Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The two factions

Socialist Organiser no. 469, 8 December 1990 · scan p. 9 · about 808 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

T divergence between the two factions. his was the starting point for the fundamental Bolshevism resolutely refused to acknowledge that the Russian bourgeoisie was capable of consummating its own revolution. With immeasurably greater force and consistency than Plekhanov, Lenin advanced the agrarian question as the central problem of the democratic revolution in Russia: "The crux of the Russian Revolution is the agrarian (the land) question. We must make up our minds about the defeat or victory of the revolution....on the basis of accounting for the condition of the masses in their struggle for At one with Plekhanov, Lenin regarded the peasantry as a petty-bourgeois class and the peasant land programme as the programme of bourgeois progressivism. "Nationalisation is a bourgeois measure, " he insisted at the Unification Congress. "It will give impetus to the development of capitalism by intensifying the class struggle, by strengthening the mobilisation of land and the investment of capital in agriculture, by lowerNotwithstanding the admitted bourgeois character of the agrarian revolution, the Russian bourgeoisie was nevertheless hostile to the expropriation of the land owned by the landed gentry, and precisely for that reason strove for a compromise with the monarchy on the basis of a constitution after the Prussian model. To the Plekhanovite idea of union between the proletariat and the liberal bourgeoisie, Lenin counterposed the idea of union between the proletariat He proclaimed the task of the revolutionary collaboration of these two classes to be the establishment of a "democratic dictatorship" the only means for radically purging Russia of its feudal refuse, creating a free class of farmers and opening the way for the development of capitalism after the American rather than the The victory of the revolution, he wrote, can be attained "only through dictatorship, because the realisation of the transformations immediately and unconditionally necessary for the proletariat and the peasantry will call forth the desperate resistance of the landlords, of the big bourgeoisie, and of Tsarism. Without dictatorship it would be impossible to break that resistance, it would be impossible to defeat counter-revolutionary efforts. That would be, needless to say, not a socialist, but a democratic dictatorship. It would not be able to dispose of (without a whole series of intermediary stages in revolutionary development) the foundations of capitalism. At best, it would be able to introduce a radical redistribution of land ownership for the benefit of the peasantry, carry out a consistent and complete democratisation, including a republic; uproot all the oppressive Asiatic characteristics in the life of the factory as well as the village; lay down the beginnings of important improvements in the condition of the workers; raise their standard of living; and finally, last but not least, carry the revolutionary conflagration into Europe."

Lenin's conception represented a tremendous step forward, proceeding as it did from the agrarian revolution rather than from constitutional reforms as the central task of the revolution, and indicating the only realistic combination of social forces that could fulfill that task. The weak point of Lenin's concept was its inherently contradictory notion, "the democratic dictatorship of the proletariat and the peasantry"

Lenin himself emphasised the basic limitations of that "dictatorship" when he openly called it bourgeois. He was thus implying that, for the sake of maintaining unity with the peasantry, the proletariat would be obliged to forego posing the socialist task directly during the impending The fate of the Russian Revolutior : than the ity are so iditioning lows that cumbent lates the rengthentheir own le which an workpressure argeoisie as a class... khanov.

he Russian Social-Democracy.

- such was the perspective.

George Plekhanov was the leader of the first Russian Marxist group, the 'Emancipation of Labour Group', formed in exile in 1883 after Plekhanov broke away from the populists (qv). He played a prominent role in the Russian Marxist movement for land." many years, but moved to the right in World War I, supporting Russia in the war and bitterly opposing the Bolsheviks in 1917.

Wing the prices on grain.* arricade and the peasantry.

Prussian model. democratic republic"

Petrograd. enemyliberal bourgeoisie.

Pavel Axelrod was a member, with Plekhanov and Zasulich, of the first Russian Marxist group (in exile). After 1903 he supported the Mensheviks.

Julius Martov was Lenin's closest comrade when they were both young Marxists in the 1890s, but became the leader of the Mensheviks after 1903. In 1917 and after he led a leftwing faction of the Mensheviks which, though opposing the Revolution, subsequently gave critical support to the workers" Vera Zasulich was a member, with Piekhanov and Axeirod, of the first Russian Marxist group (in exile). Before becoming a Marxist she had been a populist, famous for her part in the attempt to kill the notorious Tsarist General Trepov. After 1903 she supported the Mensheviks.

Trotsky and his first wife, Alexandra, in exile in Siberia.

Alexandra won Trotsky to Marxism

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 469

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →