The fate of the Russian Revolution permanent
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-12-08Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 12
noituloveR nsiezun uch were the divergent positions of the two Social-Democracy. But alongside them, as early as the dawn of the First Revolution, a third position was formulated, which met with practically no recognition in those days, but which we must explain — not only because it was confirmed by the events of 1917, but particularly because seven years after the Revolution, after being turned upside down, it began to play an utterly unforeseen role in the political evolution of Stalin and of the entire Soviet bureaucracy.
Early in 1905 I published in Geneva a pamphlet which analysed the political situation as it existed around the winter of 1904. I came to the conclusion that the independent campaign of liberal petitions and banquets had exhausted its possibilities; that the radical intellectuals, who had shifted their hopes to the liberals, had found themselves in a blind alley together with the latter; that the peasant movement was creating conditions favourable for victory yet incapable of assuring it; that the showdown could be brought about only through an armed insurrection of the proletariat; that the very next stage along that way must be the general strike. This pamphlet called "Until the Ninth of January" , had been written prior to the Bloody Sunday in Petersburg. The powerful wave of strikes which began that day, together with the first armed clashes that supplemented it, was an unequivocal confirmation of the pamphlet's strategic prognosis.
The preface to my work was written by Parvus, a Russian emigré, who had already become by then a prominent German writer. Parvus's was an extraordinarily creative personality, capable of becoming infected with the ideas of others as well as enriching others with his ideas. He lacked the tribute anything worthy of his talents as a thinker inward balance and application necessary to con- began to establish large cities in its own image, that is, factory towns and centres of world trade... and writer to the labour movement. There is no doubt that he exerted considerable influence on "That which had hindered the development of my personal development, especially with respect to the social-revolutionary understanding of our petty bourgeois democracy came to benefit the class consciousness of the proletariat in Russia — the weak development of the artisan form of proepoch. A few years before our first meeting Parvus duction. The proletariat was immediately concenpassionately defended the idea of a general strike trated in the factories... in Germany; but the country was passing through "Greater and greater masses of peasants will be prolonged industrial prosperity, the Social- drawn into the movement. But all they can do is Democracy was adjusting itself to the Hohen- to aggravate the political anarchy already ramzollern regime, and a foreigner's revolutionary pant in the country and thus weaken the governpropaganda met nothing but ironical indifference. ment; they cannot become a compact revoluHaving read my pamphlet in manuscript, the tionary army. Hence, as the revolution develops, very next day after the bloody events in an ever greater portion of political work will fall Petersburg, Parvus was overwhelmed with the to the lot of the proletariat. At the same time its thought of the exceptional role which the pro- political awareness will be enhanced and its letariat of backward Russia was called upon to political energy will grow apace... play. Several days spent jointly in Munich were *The Social-Democracy will be confronted filled with conversations that clarified much to the provisional government or to stand aloof from with this dilemma: to assume responsibility for both of us and brought us personally close together. The preface Parvus then wrote to the the labour movement. The workers will regard pamphlet entered permanently into the history of that government as their own, no matter what the attitude of the Social-Democracy...In Russia only the Russian Revolution. In a few pages he shed light on those social workers can accomplish a revolutionary insurrecpeculiarities of backward Russia which, true tion. In Russia the revolutionary provisional enough, were already well known, but from which government will be a government of the workers?
no one before him had drawn all the necessary in- democracy. That government will be Social-Democratic, should the Social-Democracy be at ferences. "Political radicalism throughout Western the head of the revolutionary movement of the Europe," wrote Parvus, "as everybody knows, Russian proletariat...
depended primarily upon the petty bourgeoisie. *The Social-Democratic provisional governThese were artisans and generally all of that part ment cannot accomplish a socialist insurrection in of the bourgeoisie which was caught up by the in- Russia, but the very process of liquidating the dustrial development but which at the same time autocracy and establishing a democratic republic was superseded by the class of capitalists... will provide it with fertile ground for political ac*In Russia of the pre-capitalist period cities tivity."
developed on the Chinese rather than on the In the heyday of revolutionary events, in the European model. These were administrative cen- autumn of 1905, I met Parvus again, this time in tres, purely official and bureaucratic in character, Petersburg. Remaining organisationally independevoid of any political significance, while in the dent of both factions, we jointly edited Russkoye economic sense they were trade bazaars for the Slovo (The Russian Word), a newspaper for the landlord and peasant milieu of its environs. Their working class masses, and in coalition with the development was still rather inconsiderable, when Mensheviks, the important political newspaper, it was terminated by the capitalist process, which Nachalo (The Beginning). Revolutionary workers in 1917