The fate of the Russian Revolution What the
Socialist Organiser1990 1990-12-08Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
Pd changed everything. Given the isola- Trotsky, that you were righ le Russian revolution, defeat became revolution of 1923, the Brit . Trotsky and Lenin always knew that. 1926, the Chinese revolutic ois triumphalism and the mass rise to power, and the Spani from even nominal socialism of the yet we are still a tiny, isolat It presses down even on the Trot- If your ideas do not prevail, though our version of Marxism is vin- German, Chinese, British,
mea
1905: strikes broke out in December 1904 and January 1905. On 9 January workers marching to the Tsar's palace to appeal for his help were shot down. The strike wave grew.
Strikes continued through the summer. Peasants withheld taxes. Sailors mutinied on the battleship "Potemkin'.
In September a new strike wave exploded. A joint council of workers' delegates — a 'soviet' in Russian - was set up in St Petersburg (Leningrad).
In December the Tsar regained the initiative, arresting the Executive of the St Petersburg soviet. An armed workers' uprising in Moscow was put down. Bourgeois revolution: by this term Marxists meant a revolution that would break the power of the Tsar (king) and the landed nobility, raising up a new rulin class from the industrialists, merchants and bankers. It would replace hereditary privilege as the keystone of society with profits made in the market place. Populism, in Russia, meant revolutionary politics which looked to a revolution made by 'the people' in general (not the workers particularly). The populists usually argued that Russia need not (or could not) go through capitalist development, but could instead go straight from Tsarism to a sort of peasant-based socialism. Tactically the populists often favoured conspiracies to assassinate leading figures of the Tsarist regime as a way to arouse the people.
Menshevik: the less revolutionary wing in the split in the Russian socialist movement after 1903. Although the split was originally about obscure organisational issues, it quickly gained political substance. The Mensheviks' strategy was to push the bourgeoisie (the industrialists, merchants and bankers) into leading the bourgeois revolution — and this meant the workers must be careful not to frighten the bourgeoisie off. Bolshevik: the more revolutionary wing in the split the Russian socialist movement after 1903. In contrast to the Mensheviks (qv), the Bolsheviks argued for the workers to fight to take the lead and to drive the revolution forward as far as possible. Even though (before 1917) they calculated that it would be impossi ble for the workers to drive the revolution beyond the level of radical democratic measures within a society still based on private profit and private ownership of the means of production, they believed that if the workers did not lead the "bourgeois revolution' the bourgeoisie would make no revolution at all.
Correspondingly, the Bolsheviks argued for a tighter, more clearly defined party organisation than
From page 7
power anc
tion of th inevitable Bourge renegacy Stalinists course e socialists. skyists, al
An introduction
and their fellow-travellers does of „group? kert a great pressure now on all
dicated - the Marxism del Fending which many thousands of our comrades l have died, in a struggle to the death with the murderous Stalinist counterfeit in the Soviet l Jnion, in China, in Spain, and elsewhere.
In the late 1930s CL RJ ames talked to Trotsky. How, he asked, is it possible, comrade
It about the German
Wish general strike of on in 1927, Hitler's ish Civil War - and ed, persecuted little Trotsky replied that to be down to crushing defeat, then being not protect you from the general de class. The defeated movement declin go down with it. We cannot rise high class whose vigour, elan and combati central and irreplaceable and all-co for our politics. Worse: experience working-class defeat strengthens bureaucracies and thus further revolutionaries.
Thus it is now. The reformists are: ed, though it was the reformists' trea Russian revolutionary workers and te working classes Western Eun isolated and defeated the heroic Rus ing class. une trotskyists too stare