Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Why different campaigns on ti

Socialist Organiser no. 468, 30 November 1990 · scan p. 14 · Colin Foster · about 664 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 14

expectancy. Just as importantly, investigation into factors such as smoking and poor diet indicate that these are intricately linked with poverty and can not be used as an excuse for the low health standards of the poor.

* The Black Report on socioeconomic inequalities in health 10 years on' • George Davey Smith, Mel Bartley, David Blane. British Medical Journal, vol 301, 18-25 August 1990"

Is many people will their dismay on the demonstration against wa in the Gulf last Saturday, 24th, there are three rival campaigns on this issue.

They have real differences politics and orientation. The Campaign Against War in the Gulf calls for US and British troops out of the Gulf, opposes the Iraqi invasion of Kuwait and orients to the labour movement.

The Ad Hoc Committee calls for troops out, but aiso positively supports Irag, and orients to left grouplets and unorganised youth.

The Committee to Stop War in the Gulf calls for "no war" (but not for troops out), and appeals primarily to CND, Greens, Plaid Cymru, and church groups.

Such differences are predictable, perhaps inevitable, given the state of the left. But why are they not expressed as different emphases and preferences within a united campaign? Why is there not even a liaison committee of the three campaigns to organise joint activities?

Part of the answer lies in this: each campaign has political groups at its core. The pro-Iraq Ad Hoc Committee has the Revolutionary Communist Party.

The Campaign, has Socialist Organiser and Socialist Outlook.

And what about the Committee?

It is the organisers of the Committee who have been the most determindedly divisive. Their differences with the "Campaign' are merely tactical (no war means inevitably troops Action.

Although very small, Socialist Action has been sufficiently well-placed to play a big part in shaping the Committee's stance of stubborn non-cooperation with the Campaign.

It has, in effect, been the major force on the left campaigning against "troops out of the Gulf', and for economic sanctions against Iraq.

Doubtless Socialist Action's arguments on their own do not carry much weight. They have had weight because they chime in with the more diffuse influence of the fragments of the CP and sections of the Labour left traditionally closeto the CP. But weight they hav had.

Well of course, that's a shame, you may say, but what can you do about it? Politics is politics: and there are serious differences dividing the Committee. All you can hope do is get unity in action; though, you may, on the evidence, be inclined to add, Socialist Action could try to be a bit less divisive and 'sectarian' in their prosecution of the cause of their own "softer' position on the Gulf.

You could say that, but you'd be way off beam: Socialist Action's own position — the position of its magazine — are the politics of the semiloony Ad Hoc Committee who couldn't give a damn what Saddam does to Kuwait as long as he opposes 'imperialism'.

But the CPs, as far as I know, never went so far as to organise a campaign supporting economic sanctions agianst the Socialist Action's magazine explains their two-faced politics on this (as on almost everything these days) as resistance to 'ultra-leftism'. 'Fake ultraleftism consists in refusal to support semi-colonial countries in struggles with imperialism (and) another form of ultraleftism... is the refusal to see the need to fight against imperialist wars alongside pacifists..' What Socialist Action has taken over most fundamentally from the CP tradition is manipulative politics — the idea that instead of arguing straightforwardly, political activists should talk out of both sides of their mouths, and cynically use catchwords which they privately condemn in the hope that they will manoeuvre people towards desired conclusions. It is the same method used by most of the lef on the issue of the European Community over the last 20 years, only much cruder and more blatant.

----- pull-quotes -----

LEFT PRESIS A have found out to

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 468

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →