Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The Czechs that don't want capitalism

Socialist Organiser no. 469, 8 December 1990 · scan p. 4 · about 1,840 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

Bush offers Vaclav Havel the future: you too can have mass unemployWho says shoppers put the widest range of choice as their first requirement from retailers?

A survey carried out by the University of Ulster (based on a survey of 300 Belfast shoppers) identified working women as by far the most im portant group of customers.

But they said the most important thing for them was ease of access - together with good parking facilities and flexible opening hours.

They'll be lucky. Supermarkets are deliberately organised so that the staples most people come to buy are way back in the store, furthest from the entry point. No, not capitalist bloodymindedness, capitalist cunning: that way people go all through the store and, often, they buy the things they had not come there to buy.

That's going on here? department. Two leading NUT activists were spotted on a train last weekend reading Socialist Organiser's review of Mr Tarig Ali's "novel" "Redemption', spluttering in "This is workerism," said one of them loudly. "Yes," replied the other, "/'d just love to have been born into Tariq Ali's class." "This is character assassination," the first one rejoined.

What makes this scene interesting is that one of them is a supporter of Socialist Outlook and the other is, believe it or not, the SWP's leading teacher!

Someone should tell them that the attitude you take to renegades says a great deal about what you yourself are. Usually it also tells you something about where you are going...

Hat as they intenaly uman beings make not as they intend, said Karl Marx.

Men and women act to achieve an objective: but they cannot see, still less foresee, and control, all the social factors in operation alongside their own will, and these warp and reshape their designs.

Often the result is something radically different from that intended.

The French Revolution was Classless Tories? AND A POUND OF SWEEPING REFORM.made by people willing to give their lives for real freedom and equality: it resulted in our bourgeois society with its grotesque inequalities erected on the mass wage slavery of the majority of the legally free and equal citizens. And it follows from this that often it falls to others to achieve longthwarted and half-forgotten objectives.

The great late 19th century English socialist William Morris, who was a Marxist, put it poignantly: 1 pondered...how men fight and lose the battle, and the thing that they fought for comes about in spite of their defeat, and when it comes turns out not to be what they meant, and other men have to fight for what they meant under another name."

Many people think there was an element of this in Mrs Thatcher's reign. Certainly Thatcher did adopt - in the interests of capitalism - a fai more radical posture towards the British civil service and ol boy network establishment than any Labour Prime Minister had ever done. Thatcher was, in this view a legatee of British radicalism.

And now, we are told, comes classless, one-nation John Major, beneficiary of "Thatcher's Revolution".

That's the official propaganda line anyway. And what a lot of balderdash it is, as was shown in last Sunday's Independent. They investigated the background of the chief members of the Major gang and found a cluster of well off former presidents of the Cambridge University union -even that other showpiece Thatcherite plebian KennethClarke!

Still, we will be hearing a lot in the months to come about the classlessness of the galloping Major. Tain rom is tre amden library, 4 December.

reading from his first novel "Redemption", , a book that identifies Trotskyism with religion.

Tariq, of course, has spent much of his life in and around would-be Trotskyist groups, mainly the IMG.

The book's author claims that he "holds up a mirror to the far left". but what is reflected there is just his own confused past, with its ab surd central belief that Stalinist tyranny was incipiently socialist and politically criminal stupidities like Ali and his friends standing as joke "Socialist Unity" candidates against Labour in the watershed 1979 general election.

When asked by a rather mild mannered SO reader if he saw this irony in his "satirical" work, Tariq Ali said he refused to answer this question "because it was asked by a Trotskyite".

His book, you see, is "an elegy for a movement the time of which has come," (sic); this movement is not only Trotskyism but the entire tradition of the 1917 Russian Revolution.

He got very angry when asked if he was still a socialist and made a dire threat: he'd put the SO reader in the next edition of his novel.

Second edition? The novel is a bit of a flop, it seems. Only 7 people turned out to hear him, and some of those seemed only to be escaping the cold night outside. Good! Adam Novak from Prague he Czech press is still full of the recent visit of US President George Bush and his domination of the 17 November commemoration on Wenceslas Square, scene of the demonstrations a year ago that forced the Stalinist bureaucracy to share power with Civic Forum and Public Against Large sections of the population, however, continue to feel that the promises of a year ago have not been fulfilled. An open letter by student leaders of last year's events called on people not to celebrate November 17, saying that the revolution has been blocked by bureaucrats still in place. The only critical demonstrations held were called by small groups, under an effective press black-out on their activity.

The far right Assembly for the Republic organised their demonstration in the middle of the crowds come to hear Havel and Bush. They tried to polarise those present by forcing their way to the front barrier in a 3,000-strong crowd, calling on Havel to resign, and carrying banners equating Civic Forum to the Communist Party, and condemning the "puppet the democracy Communist-dissident elite."

The danger is that the Republicans remain the largest group openly criticising the monetarist, neoliberal reform programme of Federal Finance Minister Vaclav Klaus. They condemn the old-new bureaucracy in clear, militant language.

The most successful left counter-demonstration was called by two Prague anarchist groups. About 250 people, overwhelmingly high school students and apprentices, marched through the side streets of Prague, defying confused and unprepared police and Civic Forum officials to stop them, before marching through the crowd on Wenceslas Square waving black flags and chanting "Yankee go home". They handed out leaflets condemning the new political elite as a group of bureaucrats concerited mainly with transforming themselves into capitalists, on the basis of connections and wealth built up under the old regime.

A very small, poorly organised demonstration was staged on National Boulevard tellectual left coalition of about 100 people inside Civic Forum, including MP Petr Uhl and Egon Bondy, a dissident poet popular among young workers. Apart from issuing a fortnightly journal, Polarita, with a circulation of several thousand, this group is not very active.

Left Alternative reached ublic attention only recent y, when Vaclav Klaus attempted to secure his position in Civic Forum by (unsuccessfully) trying to expel ment, poverty and homelessness. them. Their journal remains, however, the only left forum open to all non-Stalinist left currents to the left of the social democrats, to those unable to accept the domination of ex- (and not so ex-) members of the Communist Party in most of the left opposition groups. Polarita has recently agreed to carry regular articles from the Club for Popular SelfManagement, in an attempt to develop a discussion on alternative forms of economic management.

The newly formed Campaign for the Rights of Youth, a militant anti-Stalinist anti-capitalist youth campaign, started by high school students close to Left Alternative, launched an 11 point charter for the rights of youth at an open air meeting (about 70 strong) addressed by Petr Uhl, who spoke about his involvement revolutionary youth politics as a young teacher in 1968-9.

The Campaign's charter demands basic rights - a job, education, somewhere to live, an end to racism, sexual discrimination and antihomosexual discrimination, and links a rejection of the market reforms with a call for popular control over the economy.

"Why should the workers and youth pay for the economic mistakes of the old regime, and make industrial capacity more attractive for foreign capital through unemployment and price rises.:.?

Government promises that every citizen will have the same chance in the privatisation process are ridiculous. Which shop assistant will be able to buy the shop where she works, under the conditions set by the government? The only people who can contemplate buying are the top figures of the black market, ex- and current bureaucrats and foreigners... The economy will be governed by a smaller and smaller number of monopolies. Artificially high prices will become common practice. Volkswagen wants to buy 75% of Skoda, Tomas Bata might be given the Svit shoe factories in Zlin back. The result of this kind of privatisation will be that Czechoslovakia becomes an economic colony of Germany and other countries."

Towards capitalism or workers' liberty!

The largest group on the non-Communist left, the Social Democratic Party (CSSD), played no role in the anniversary events. The CSSD had, until recently, made its name as the most anti-communist party of the left, some branches even refusing to accept as individual members those who had once been in the Communist Party. The CSSD's recent move away from anti-communism may be due to their declining fortunes, and their difficulties in establishing themselves as the 'centre party with a social conscience' a country where most parties claim the centre, and where there also exist the Socialist and National Social Parties, struggireformist positisame centreCSSD has already agreed to merge with Obroda, a group claiming the heritage of the Prague Spring Communist Party leadership, and ideologically close to Alexander Dubcek, the leading figure of the Communist Party in 1968.

Given the depths of the economic crisis, however, the CSSD and Obroda have found it difficult to explain exactly how they would pursue a less harsh path than the government. They continue to pursue their goal of a Swedish/ Austrian-style society, but their political proposals are exceedingly moderate. They seem to face the same internal problems of disillusionment and lack of vision of all the left groups, and have failed to regain Social Democracy's traditional support among the skilled workers. They seem to have no more than a few thousand active members.

The left demonstrations received little strong positive support, and little outright hostility.

Left groups opposing the market reforms and the old bureaucracy clearly have a place in Czech politics, and an audience, if only they can get their message across better, and make some proposals lying together a coalition of those adversely affected by the government's reforms.

November 17 1990 was a step in the right direction.

Eastern Europe. 60p plus 32p SE15 4NA

----- pull-quotes -----

GORBY'S as much as 'Ma

EASTERN EUROPE

rostage from SO, PO Box

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 469

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →