Populism: old and new
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-12-08Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 11
first Red Flag to be raised by soldiers on the front 1917 iberalism while the peasant movement will pour their mill."
Lenin made sport of Jordania's misgivings that an irreconcilable policy toward the bourgeoisie might doom the workers to helplessness. Jordania *discusses the question of a possible isolation of the proletariat in the democratic insurrection and forgets...the peasantry! Of the possible allies of the proletariat, he recognises and takes delight in the landed gentry of the county councils, but he does not recognise the peasants. And that in the Caucasus!"
Lenin's retort, essentially correct, oversimplified the question on one point. Jordania did not "forget" the peasantry and, as is evident from Lenin's own hint, could not have possibly forgotten it in the Caucasus, where it was then stormily rising under the banner of the Mensheviks. But Jordania saw the peasantry not so much as a political ally as a political battering ram which the bourgeoisie could and should utilise in union with the proletariat. He did not believe that the peasantry could become a leading or even an independent force of the revolution, and in that he was not wrong; but neither did he believe that the proletariat could secure the victory of the peasant uprising in the role of leader - and in that was his fatal error.
The Menshevik idea of union between the proletariat and the bourgeoisie actually meant submission of the workers as well as the peasants to the liberals. The reactionary utopianism of that programme proceeded from the fact that the fargone dismemberment of the classes paralysed the bourgeoisie from the start as a revolutionary factor. In that fundamental question Bolshevism was right: the quest of union with the liberal bourgeoisie was perforce driving the Social-Democracy into the camp opposed to the revolutionary movement of the workers and peasants.
In 1905 the Mensheviks merely lacked the courage to draw all the necessary inferences from their theory of "bourgeois" revolution. In 1917, pursuing their ideas to the bitter end, they broke their neck.
On the question of the attitude towards the liberals Stalin sided with Lenin during the years of the First Revolution. It must be said that in that period, when it was a question of the opposiopulists regarded all workers and peasants who were equally interested in socialism, while to Marxists a peasant was a petty-bourgeois, capable of becoming a socialist only to the extent that he materially or spiritually ceased being a peasant. With a sentimentality characteristic of them, Populists saw in that sociological characterisation a dire insult to the peasantry.
Along that line was fought for two generations the principal battle between the revolutionary tendencies of Russia.
In order to understand the subsequent conflict between Stalinism and Trotskyism, it is necessary to emphasise that, in consonance with all Marxist tradition, Lenin never regarded the peasant as a socialist ally of the proletariat; on the contrary, it was the overwhelming preponderance of the peasantry which had led Lenin to conclude that a socialist revolution was impossible in Russia. That idea recurs time and again in all his articles that directly or indirectly touch upon the agrarian question.
"We support the peasant movement", wrote Lenin in September, 1905, "in so far as it is revolutionary and democratic. We are preparing (at once, immediately preparing) to fight against it in so far as it asserts itself as a reactionary antiproletarian movement. The whole essence of Marxism is in that twofold task...
Lenin saw the Western proletariat and to some extent the semi-proletarians of the Russian village as socialist allies, but never the whole of the peasantry. "At first, we support to the very end, with all means, including confiscation," he repeated with persistence typical of him, "the peasant in general against the landed proprietor, but later (and not even later, but at the very same time) we support the proletariat against the peasant in general."
"The peasantry will win in a bourgeois democratic revolution," he wrote in March 1906, "and thereby will completely exhaust its revolutionism as a peasantry. The proletariat will win in a bourgeois democratic revolution and thereby will only begin really to unfold its true socialist revolutionism."
'The movement of the peasantry," he repeated in May of the same year, "is the movement of another class; it is a struggle not against the foundations of capitalism but for their purging of all the remnants of serfdom."
That view may be traced in Lenin from article to article, from year to year, from volume to volume. Expressions and illustrations vary, but the basic thought is unalterable. Nor could it have been otherwise.
Had Lenin seen a socialist ally in the peasantry he would not have had the slightest basis for insisting upon the bourgeois character of the revolution and limiting it to "the dictatorship of the proletariat and the peasantry" , to purely democratic tasks. On the occasions when Lenin accused me of "underestimating" the peasantry, he did not have in mind my failure to recognise the socialist tendencies of the peasantry but rather my failure to realise sufficiently, from Lenin's point of view, the bourgeois-democratic independence of the peasantry, its capacity to create its own power and through it impede the establishment of the socialist dictatorship of the proletariat.
The revaluation of that question commenced only during the years of the thermidorian reaction, the beginning of which coincided by and large with Lenin's illness and death. From then on the union of Russian workers and peasants was declared to be in itself sufficient guarantee against the dangers of restoration and a firm pledge that socialism would be achieved within the borders of the Soviet Union. Having substituted the theory of socialism in a separate country for the theory of international revolution, Stalin began to call the Marxist evaluation of the peasantry *Trotskyism" , and moreover not only with reference to the present but retroactively to the entire past.
It is, of course, possible to ask whether the classical Marxist view of the peasantry had not proved erroneous. That theme would lead us far beyond the limits of this appendix. Suffice it to say for the nonce that Marxism never ascribed an absolute and immutable character to its estimation of the peasantry as a non-socialist class. Marx said long ago that the peasant is capable of judgement as well as prejudgement. The very nature of the peasantry is altered under altered conditions. The regime of the dictatorship of the proletariat discovered very great possibilities for influencing the peasantry and for re-educating it. History has not yet plumbed to the bottom of the limits of these possibilities. But it is already clear that the growing role of state compulsion in the USSR, far from refuting, has basically confirmed the very view of the peasantry that distinguished Russian Marxists from Populists.
Yet, whatever the situation on that score today, after twenty-odd years of the new regime. the fact remains that prior to the October Revolution, or rather prior to the year 1924, no one in the Marxist camp, and least of all Lenin, had regarded the peasantry as a factor of socialist development. Without the aid of a proletarian revolution in the West, he reiterated time and again, restoration is unavoidable in Russia. He was not mistaken: the Stalinist bureaucracy is nothing else than the first stage of bourgeois restoration.
Sverdlov was the chief organiser of the Bolshevik Party in the years of revolution and civil war. He died young, from disease, during the civil war.
Father Gapon, a priest and a police agent, nevertheless led a workers' demonstration to the Tsar's palace in January 1905.
The shooting-down of the workers - who wanted to appeal to the 'good Tsar' against the bad employers and state officials - sparked off revolutionary upheavals.
The Tsarist regime had set up trade unions secretly controlled by the police (called "Zubatov unions" after their organiser), in an effort to divert workers becoming militant over wages and conditions away from the socialists. The tactic didn't work, however, The "Zubatov unions" were forced to support strikes, and the socialists worked within them to spread their ideas.