' government could take power in backward Russia. He was a maverick left-winger, active mainly in the German Socialist movement, who became a war profiteer in World War L he theory of permanent revolution was usually associated with the names of Parvus and Trotsky". That was only partially correct.
Parvus attained revolutionary maturity at the end of the preceding century, when he marched at the head of the forces that fought so-called Revisionism", ie. the opportunistic distortions of Marx's theory. But his optimism was undermined by the failure of all his efforts to push the German Social-Democracy in the direction of a more resolute policy. Parvus grew increasingly more reserved about the perspectives of a socialist revolution in the West.
At the same time he felt that "the Social-Democratic provisional government cannot accomplish a socialist insurrection in Russia." Hence, his prognosis indicated, instead of the transformation of the democratic into the socialist revolution, merely the establishment in Russia of a regime of workers' democracy, more or less as in Australia, where the first labour government, resting on a farmerist foundation, did not venture beyond the limits of the bourgeois regime.
I did not share that conclusion. Australian democracy, maturing organically on the virgin. soil of a new continent, immediately assumed a conservative character and dominated the youthful yet rather privileged proletariat. Russian democracy, on the contrary, could come about only in consequence of a large-scale revolutionary insurrection, the dynamics of which would never
Scan page 13
permit the labour government to maintain itself within the framework of bourgeois democracy.
Our differences of opinion, which began soon after the Revolution of 1905, led to a complete break at the beginning of the war, when Parvus, in whom the sceptic had completely killed the revolutionist, proved to be on the side of German imperialism and subsequently became the counsellor and inspirer of the First President of the German Republic, Ebert.
After writing my pamphlet, *Until the Ninth of January", I repeatedly returned to the development and the grounding of the theory of permanent revolution. It is necessary to present it here in the form of exact quotations from my works of the years 1905 and 1906.
*The nucleus of population in a contemporary city — at least, in a city of economic and political significance — is the sharply differentiated class of hired labour. It is this class, essentially unknown to the Great French Revolution, which is fated to play the decisive role in our revolution... In an economically more backward country the proletariat may come to power sooner than in a country more advanced capitalistically. The conception of a kind of automatic dependence of the proletarian dictatorship on a country's technical forces and means is a prejudice of extremely simplified 'economic' materialism. Such a view has nothing in common with Marxism...Notwithstanding the fact that the productive forces of the United States industry are ten times greater than ours, the political role of the Russian proletariat, its influence on the politics of its own country and the possibility that it may soon influence world politics are incomparably greater than the role and significance of the American proletariat...
The Soviet of workers and soldiers' deputies in session, 1917 hostages but as the leading force, the representatives of the proletariat will by virtue of that alone smash the demarcation between the minimal and maximal programme, ie. place collectivism on the order of the day. At what point in that tendency the proletariat would be stopped will depend on the inter-relation of forces, but certainly not on the initial intentions of the proletariat's par"But we may already ask ourselves: must the dictatorship of the proletariat inevitably smash itself against the framework of the bourgeois revolution or can it, on the basis of the existing historical situation of the world look forward to the perspective of victory, after smashing this limiting framework?….
"One thing may be said with certainty: without the direct governmental support of the European proletariat, the working class of Russia will not be able to maintain itself in power and transform its temporary reign into an enduring socialist dictatorship...
But this does not necessarly lead to a pessimistic prognosis: "the political liberation, led by the working class of Russia, will raise the leader to a height unprecedented in history, transmit to him colossal forces and means, and make him the initiator of the worldwide liquidation of capitalism, for which history has created all the objective prerequisities...'"' As to the extent to which international Social-Democracy will prove capable of fulfilling its revolutionary task, I wrote in 1906: "The European Socialist parties — and in the first place, the mightiest of them, the German party - have developed their conservatism, which grows stronger in proportion to the size of the masses embraced by socialism and the effectiveness of the organisation and the discipline of these masses. Because of that, the Social-Democracy, as the organisation that embodies the political experience of the proletariat, may at a given moment become the immediate obstacle on the path of an open clash between the workers and the bourgeois reaction..."
Yet I concluded my analysis by expressing the assurance that "the Eastern revolution will infect the Western proletariat with revolutionary idealism and arouse in it the desire to start talking "Russian" with its enemy..." Socialist Organiser No. 469 page 13 Does the historical fate of the Russian workers' revolution endorse in retrospect the verdict of those scholastic Marxists like Karl Kautsky who condemned Lenin and the Bolsheviks as adventurists -people who took a leap in the dark?
It is best to let the splendid revolutionary Marxist Rosa Luxemburg answer that question. Luxemburg was an rdent supporter of the Russian Revolution, but also a sharp critic of the policy of the Bolsheviks. She differed with them on their land policy and on their national policy. She criticised the Red Terror and